Polygamy, TRPs, self censorship & more......

Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
So I dont watch Indian shows. No not because I am a snob, I used to watch all Doordarshan shows. Just that my tolerance limit to bull shit is extremely low hence dont watch any shows post DD era. Watched only 1 Indian show & that too only for the hero. Now watching another which started out as a thriller but now neither here nor there. But then I digress...

The reason for gate crashing into your forum is slightly different. So there was a click bait article in IF which I unfortunately opened & literally fainted on reading the content. Thought I misunderstood & did some WIKIing & GOOGLEing about this show. I am sorry some of the stuff I read make me literally puke. While i understand tat this show is a TV version of a stupid bolly movie even in bollywood where the stupidity level is astronomical they showed the surrogate finally making a dignified exit & the childless couple getting a Happily Ever After. Then y is this show deviating from that plot.

You can ask me what business is it of mine to talk bt a show which I dont even watch. But dont u think we women should raise our voice against such nonsense be it reel or real. Yeah may be wasting energy on fictional shows & characters might b silly but dont they say that ART is a MIRROR of the society we live in. Which brings me to the next point. I ve been reading about many shows which were shut down in the past few weeks due to low TRPs. Can someone then explain to me how this shit is still managing to survive.

Does this mean Indian TV audience really like stuff like what is shown in this serial. Some of the updates I read on this very forum made me cringe. I was revolted by those stuff. Then who are these viewers who actually watch this kinda stuff. I dont think any guy will watch this crap. Anyway most of the soaps are watched by women. Then how can women actually like such plots. Seriously is this how Indian women think & feel. I am unable 2 digest this fact. I remember reading articles which said that the more the FL cries & is tortured more the TRPs. So r Indian TV audience esp the women sadistic that they like stories which make the FL suffer, get humiliated, ill treated, abused & what not

What kinda message are we trying to give via such shows.

My intention is not to hurt this show's fans or start any fan wars. I was genuinely curious about all the above points that I mentioned. Hence this post. Hoping to see a healthy discussion & want the show's fans to share their honest opinion.

The reason y I am asking this is why blame the PH & actors if we the public are actually watching such crap thus encouraging them to continue with this crapfest.
Edited by Angels11 - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.3k

Users

10

Likes

139

Frequent Posters

Kallol012 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Angels11

So I dont watch Indian shows. No not because I am a snob, I used to watch all Doordarshan shows. Just that my tolerance limit to bull shit is extremely low hence dont watch any shows post DD era. Watched only 1 Indian show & that too only for the hero. Now watching another which started out as a thriller but now neither here nor there. But then I digress...

The reason for gate crashing into your forum is slightly different. So there was a click bait article in IF which I unfortunately opened & literally fainted on reading the content. Thought I misunderstood & did some WIKIing & GOOGLEing about this show. I am sorry some of the stuff I read make me literally puke. While i understand tat this show is a TV version of a stupid bolly movie even in bollywood where the stupidity level is astronomical they showed the surrogate finally making a dignified exit & the childless couple getting a Happily Ever After. Then y is this show deviating from that plot.

You can ask me what business is it of mine to talk bt a show which I dont even watch. But dont u think we women should raise our voice against such nonsense be it reel or real. Yeah may be wasting energy on fictional shows & characters might b silly but dont they say that ART is a MIRROR of the society we live in. Which brings me to the next point. I ve been reading about many shows which were shut down in the past few weeks due to low TRPs. Can someone then explain to me how this shit is still managing to survive.

Does this mean Indian TV audience really like stuff like what is shown in this serial. Some of the updates I read on this very forum made me cringe. I was revolted by those stuff. Then who are these viewers who actually watch this kinda stuff. I dont think any guy will watch this crap. Anyway most of the soaps are watched by women. Then how can women actually like such plots. Seriously is this how Indian women think & feel. I am unable 2 digest this fact. I remember reading articles which said that the more the FL cries & is tortured more the TRPs. So r Indian TV audience esp the women sadistic that they like stories which make the FL suffer, get humiliated, ill treated, abused & what not

What kinda message are we trying to give via such shows.

My intention is not to hurt this show's fans or start any fan wars. I was genuinely curious about all the above points that I mentioned. Hence this post. Hoping to see a healthy discussion & want the show's fans to share their honest opinion.

The reason y I am asking this is why blame the PH & actors if we the public are actually watching such crap thus encouraging them to continue with this crapfest.


I agree to each and every of your words.
Let me do some explanation

In india TV shows are judged by trp method; a quantitative approach that counts the time people all over the country spend on the show time on the channel

More trp means the show is popular and it means the advertisement slot that show has will bring more money to the channel

so channels are ready to go to any limit to achieve higher trps. they don't care whether the show carries a message or not, even they don't care the show is regressive and society spoiler or not. many shows with good content has been taken off air for not being failed to provide the trp the channel want from it. as an example, this same channel recently decided to take off air another very good show, the most expensive show in india right now, a mythological series named "karmafal data shani"

yes art is a mirror of the society. in the same way art of a soceity also affects the society. people here does not like to accept knowledge. people here don't understand the good contents because among the viewers who appreciate good contents and understands them are few in numbers and they can not provide some big trp figures. Thats why very sensible shows like Mere sai(religious), Porus(historical), Prithvi Vallabh(historical), Yeh uun dino ki baat hai(the story of old days), mahakali(mythology) or laado(women rights) don't get good trps they deserve.

TV is dominated by some utterly non sense shows here

women are the main trp provider for the shows, as young generation does not like these family melodrama, saas bahu sagas or overacting based pseudo mystery shows.


this Dil se dil tak (i rather name it SSST) survives because it is selling some kind of cheap entertainment like cheap fast food which is temporarily alluring, but leaves bad impression on mind(which majority of the viewers don't care or don't understand). they love to watch something hot and spicy.

and the most important thing i think, viewers here in the society are not matured enough to give importance to a sensible show.

The matters are so huge and in depth that it is tough to explain everything.
you can go through this if you find it interesting.

https://www.quora.com/Why-do-Indian-TV-serials-suck

thank you.

Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Thanks dear. So basically these saas bahu serials are watched not by young genx but old folks who prefer kitchen politics. But I am still puzzled. If tat is the case should they not actually support the wife & not the "OTHER WOMAN" 😕 Then how come this track is getting TRPs. These sanskari TV watching folks should oppose this concept of polygamy na...
ruhi86 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
You are right about this show, but it isn't for logical people. It is for people who think women who can't have kids are worthless and they deserve all the pain in this world. It reduces women to child bearing machine, there is no career ambition no set respect, no dignity, nothing...
As a fan of internationally recognised shows like Game of Thrones, Homeland, Castle, The Good Wife etc, I feel these kind of Indian shows drag us Indian women centuries behind in the name of entertainment. All the international shows, be it Turkish, Korean, women are always strong and fighting for their rights, but here women are nothing but slaves. It's beyond disgusting.
Edited by ruhi86 - 7 years ago
Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ruhi86

You were eight bye this show isn't for logical people. It is for people who think women who can't have kids are worthless and they deserve all the pain in this world. It reduces women to child bearing machine, there is no career ambition no set respect, no dignity, nothing...
As a fan of internationally recognised shows like Game of Thrones, Homeland, Castle, The Good Wife etc, I feel these kind of Indian shows drag us Indian women centuries behind in the name of entertainment. All the international shows, be it Turkish, Korean, women are always strong and fighting for their rights, but here women are nothing but slaves. It's beyond disgusting.



THIS _/\_ I posted something similar on another thread as well. In India which is gng 2 bloody overtake China in population, infertility is a big deal. Jeezzz. Even I am a working mother. I had some difficulties but luckily conceived naturally. But I know countless women who suffer through painful IVF treatments. Yes I love being a mother. I cant imagine a life without my angel. Its been 8 yrs & I still remember the 1st time I held her in my hand. God its a divine feeling. BUT at the same time Indians should stop torturing women if they dont ve kids. You are right. We are not baby making machines. Appalled to c such a sensitive topic like Infertility, IVF, Surrogacy being handled in such a horrible manner.

It gives such a wrong message. All half baked ideas to a country where literacy level is still low. Its v dangerous. Instead of creating awareness these ppl r sending wrong message by making a surrogate as "THE OTHER WOMEN". DISGUSTING!
Kallol012 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ruhi86

You are right about this show, but it isn't for logical people. It is for people who think women who can't have kids are worthless and they deserve all the pain in this world. It reduces women to child bearing machine, there is no career ambition no set respect, no dignity, nothing...
As a fan of internationally recognised shows like Game of Thrones, Homeland, Castle, The Good Wife etc, I feel these kind of Indian shows drag us Indian women centuries behind in the name of entertainment. All the international shows, be it Turkish, Korean, women are always strong and fighting for their rights, but here women are nothing but slaves. It's beyond disgusting.


exactly. in indian shows women actually has nothing to do except wrecking havoc in the house by evil politics. even the men also has nothing to do get busy. most of the serial's family are infinitely wealthy, hardship never comes to their business, they always get whatever they want, they spend all time and efforts the beat the hell out of one another. perfect ideal condition of s***
Kallol012 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Angels11

Thanks dear. So basically these saas bahu serials are watched not by young genx but old folks who prefer kitchen politics. But I am still puzzled. If tat is the case should they not actually support the wife & not the "OTHER WOMAN" 😕 Then how come this track is getting TRPs. These sanskari TV watching folks should oppose this concept of polygamy na...


that temporarily alluring contents, spicy hot entertainment. same old sh** in new package
once i read in marketing studies that nothing sells better than s**
and also because women here enjoys kitchen politics, they get excited to watch someone wrecking havoc by her politics, quarrel over a pice of spoon .
Kallol012 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Angels11



THIS _/\_ I posted something similar on another thread as well. In India which is gng 2 bloody overtake China in population, infertility is a big deal. Jeezzz. Even I am a working mother. I had some difficulties but luckily conceived naturally. But I know countless women who suffer through painful IVF treatments. Yes I love being a mother. I cant imagine a life without my angel. Its been 8 yrs & I still remember the 1st time I held her in my hand. God its a divine feeling. BUT at the same time Indians should stop torturing women if they dont ve kids. You are right. We are not baby making machines. Appalled to c such a sensitive topic like Infertility, IVF, Surrogacy being handled in such a horrible manner.

It gives such a wrong message. All half baked ideas to a country where literacy level is still low. Its v dangerous. Instead of creating awareness these ppl r sending wrong message by making a surrogate as "THE OTHER WOMEN". DISGUSTING!


hate this absolutely. in some other serial of this channel they said reproduction is not the actual meaning of marriage, but here they are showing that, you are infertile, so your husband should marry a surrogate. omfg
Angels11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Just wondering. Suppose Surrogate # 1 dies or due 2 some reason she is unable 2 conceive will this loser family bring Surrogate # 2 for Surrogate # 1. And Biwi # 1 will do seva to both S1 & S2.

Hubby 1 = H1
Biwi 1 = B1
Surrogate 1 = S1
Surrogate 2 = S2

H1 + B1 + S1 + S2 = DILCHASP RISHTA Ta Da Slow claps 👏
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
I want sumeet mittal to get married to outside woman then I will like to c whether Shashi mittal accept threesome in her life

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".