no comparison between J and manyata

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

kickassfairy

@kickassfairy

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

I believe both sisters are equally stubborn and silly. However, JN has the benefit of a good education and in spite of her all jealousy issues does care for her family. She does have reason to be jealous.. all her life she lived under the shadow of the missing princess. Everything she thought was hers is no longer hers and she thinks Manyata is not deserving of all this.. ie.. Uday..Devgarh..her family.

Manyata she is supremely childish and has an one track mind. There is nothing wrong in protesting against wrong but doing in a juvenile fashion while hurting member's of family who have not done anything to deserve that. The one word i associate with Manyata's character is silly. Who has a lot of growing up to do.

Both J and Manyata are daughters of Brijraj..who has the streak of stubbornness , impatience and anger. I would like to see them display sides of their personality which reflect on Komal's character.

Quote

Poulomi Das

@_Poulomi_

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

I dont know about comparison, but both the girls are same. Selfish to the core.

J has the education and intelligence to be a queen, but would use it for her own agenda. However Manyata has the heart of a ruler, but lacks the education.

Manyata is not hated because she loves Majnu, but because, her insensitiveness towards her family. Its true what happened to Akash is wrong, UV shouldnt have done it, but the thing is why is behaving as if they arent her own blood but some people who are forcefully keeping her with them? Hell! they are your family members, try to believe and understand them a little.

In every family the first thing we do is trust our own blood and then try to find out if they did anything wrong, and make them realise their mistakes. She has stayed in Palace to enough to learn that DS is not those type of ruler who abuse their power, she even said that she can never do anything that will hurt her sentiments. Then what is she doing now?

Remember when Akash lost his job, she was quick to blame DS, but did she try to learn the truth, did she apologize to her after that, for her behavior, knowing that it wasnt her fault? Tell me does that show her character in some good light? It only shows that she is a SELFISH and MATLABI person who knows about herself only and doesnt care about others' feelings.

She gives lectures about lying and right and wrong, but did she hesitate when telling so many lies to them? One white lie after another, then doesnt that show her as a double standard? She says she is hurt by them for keeping them in the dark, but did she not keep them in the dark about her relations with Akash feigning in front of everyone that she has accepted UV as her fiance? Manyata, u have always broken their trust how can u expect the same from them?

She loves that woman who made fun of her class and poverty when she was just a chawl girl, and now she is taking care of her and being polite to her? However she cant even maintain the minimum norms of a daughter with her family?! Explain me that!

I am not telling that she should not find akash but whats with that behavior with her Family? why is she being so insensitive towards them? This same family pined for her for 16 years and why is she not even considering their emotions? Are they not at all impotant to her? The way she is trying to find Akash only shows that she has no feelings for her family.

At least J wouldnt make a mockery out of their family's reputation, to get her things done.

The way Mnayata is behaving right now, isnt the behavior of a 20 year old, but some 14 year old teenager with raging hormones, and no sense.

MOST IMPORTANTLY: We are getting ManVeer scenes every day then why are the TRPs falling?????? Isnt it becoz of Mnayata's unreasonable behavior that no one can relate with?????

People dont watch drama just for the sake of watching it, they watch it when they can relate themselves with the characters. In case of DEK, Mnayata is beyond EVERYONE's tolerance. Majority is not WRONG.

Edited by poulomi12 - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Poulomi Das

@_Poulomi_

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

And people stop calling us hypocrites, as we will see when the time comes who is one and who is not.

People have acknowledged the wrong and right, everytime, so know before you speak. We, the hypocrites, have analysed the wrong and right actions in each character. The characters of DEk are all grey, and not just completely good or bad, unlike other soaps. Uv wanting to marry Manyata for the estate, thats we have all known, and we are all aware of his ambitions and his Casanova nature, but thats the biggest challenge there, to see him reform and become a one woman man. To see him ditch his ambition for love, to see his emotional turmoil.

J is born and brought up as a princess but her insecurities have always been her biggest enemy, she hasnt done anything bad, but if we THINK IMPARTIALLY, FORGETTING THAT MANYATA IS THE LEAD, we can see that she is fit to become a Queen of face value, and not a Queen of people's heart. So i guess we, 'the hypocrites', are doing a impartial judging.

So we know now who thinks one sidedly...eh?!

Quote

unniknairtcr

@unniknairtcr

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

people hate manyata,not becoz she loves akash,but the way she behaves nowadays.we cant blame akash.i think people go for udhay mainly becoz,he is more handsome than akash.if akash were more good looking than anyone,i know everyone who talks against him,would have been on his side.

grow up all. i am not on anyone s side,as my age is not that goes after udhay or akash.

manyatha behaves as if she is just a school kid.let her grow up.

we cant blame her for loving akash,as only he was with her in her bitter days,though only for a few months ,perhaps.he was such a relief to her.but the way she found to confront all is not right,seems so silly

Edited by unniknairtcr - 13 years ago

Quote

xpakigirlx

@xpakigirlx

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

dream chasing you have no right to call us manyaats hater or hypocrite ...you ppl are with her beacuse she is the lead and you cant get that out of your head...when it comes to behaviour manaata also missbehaved with not only komal when she came to chawl but also dadi sahab..

Quote

kasturika ghosh

@kasturika_kashu

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: dreamchasing

So true, I totally agree!

People should stop talking about ethics when judging the characters of Dek! They should simply stop coz they appear more like hypocrites when they start blaming manyata one sidedly!! So many times, other characters of Dek have shown their immorality, but they have never said anything against them and when it comes to manyata, they keep shouting at her just bcos she has fallen for the most irritating character! Starting with Jay, what good she has to date to claim her princess? She was born as a princess but she shows no sign of a princess! She is good only in her dress choice matter!! Love Uday but there was many times his acts of flirting with girls, planning to marry manyata for Devgadh sts ago, physically harming Aakash were not justified at any cost from an ethical point of view but people have nothing to say!! There are lots where you can claim others's moral hazards but no everyone us after manyata! Yes I agree she is immature and childish and stupid but she does have a pure heart!

thnx.. i just wanted to specify that manyata is the lead..after.. before she is human being.. so she definitely has a ryt to do faults... yesterday i felt very bad for her wen uday left her like that.. somehow i feel that she unconsciously likes him...😳

Quote

iqbalslover

@iqbalslover

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

kashu when will this all drama stop man. i havent seen the show for a week now. the akash missing twist was the worst action by CVs. its boring to death.

Jai and Manyata are two different people. we cant compare them in any way. in the beginning Jai was not toelrable but somehow now i can understand her actions PS. her char is relatebale but i cant relate to manyata since she got to know she is Rajkumari.

and please can somehow change her warderobe. i am sure even chawl girls dont wear such clothes. it looks she 12 years old girls clothes are giving to manyata. Cant PH do some fitting to her kameez...

Edited by steffroc - 13 years ago

Quote

kasturika ghosh

@kasturika_kashu

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: steffroc
kashu when will this all drama stop man. i havent seen the show for a week now. the akash missing twist was the worst action by CVs. its boring to death.
Jai and Manyata are two different people. we cant compare them in any way. in the beginning Jai was not toelrable but somehow now i can understand her actions PS. her char is relatebale but i cant relate to manyata since she got to know she is Rajkumari.
and please can somehow change her warderobe. i am sure even chawl girls dont wear such clothes. it looks she 12 years old girls clothes are giving to manyata. Cant PH do some fitting to her kameez...

dnt know yar.. u cn watch today.. its gonna be interesting...😉 bt yar i dnt know why J ko dekhti hu to mera khun gholta hain...😡 i hate chipku and despo girls... yuckk🤢 manyata is irritating.. bt i dnt hate her.. bt i hate J...🤢

Quote

iqbalslover

@iqbalslover

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: kasturika_kashu
dnt know yar.. u cn watch today.. its gonna be interesting...😉 bt yar i dnt know why J ko dekhti hu to mera khun gholta hain...😡 i hate chipku and despo girls... yuckk🤢 manyata is irritating.. bt i dnt hate her.. bt i hate J...🤢

i will watch if maanveers love story starts😆

most of the time all telly leading ladies are irritatiing😆