Enough is enough!!!!!!!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.6k

Users

19

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

sia221 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: .Vrish.




Both of them had good arguments, but in the real story, Mahadev was a lot more intransigent than what was shown here. Vinayak never had any idea that he was dealing w/ his father, since his mom never told him who his father is. Mahadev did find out that he was dealing w/ his son, but made it an ego war w/ Parvati.

However, showing Vinayak as itching for a fight and then being the first to hurl is club was downright defamation. The two of them did confront, and neither tried to reason w/ the other. Here, they showed everybody trying to reason w/ him, whereas in the real story, while he did do that to Brahma, truth is that the ganas tried to forcibly remove him from his position.

Another thing - when Vinayak was beheaded (the Shiva Purana account is that he was beheaded from behind by Shiva while he was busy battling Vishnu - this one is also there in the ACK) - the devas & ganas burst into celebrations & dancing. That made Parvati mad, and she asked Durga & Mahakali to wreck vengeance on them. Here, they showed everybody shocked @ Vinayak's beheading, which was total bunk!

I actually agree w/ Mahadev's POV. Granted that Parvati wanted her privacy, but remember - she wanted to bathe alone w/ her attendants - Jaya, Vijaya & so on. So it's understandable that her husband would feel hurt @ being so shafted. But she never tried to explain to Mahadev why she needed her privacy - she just wanted someone who'd obey her even if it meant disobeying Mahadev - and got this result.



Actually at their first encounter..Mahadev went back after listening to Vinayak.. he didn't seem to have a problem.. he was ready to wait...it was the others..the Ganas..prets.. Devtas that seem more disturbed by the fact that Shivji has not met Parvati...😕😆
If anyone desrved punishment..its the others for interfering in Husband wife's personal matter..😆😆

On a serious note.. why couldn't Mahadev wait ?? When he knew that Parvati is taking a bath and doing a puja.. why interfere in that ?? 😕
Or did he think that just like him..and his Tap.. Parvati will be inside the cave for years together..?? 😆
Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
Parvati was shown in very bad light today.
I hated it when Mahadev called her selfish.He said that she gave birth to Vinayak for personal reasons and used him to fulfil her own motive.But that was not true.She gave birth to vinayak for jagat kalyan as well as not to leave her ever.When vinayak asked her why was he born,she clearly told him,he was born for jagat kalyan and to bring shubhta to the world.So where was she selfish?Asking for privacy is selfishness?In that case,why mahadev?She should let everyone in when she is taking bath na.🤢😡
That's the problem with today's world.If a woman asks for freedom or privacy,she is always called a selfish.And that's what was shown today.
So if parvati is selfish,isn't mahadev selfish?If mahadev leaves everything and goes in samadhi,that's also selfishness.And what solution did he find after going in samadhi?Nothing.
Mahadev always rejected Adishakti's love because he didn't wanted to lose his bairagya.Isn't that selfishness?
When the show began,they showed Mahadev not caring about anybody.Whenever Vishnu and Brahma would come to him and request him to marry sati for jagat kalyan,he would always say,"Jagat kalyan my foot!I don't want to lose my bairagya by marrying sati."So isn't that selfishness?
I really hated it when he was blaming parvati for everything.He even blamed her for vinayak's misbehaviour.That was too much!
And then parvati was shown as a selfish and idiotic woman by saying that she will do sansaar's vinash because her son was killed.😡The way they showed her doing vinaash,she was looking like a villain.
That was ridiculous!And the precap was horrible.Vinayak's apology was somewhat ok because he misbehaved with his father but parvati apologising was too much!
If we thought Kali episode was worst,today's episode was even more worst.Today the cvs massacred Adishakti's character like anything.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
Actually, in the original story - or at least one version of it - Parvati didn't create Vinayak for jagat kalyan - she created him b'cos Nandi was not obeying her in terms of letting nobody in if the somebody was Mahadev. So in that respect, while one could call Parvati selfish, fact is that Mahadev never did: he regretted beheading Vinayak once it was done. But when he did behead Vinayak, he didn't do it reluctantly or tearfully: he did it in the heat of rage on seeing the ganas & devas getting routed.

But they way they showed it in this serial - in trying to 'salvage' the images (of who, I have no idea), they ended up making the whole storyline look ridiculous. Here it looked like making statues was Parvati's hobby, and after her experiment w/ Asoka-Sundari, she's now on to Ganesh. But no reason was shown as to why she suddenly hardened and was miffed when Nandi or Bhrigni or other Ganas came to her for instructions on how to welcome him - she just randomly summoned Vinayak, when she could have simply asked Nandi himself - as originally happened - to guard her sthal. Why ask a child to do something that one of these experienced ganas could have done?

In the original story, there is no record of Parvati trying to persuade Shiva to give her the privacy she desired, or of Mahadev mocking such a request. Had that been there, the root of it too would have been available. Anyway, now that Vinayak has gotten his trunk, guess we can start watching Ganesh vs Kartikeya escapades. 😆
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
i dont not think Parvati was shown like a Villian-and i do not think the episode was even 1/4th of how bad the Kaali episode was...
Parvatis arguments were logical and even her anger was justified
Infact through out the argument Parvati did have an upper hand

What did Vinayak do so bad that he deserved a beheading?
Why all the DEvtas and Ganas ganged up against a little boy just following his mothers orders?
Why Mahadev who otherwise leaves her alone for days together couldnt wait for just sometime to meet her?
If Prajyapati Daksha could be brought back to life,why not Vinayak?
Dakshas and Vinyaks crimes were of two diffrent levels,Dakshas being worse-so if Daksha could be brought alive why not Vinayak

She first nicely asked Mahadev-mostly she immidiately gets angry

here she asks Mahadev nicely,then she demands it,and when Mahadev doesnt listen to her demand only then she becomes Adi Shakti and begins to destroy everything

Parvatis anger and her vengance was justified-i do not think she looked bad!

The Makers actually gave us two arguments-One Mahadevs and One Parvatis both arguments in thier own way were right
I though Parvati was right and Mahadev was the one who looked like a villian!

but i agree with Vrish,in an attempt to justify Vinayaks beheading they did manage to make the viewers confused

Infuriating was the precap🤣-no comments on that😊
sanju01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Actually, in the original story - or at least one version of it - Parvati didn't create Vinayak for jagat kalyan - she created him b'cos Nandi was not obeying her in terms of letting nobody in if the somebody was Mahadev. So in that respect, while one could call Parvati selfish, fact is that Mahadev never did: he regretted beheading Vinayak once it was done. But when he did behead Vinayak, he didn't do it reluctantly or tearfully: he did it in the heat of rage on seeing the ganas & devas getting routed.


But they way they showed it in this serial - in trying to 'salvage' the images (of who, I have no idea), they ended up making the whole storyline look ridiculous. Here it looked like making statues was Parvati's hobby, and after her experiment w/ Asoka-Sundari, she's now on to Ganesh. But no reason was shown as to why she suddenly hardened and was miffed when Nandi or Bhrigni or other Ganas came to her for instructions on how to welcome him - she just randomly summoned Vinayak, when she could have simply asked Nandi himself - as originally happened - to guard her sthal. Why ask a child to do something that one of these experienced ganas could have done?

In the original story, there is no record of Parvati trying to persuade Shiva to give her the privacy she desired, or of Mahadev mocking such a request. Had that been there, the root of it too would have been available. Anyway, now that Vinayak has gotten his trunk, guess we can start watching Ganesh vs Kartikeya escapades. 😆


If u want to discuss about what they show in dkdm, better not to discuss about the original story or story according to puranas because cvs hardly show anything according to the puranas.They only take 1 or 2% from the puranas.Rest all is their own story.
According to story shown in dkdm, parvati gave birth to vinayak for jagat kalyan and not to do let people in when she takes bath.So according to this story, she thought about the world too while giving birth.So she was not fully selfish like she was during kartikeya and ashok sundari time.so Mahadev calling her selfish was not justified.
The cvs have completely changed the story in order to justify mahadev's killing and to some extent they have been successful because there are certain people who don't find anything wrong in killing vinayak after watching the last 2 episodes. We feel sympathy for parvati and think she was right but others feel she was the main culprit. I guess dkdm makers are making this show only to keep that certain section of people happy.
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
actually regarding the "selfish thing" here the Cvs contradicted themselfs here
Parvati here clearly created Vinayak not only forherself but for the world too
this whole selfish thing shouldnt have been added in the first place!
they could have stuck with the theory that Ganesha was created out of Parvatis used turmeric hence he had some faults in him
that selfish thingy didnt make sense
but yeah it was enough to infuriate Parvati though🤣
sindhupv thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
The weirdest part was when Mahadev accused Parvati for being selfish when she created Vinayak. In the past episodes Mahadev went to do tapp preciously to find a solution and he was mentally relaying that Parvati soon u will know what to do.
When She created Vinayak she was clear she was doing so for jagat kalyan and not just for her selfish needs. I was not convinced by Mahadev's argument with Parvati at all.
Sonarika was very good but somehow every justification of Vinayak's beheading by Mahadev did not register it sounded very lame.
Precap was head banging why oh why is she made to fall on his feet. I don't think I want to watch tonight's episode.
sanju01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: shruti.nil

actually regarding the "selfish thing" here the Cvs contradicted themselfs here

Parvati here clearly created Vinayak not only forherself but for the world too
this whole selfish thing shouldnt have been added in the first place!
they could have stuck with the theory that Ganesha was created out of Parvatis used turmeric hence he had some faults in him
that selfish thingy didnt make sense
but yeah it was enough to infuriate Parvati though🤣


That's why people felt parvati was shown in bad light because she was called selfish even after thinking about jagat kalyan.
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
actually in the entire episode Mahadev did look bad-its not like he looked like an angel!
infact his justifications seemed like a desperate attempt on his part to cover up for the fact that he commited a big crime
but its contradictory to all that the Cvs said earlier...
i hope the cvs justify why Mahadev was so cold towards Parvati!
jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
Shruthi the only way parvati/Adishakthi will threaten to destroy the universe is to be cold towards her !!!!! [ i am looking at it from CV point of view] 🤡
If he was nice and loving she would have been like ' AAHHHA NOW I SEE UR POV MAHADEV ' 🤢 Yes my son who I lovingly brought into the world for Jagat Kalyan was so so so selfish of me .. 😲

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".