Sid does NOT 'deserve' the punch, no way! - Page 7

Originally posted by: Ramy25

Wow! how very easy it is for some to put the blame on someone and say that he "deserves" that punishment...that he "deserves" to bleed his mouth...that he "deserves" to be hit?.

How very easy, isn't it?


Sid does NOT "deserve" the punch...or the bleeding! Why should he?

ok yeah he hid the truth from Armaan.....SO WHAT?

It is Riddhima's right and duty to tell Armaan the truth...certainly not sid's!


I'm not saying that Armaan's anger is wrong......His anger , his frustration and his rage is totally justified!

Armaan had the right to know the truth about Riddhima's current status...he didn't have to be ridiculed in front of the hospital...he does not deserve such a heartbreak....No way!

there is no way that one can compare the pain and heartbreak between the Three! all of them are going through a lot....all of them have been wronged...and all of them need to talk things out!


So kindly stop saying that Sid "deserves" the punch..or that he "deserves" more because that certainly isn't going to make any of us love Sid any less...instead that might just make people LOVE him more.


No one "deserves" to be beaten or to be "punched" in the face! NO ONE!

At bolded part:
Knowing the truth n lieing is a crime, but hiding the truth is just a big of a crime!
Sid is just as much responsible for Armaan's conditon just as much Riddhima is! He hid the truth, but not just that pretended to be a friend and Armaan told him all his feelings, still he didn't utter a word! Armaan told he love story infront of everyone BECAUSE of Sid's mom... he was making right a fool of himself, STILL Sid didn't say anything!

He deserved the punch, if not MORE!

AGREE! :)) Sid does not deserve a punch..& he was bleedin..

Originally posted by: 1994

Exactly what I feel....

Sid doesn't ''deserve'' to be punched because he was the one who gave Riddhima the freedom to choose her love and he could,obviously,have not told Armaan himself..

It was Riddhima's duty to tell him the truth and to decide whom she loved...

Agreed that Armaan was angry but the anger could have been taken out in a better way...it wasn't necessary to fight physically....

The main reason to do this all was for his Mom. He said "Isi bahanay tumhain mouqa mil jayega ke tum kisko pasand karti ho"
So hurting someone else deeply in the heart just because of ur mom or dad is deserved to be beaten or at all he deserved something more than that...

guys it seem most of u dun know what is relationship. when riddhima is not happy thn how can she live wth sidz itz better she understand armaan and go back in armaan life. becaz all the way armaan desrves her.

Originally posted by: doukno

No!!!!!!Sid does'nt deserve the punch..........He and Armaan need to hve a heart to heart talk and sort things out.

i agree sid does not deserve a punch. noboby has a right 2 hit anyone.

If I were Armaan I wouldv'e punched Sid too, he knew all this time but lied to him, played with his feeling's alongside with Riddhima. They made a fool out of Armaan, made him dream and believe just to crush them later, infront of everyone...

Originally posted by: dikshasharma

i agree sid does not deserve a punch. noboby has a right 2 hit anyone.

Originally posted by: choco_pie92

i completely disagree

if i would be in armaan's place i would also do the same.....if someone played with ur feelings...what would u do...sit like n idol....i cant do that atleast......sid deserved the punch...even riddhima deserves one slap...
any sensible human being will do that

my view