Sia should file for divorce now!!!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

1.5k

Users

10

Likes

69

Frequent Posters

tanvi1512 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
There really are a lot of legal problems in this show. Like when Jahnvi became Sia, it was just random. Dr. Rana said that the reason she picked the name Sia was that it was the first name that popped in her head. She really has no legal proof that she is Sia. And if she does file for divorce, she would have to admit that her name is Jahnvi right? Because technically, Sia doesn't exist. Sia has no ID, no family to back her up. So I think theres going to be a lot of legal problems that turn up during the show. And i'm absolutely NOT looking forward to it. 😔
FeistyQueen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
i agree with u !
bt this lie has put viraj in a fix!
now he has to come out of his act as he being dead is frustrating him!
this can help in making others know viraj's true face
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
Exactly I agree taniyaharshu. She should really file for divorce. It's the next step really to making sure V can't stake claims on her. And I say stake because for V she's just a property.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
One thing, though - I want Sia to do this openly & cleanly - revert to her original name of Jhanvi and then do the getting rid of Viraj. Just b'cos she keeps her name Jhanvi doesn't mean that she has to be Viraj's doormat - she can still divorce him, marry Raghav & go on w/ life. I want this schizophrenic portrayal of wussy Jhanvi/strong Sia to end. I want the Sharma family back, I want the real Sia - Jhanvi's sister - back. Just drop this inane 'I am Sia, not Jhanvi' business, and replace it w/ a 'I am a strong Jhanvi, not a pushover Jhanvi'. This is not Clark Kent/Superman, Bruce Wayne/Batman, Peter Parker/Spiderman or Prince Adam/He-Man: Jhanvi doesn't magically go from being one person to another.

They can start w/ a new interesting story. Just the romance won't be that interesting, since Sriti ain't exactly Drashti Dhami - what marks her more is her skill in transforming herself to different roles, which they haven't used much to date in this serial. But that's her USP. They can, in a post Viraj scenario, make it a combo of RaghaVi romance, family dynamics (maybe involving Krish), etc. Maybe bring in another guy after Viraj is gone, and make him a bone of contention b/w Taashu and the original Siya, thereby spicing it up & making it somewhat interesting. There are a lot of things they could do to make the show interesting after a point.
Taniya20 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: tanvi1512

There really are a lot of legal problems in this show. Like when Jahnvi became Sia, it was just random. Dr. Rana said that the reason she picked the name Sia was that it was the first name that popped in her head. She really has no legal proof that she is Sia. And if she does file for divorce, she would have to admit that her name is Jahnvi right? Because technically, Sia doesn't exist. Sia has no ID, no family to back her up. So I think theres going to be a lot of legal problems that turn up during the show. And i'm absolutely NOT looking forward to it. 😔



She told Raghav that she is Jhanvi right? Yes to gain something, she has to face the world. She also doesn't want to hide from the world... Viraj making her like that...

She can file for Divorce as Jhanvi only... What happens if she come in front of the world as Jhanvi... Her family already knew about it... Only people that doesn't know is Singh family... They will definitely understand her once the truth comes out...
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

One thing, though - I want Sia to do this openly & cleanly - revert to her original name of Jhanvi and then do the getting rid of Viraj. Just b'cos she keeps her name Jhanvi doesn't mean that she has to be Viraj's doormat - she can still divorce him, marry Raghav & go on w/ life. I want this schizophrenic portrayal of wussy Jhanvi/strong Sia to end. I want the Sharma family back, I want the real Sia - Jhanvi's sister - back. Just drop this inane 'I am Sia, not Jhanvi' business, and replace it w/ a 'I am a strong Jhanvi, not a pushover Jhanvi'. This is not Clark Kent/Superman, Bruce Wayne/Batman, Peter Parker/Spiderman or Prince Adam/He-Man: Jhanvi doesn't magically go from being one person to another.


They can start w/ a new interesting story. Just the romance won't be that interesting, since Sriti ain't exactly Drashti Dhami - what marks her more is her skill in transforming herself to different roles, which they haven't used much to date in this serial. But that's her USP. They can, in a post Viraj scenario, make it a combo of RaghaVi romance, family dynamics (maybe involving Krish), etc. Maybe bring in another guy after Viraj is gone, and make him a bone of contention b/w Taashu and the original Siya, thereby spicing it up & making it somewhat interesting. There are a lot of things they could do to make the show interesting after a point.

Now you remind me of our convos in Rakt Sambandh. 😛
The Sia/Jhanvi drama is getting too much for me. It's almost as if she's two personalities in one. Why can't she just become Jhanvi again? Why can't she just tell the family the truth instead of this fake marriage act?
As for future tracks, they can always try something that is tried and tested and proven to be a success where Jhanvi actually does marry Raghav and then they face problems after marriage.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: khota_sikka_sri

Now you remind me of our convos in Rakt Sambandh. 😛
The Sia/Jhanvi drama is getting too much for me. It's almost as if she's two personalities in one. Why can't she just become Jhanvi again? Why can't she just tell the family the truth instead of this fake marriage act?
As for future tracks, they can always try something that is tried and tested and proven to be a success where Jhanvi actually does marry Raghav and then they face problems after marriage.


Shreya

You too bring back those memories of RS. 😍

In her earlier avatars, Sudha/Devika and Sandhya/Vrinda made sense - in the first, she was suffering from Dissociative Identity Disorder, while in the latter, she was doing a con job on her murderous sasural. So it was fun watching that. But here, the 'Sia' role only made sense as long as Viraj knew nothing about it. The moment he did, it was worthless retaining that identity. People go w/ hidden identities to protect themselves from an assailant or stalker, but the moment that mask is removed from the main person they're protecting against, it becomes worthless. If Viraj knows that Sia is Jhanvi, what's the point of telling the whole world that she is Sia?

As for future tracks, as far as RaghaVi go, they have 2 choices. They could make it romantic, in which case, like I suggested, they ought to mix it up w/ other events like I suggested. Another thing they could do - they could just make it about RaghaVi, but in such a case, it would be good to show Jhanvi having difficulty adjusting to a second marriage given her abused past, maybe as a highlight that this is how DV victims have trouble adjusting when they marry again.

I have a hunch that the former is likely to be more interesting to the public than the latter. But I'd be fine w/ whichever way they choose to go.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Shreya

You too bring back those memories of RS. 😍

In her earlier avatars, Sudha/Devika and Sandhya/Vrinda made sense - in the first, she was suffering from Dissociative Identity Disorder, while in the latter, she was doing a con job on her murderous sasural. So it was fun watching that. But here, the 'Sia' role only made sense as long as Viraj knew nothing about it. The moment he did, it was worthless retaining that identity. People go w/ hidden identities to protect themselves from an assailant or stalker, but the moment that mask is removed from the main person they're protecting against, it becomes worthless. If Viraj knows that Sia is Jhanvi, what's the point of telling the whole world that she is Sia?

As for future tracks, as far as RaghaVi go, they have 2 choices. They could make it romantic, in which case, like I suggested, they ought to mix it up w/ other events like I suggested. Another thing they could do - they could just make it about RaghaVi, but in such a case, it would be good to show Jhanvi having difficulty adjusting to a second marriage given her abused past, maybe as a highlight that this is how DV victims have trouble adjusting when they marry again.

I have a hunch that the former is likely to be more interesting to the public than the latter. But I'd be fine w/ whichever way they choose to go.

Exactly. Once Viraj found her, the first step she should have taken is to tell the family the truth about Viraj. None of this would have happened if she had taken this logical step.
Well the latter is more logical if they want to stick to the social message of the show, but then that depends on them.
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

no offence, but dis is d very 1st time i saw Vrish drooling ...😲🤣🤣

LMAO..i mean seriously, i always felt he was so serious in his opinions, but good 2 see d chupa rustam wid a dreamy emo...🤣🤣

381490 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: .Vrish.


They can show RaghaVi peacefully marrying and then show a process of recovery, if they want to go the DV route. I'd prefer that they not make it a saas bahu show. If they want to, they can retain Viraj as an external threat, but keep moving the story. Ideally, at some point, they have to jail Viraj if he continues to stalk Jhanvi.

At some point, once they let go of Viraj, they can bring back the Sharmas as well as the real Sia, and maybe have her & Taashu fighting over the same guy. That sorta thing, thereby splitting Raghav's family, depending on POV. There are quite a few things they could do to keep the show interesting in a post Viraj era. It doesn't have to automatically end the day Viraj is gone.

Word, Vrish. I mentioned this in another thread that the story doesn't end with V's fall. It's like the writers fail to see what potential all the other characters hold, and the very stories that can be intertwined here. Forget Sharmas and Taashu and just look at Gayatri -- the woman's got issues. Like V, she's got a need for perfection and order and she did favor Dev as her son. How long will she accept rugged Raghav without demanding that he fit into her image of a perfect son?
Komal is another matter. Here, they could even draw in the original theme of the show, as in DV, by revealing some secret from her past and her relationship to Dev. They'd already set the foundation for it -- her strange detachment at the mention of his name, Krish's odd drawing of his father and his nightmare and his muteness. They could dig in the family's closets and find the skeletons, reveal them -- maybe even add Raghav in the mix and show how he was involved in Dev's supposed "accident". There's isn't just one type of abuse, the physical one. If Dev abused Komal, it could've been emotional and verbal.
Even Sundar, Unniyal, and Shekhawat hold potential. They could change the entire mood of the show, go for a dirty underworld environment -- since Gayatri obviously holds power and has made enemies in Gurgaon -- like they did with Laagi Tujhse Lagan on Colors.
Point is that ALL characters and their stories/potential is on hold, so that V can continue to dominate. At some point, people will grow tired of watching him. He doesn't have any relationship to anyone. It's like watching a loner in his room for 20 minutes every day.
Like you said, there's even Sia's psychological journey. Marital rape and DV leaves scars. Deep scars. Do the writers/people really think that after marriage she'd move right ahead without any fears or emotional difficulties? I don't even think she'd be able to let Raghav touch her. THAT is a huge challenge for a victim like her. In addition to that, she's got a whole healing process still head that was entirely skipped due to V's quick treasure hunt of Jahnvi in Gurgaon.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".