Partial judges unfair? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Raj, Kya title hai? Partial judges to unfair hi honge na😆.

I concur with you. Judges are supposed to judge a competition with no bias. They should voice their opinion on mediocrity and encourage contestants to do better instead of wasting their time in catfights and putting contestants down for no reason and bringing up vendetta and regional bias.

😆😆😆@ your highlighted observation...😆

Let's take a flip view of this coin. Imagine yourself living with 6 contestants from a varied background, some of them coming from very telling backgrounds (Harshit as an example). How in the world do you imagine yourself not getting bonded with such individuals? How in the world do you fulfill the promise that you make to those individuals during those training sessions? Do you recall Jatin/Lalit/AS/HR/ID saying this on countless occasion "Mai Maa Kasam/Allah Kasam khake kehta hoon ki mai tujhe star banaunga"? How do they keep their promises if they do not blatantly take sides?

I know that on surface it sounds pretty ugly partial but there is a Human Emotion attached here and they are only doing their best to help the singers. To me, there is nothing wrong marketing the singers from their gharana. Showing down other singers is not something I subscribe to. I like Bhappi-Da from that perspective. He tom-toms singers from his gharana but never undermines other singers (as far as I recall).😛..For that matter he hardly says more than "toom accha gaaaya lekin improovemaint ka aaoor chaance haye"😆😆

**really Unfair..* no doubt@!!!

as far as judges appealing for votes is concerned ...then..i think they want the TRUE talent to Win>not to lose..!!!! soo thts why.!!

*more commnets later*

Originally posted by: rutumodi915

Haha! Hell it is unfair!

But then, what is public voting for? Isn't that unfair also so many times?

What is influencing public? doesn't judges comments not more but impacts.

People say we should just let the knowledgeable people decide, but how many right things do they decide? So, is it really possible to get an unbiased winner?

Yes! thats what the expectation is, being bias is unprofessionalism..don't get such judges.

Be it judges choice or public choice, we are very fair from getting anything unfair and unbiased in these shows.

And QT di, I read it on SRGMP forum also, was Bappi Da really your favorite? Please don't get me wrong, but can you tell me why😕? And was he your fav as a judge or music director?

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

😆😆😆@ your highlighted observation...😆

Let's take a flip view of this coin. Imagine yourself living with 6 contestants from a varied background, some of them coming from very telling backgrounds (Harshit as an example). How in the world do you imagine yourself not getting bonded with such individuals? How in the world do you fulfill the promise that you make to those individuals during those training sessions? Do you recall Jatin/Lalit/AS/HR/ID saying this on countless occasion "Mai Maa Kasam/Allah Kasam khake kehta hoon ki mai tujhe star banaunga"? How do they keep their promises if they do not blatantly take sides?

I know that on surface it sounds pretty ugly partial but there is a Human Emotion attached here and they are only doing their best to help the singers. To me, there is nothing wrong marketing the singers from their gharana. Showing down other singers is not something I subscribe to. I like Bhappi-Da from that perspective. He tom-toms singers from his gharana but never undermines other singers (as far as I recall).😛..For that matter he hardly says more than "toom accha gaaaya lekin improovemaint ka aaoor chaance haye"😆😆

In one sentence - There is NO room for human emotions when it comes to professionalism. 😊

Originally posted by: raj5000

In one sentence - There is NO room for human emotions when it comes to professionalism. 😊

While I agree with you in principle, I would have to say this...

RamRajya wapas aaney mein bahut waqt lagega Babua😆😆😆

Originally posted by: rutumodi915

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar