Sid does NOT 'deserve' the punch, no way!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

pooja

@pooja_j

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

Topicmaker --- i disagree wid u,,its not only riddhima's duty to tel him the truth but sid's duty also after all it was Sid's paln to hide truth frm him. even i feel riddhima's also deserves a slap...
how can they both play wid his feelings,one thing tat riddhima did was rite is to tel him the truth and sid not even dare....

Quote

Rashmi

@Rush_25

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

It is Riddhima's right and duty to tell Armaan the truth...certainly not sid's!

So agree with this one!!! Sid need not say anything or even help him!!! 😡😡!!!! I would say punch him back and say" where were u when Ridzy was dying??""

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

dua_44ever

@dua_44ever

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

I appreciate your topic!
I just have one question. Is this topic written from an objective angle or did you actually really put yourself in Armaan's shoes and felt his pain?

Not trying to cause arguments here... just a simple question! 😊

No offence intended.

Quote

Wrackspurt

@Wrackspurt

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#14

Yeah Sid does not deserve the punch..........its true Armaan is heartbroken......his castle of dreams have come crashing down.....but i dont think any person in Armaan's position will have behaved like that....it was like some small kid punching someone because they took away his favourite toy.......surely Armaan is a bit mature than that......i expected him to be upset, or even confronting Sid and Ridz as to why he had been kept in dark......but without resorting to violence.

Quote

pooja

@pooja_j

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: aishu_25
<font color="#0000ff">It is Riddhima's right and duty to tell Armaan
the truth...certainly not sid's!

So agree with this one!!! Sid need not say anything or even help him!!! 😡😡!!!! I would say punch him back and say" where were u when Ridzy was dying??""
</font>

Excuse me... she was ready to tel him the truth but ur dear sid stopped her....
anyways wat u hav done if u hav been in armaan's place??? its not a joke tat u r playing wid sumone's feelings.......

Quote

Sadie.Saxton

@Sadie.Saxton

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#16

Armaan thought of him as a friend, someone to lean on... not someone who would lie to him...
Sid is the only one who Armaan befriended upon coming back, and even he lied (or kept the truth) from Armaan.
He let Armaan make a mockery of himself, and if he wanted to he had many chances to come out and tell Armaan he is Riddhima's husband without all the drama.

Quote

hope4u

@hope4u

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#17

i just saw the precap since its created so much waves on the forum..
anyway, i think armaan is totally justified here.. Any man with an ounce of pride will react the way armaan did..he has been ruthlessly played, his love, friendship and all emotions have been ridiculed. his frustration and anger is justified.
as for sid deserving the punch..he does..he deserves it. You're right when you say its in riddhima's place to tell the truth.. But sid, in his own way formed a bond with armaan and he was not true to it.. Maybe he had his own shackles binding him, but then all of them do.. Armaan does not deserve what is happening to him, riddhima doesn't completely either..similarly, sid's situation can also be argued and justified in both ways..

In sid's defence, he is being a man and taking the blow.. even after being punched, he's going to armaan to justify.. Its coming at a late stage, but he is at least trying to make amends..

Quote

mithilalovesksg

@mithilalovesksg

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 15 years ago

#18

well i think he deserve this as he literally played with armaan feelings knowing how much he loves her

rids would have told armaan before if sid would have not stop her

my view

those who think armaan should have talk with sid bt at prsent he has lost fait in every relationship either love or freindship

Quote

xEternalLovex

@xEternalLovex

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#19

I'm an AR fan, but I agree with most the stuff you said.

Armaan is in a really bad situation right now, and no doubt all of them are. I guess this action was not expected (atleast by me) from Armaan. His character stands much more than this..Sid didn't deserve the punch, nope, not at all.

Ridhima SHOULD have told Armaan, I highly feel it was her duty to tell him as she would probably be the only one who could've handled him. She should've said it, then this situation would never have occured. But, I still do feel that Sid shouldn't have hidden the truth from Armaan either, as Armaan thought he was his friend and made him meet Ridhima. But the good thing about Sid is that he DID try to get AR united again but he was testing Ridhima to see who she loved..and well, he shouldn't have hiddent the truth from his mum either.

There are surely other ways to sort this situation out, but punching was really unexpected and wrong. Violence is not always the answer.

Hope I didn't offend anyone. :)

Peace Out xx

Quote

naureen

@Norz

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#20

well armaan many times told in front of sid that thanks 4 taking care of MY RIDDHIMA he also had express serval times how much he loves HER more then sid

it was an duty of sid to tell him that she is married now or atleast have let riddhima to tell him

when all those promises were going on SID was keeping quiet

why the hell he was quiet and letting ur wife to go through such pain and even when armaan was putting mangalsuter he was quiet ALL THE TIME it was riddhima who has to take the step

when u r angry or u r betrayed by ur frd its in nature in human that u raised ur hand

the way armaan was treated in hospital that way also not deserving