\|/Doubts & Discussions about Lord Shiva Part-1\|/

First Previous

Page

117

Next Last

Frequent Posters

mnx12

@mnx12

Channel Moderator

+ 16

Posted: 12 years ago

#1111

Vrish,

according to Ganesh Puran, Paravti's Punyak vrat to get a son was to please Krishna, who always resides in Goloka. Here it's Shani's dristi, the reason for Ganesh's head getting cut. He was not beheaded by Shivji, it is mentioned the moment Shani saw the child, his head was cut off from the body. It merged in Krishna in Goloka. That's why head couldn't be replaced. Other part of the body was alive that's why replacing head was possible.

Quote

mnx12

@mnx12

Channel Moderator

+ 16

Posted: 12 years ago

#1112

Originally posted by: _twilight_
I have a querry. In the serial Shivji has been shown to be ataryami -- that is he knows the future events before they occur. How is it tat he did not know that vinayak was his son while he fought with him and beheaded him?

Shivji is shown as being aware of Vinayak, as his son. He knew, as per rishi Kashyap's curse he'll be killing his own son.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Kriti Jain

@wildcat1994

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#1113

Originally posted by: mnx12
Vrish,
according to Ganesh Puran, Paravti's Punyak vrat to get a son was to please Krishna, who always resides in Goloka. Here it's Shani's dristi, the reason for Ganesh's head getting cut. He was not beheaded by Shivji, it is mentioned the moment Shani saw the child, his head was cut off from the body. It merged in Krishna in Goloka. That's why head couldn't be replaced. Other part of the body was alive that's why replacing head was possible.

hey meenakshi..can u explain this in detail..for i hven't i hrd this story b4 n m utterly confused about his GOLOKA theory...thanks!!!!

Edited by wildcat1994 - 12 years ago

Quote

.Reshama.

@.Reshama.

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#1114

are there any other of mytho forums???

Quote

mnx12

@mnx12

Channel Moderator

+ 16

Posted: 12 years ago

#1115

Originally posted by: wildcat1994

hey meenakshi..can u explain this in detail..for i hven't i hrd this story b4 n m utterly confused about his GOLOKA theory...thanks!!!!

Read Ganesh Purana, this concept is explained in detail. Even Devi Bhagvat, mentions, Radhaji is living with Krishna forever in Goloka, this is even before the Krishna avatar.Parvati did Punyak Vrat to get a son that pleased Krishna, as a result Ganesh was born.

Quote

magicman555

@magicman555

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

#1116

Hi everyone,

I just wanted to know how was the relationship between Lord Ganesha and Lord Kartikeya. were they cordial with each other or did kartikeya distance himself from the family

Thanks😊😊😊

Quote

Kriti Jain

@wildcat1994

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#1117

as can be seen in d show currently..kartikeya loved his parents n family bt was always a lil egoistic n used to fight wid ganesh despite loving him...just lyk hw 2 sis may continuously fight bt in they end wen trouble falls r always 2gether..tats hw ganesh nd kartikeya were...they would fight bt at the end of d day wuld land up 2gether!!!!

Quote

varaali

@varaali

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#1118

Originally posted by: magicman555
Hi everyone,

I just wanted to know how was the relationship between Lord Ganesha and Lord Kartikeya. were they cordial with each other or did kartikeya distance himself from the family

Thanks😊😊😊

I am not sure how Kartikeya's relationship is depicted in the North Indian sources, but I can surely tell you how Tamil literature describes the brothers' relationship.

First of all, down South, Kartikeya is the younger brother and Ganesha the elder one. So there is a reversal of roles. OTOH, I can recollect three incidents which shed light on the brothers' relationship.

First is the circumambulation of the Earth- in which Ganesh is declared the winner. In the Tamil sources, this incident takes place when they were still children and the reason for holding the competition was to determine who would get to eat the mango that Narada had brought and offered to Shiva. Kartikeya is rather miffed that his parents' agreed with Ganesh's 'shortcut' parikrama.

Kartikeya's anger is more against his parents' than his brother. But as far as I have read, it is the sulking and disappointment of a young child- not the vindictiveness of a teenager as being shown in the serial. In fact Parvati goes on to cajole Murugan.

The second incident where we get to see both of them is just before the war with Surapadman when Kartikeya prostrates before Vinayaka and seeks his elder brothers' blessings before starting out (since Ganesha is considered Vignaharta- remover of all obstacles).

The third and most famous incident is when Murugan tries to woo Valli but runs into one problem after another. Getting frustrated, Kartikeya mentally invokes Ganesha to come and help him out.

and Ganesha immediately responds (what are elder brothers for, if not solve their siblings' problems?) by appearing as a huge wild elephant.

(I had written about Murugan- Valli romance somewhere- not able to locate it right now)

Apart from these Puranic accounts, there are several description by poets and saints describing the quaint, sometimes amusing, activities of Ganesh- Kartik.

Edited by varaali - 12 years ago

Quote

VishaD.

@VishaD.

Achiever

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#1119

Actually even i was confused as i had always known that Murugan is younger than Lord Ganesha and Ganesha is the elder brother. And the current track which i know was also a fruit given by Narathar to Lord Shiva and with both of them wanting the fruit, Lord Shiva decided that the first to go around the world will win the fruit to which Murugan leaves on his peacock while Lord Ganesha goes around his parents. Lord Murugan who returns is angry and goes to the top of a mountain to which Parvathi goes to cool him down.

Quote

mnx12

@mnx12

Channel Moderator

+ 16

Posted: 12 years ago

#1120

Originally posted by: Visha_Dhami
Actually even i was confused as i had always known that Murugan is younger than Lord Ganesha and Ganesha is the elder brother.

In the North Indian version, Kartikeya is eldest. He was born to kill Tarakasur. then Ganesh is born. This show follows that version. But they tend to mix up different version & create one of their own, at times confusing viewers at what actually is happening😆

Quote

1 ... 110 111 112 113 114 ... 117

\|/Doubts & Discussions about Lord Shiva Part-1\|/ - Page 112

Related Topics

Explore Topics