MOTHERHOOD thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
The norm of society is that a girl has to live her parental home and stay with her in laws after marriage.
But what if a girl does not want to live with her in laws?
What if she does not want to adjust with a new family?
What if she does not want to change her lifestyle?
Should be allowed to fulfill her wishes?
Our society considers girls who do not want to live with their in laws as immoral, insensitive and selfish.
But is it really selfish?
Men will never stay with their in laws.
Then why are they not selfish?

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

2.6k

Users

11

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

Forever-KA thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
lets make it more filmi
"ladki toh paraya dhan hoti hai"
"ladki toh kisi aur ki amanat hoti hai, ek din to us ko jaana hai"
"beti, aap toh pati ke ghar se arthi hi mein wapas aana"
"hum to beti ke ghar ka paani bhi nahi peete hain"
"banno re banno chali sasural, aakhion mein paani de gaye"
"babul ka aangan chod ke, janmoon ka bandhan jod ke, beti paraye ghar jaaye gi"
okay are you girls crying now? lol. some of you have rebelled
"jab yaaar kare parwa meri, mujhe kya parwa is duniya ki, jag lakh lagayee mujh pe pabandi, main hon hi nahi is duniya ki"
lol. i think if girls dont like the arrangment then they should marry someone where they dont have to be in such a setup. important thing is they should be happy in whatever they want to do. just dont be part of something you dont like. no rocket science.
Edited by King-Anu - 12 years ago
alina.b thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I think both the husband and wife should each give up something equally. To clarify, it should not only be the girl who has to give everything up. I think it's more important for a couple to live together than to live with in laws. So whether it be at husband's in laws house or the woman's in laws house or even if they live alone. What matters is that they stay together. Now getting adjusted in life to new environments or new people is just a part of life. I've grown up in the US but I've had dreams of living in a traditional family. I think it would be fun to live with an extended family. But the excuse for the husband or wife is that they don't feel like "adjusting" is just not acceptable because adjusting is part of life.
-Believe- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: -IHATEYOU-

The norm of society is that a girl has to live her parental home and stay with her in laws after marriage.
But what if a girl does not want to live with her in laws?
What if she does not want to adjust with a new family?
What if she does not want to change her lifestyle?
Should be allowed to fulfill her wishes?
Our society considers girls who do not want to live with their in laws as immoral, insensitive and selfish.
But is it really selfish?
Men will never stay with their in laws.
Then why are they not selfish?


Kyu ki saas bhi kabhi bahu thi...😆


maha2us thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
I will attempt to answer some of the questions of the person who started this debate.
You have asked good questions and they all deserve to be answered. You ask, 'What if a girl does not want to live with her in-laws and and what if she does not want to adjust to a new family?' Definitely any girl can ask these questions to herself. But why is she expecting the society to let her be in a certain way. The society is full of fear and the number of persons who follow their heart and be loving are not many. Yet God has endowed with every human being the capability to be a loving person and the capability to be a caring, compassionate, tender, gentle and understanding person. And the first person to whom you have to be loving, compassionate, gentle, tender and understanding is yourself and not any other person. You have every right to give importance to the pain within you. Remember you are your best friend and not your in-laws. Did the society encourage Jhansi Rani to be who she was? How did she become that? She followed her heart and gave importance to the pain within her. God has given special talents to everyone - both men and women. But it is the duty of each person to follow his or her talent. Can you read the life history of J.K.Rowling?

if you really don't want to stay with your in-laws, it is quite acceptable point. But just rebelling or crying or creating a scene doesn't help. You have to take responsibility to show that you are a woman of substance who can be like Jhansi Rani, Madame Curie or J.K.Rowling. As on today, I definitely know that my parents and my siblings are selfish people. But just lamenting this repeatedly and expecting them to change won't help me. But if I become courageous and take responsibility for myself and do the needful to follow my heart and value my talents, it helps me and I can become a renowned person or a man of substance.

Phir_Mohabbat thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

The norm of society is that a girl has to live her parental home and stay with her in laws after marriage.
But what if a girl does not want to live with her in laws?
What if she does not want to adjust with a new family?
What if she does not want to change her lifestyle?


so what? many are nt living with in laws...my mom also dnt live with in laws. though we had family problems, but today many dnt live. the thing matter is if we have gd relation with in laws or not. staying with them and having problems- its better to live separate and having gd relations.


Should be allowed to fulfill her wishes?
Our society considers girls who do not want to live with their in laws as immoral, insensitive and selfish.
But is it really selfish?

why not? when women are allowed to have similar rights like men, why not this? its choice of individual.
and that is nt selfish...its better to live separate and hv gd relation than stay together and have everyday fights.

Men will never stay with their in laws.
Then why are they not selfish?


our society is diff when it comes to men. and not living with ur in lazs doesnt mean u are selfish

Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
I think living with others whether they are "in laws" or "out laws" require a lot of sacrifice, adjustment and accomodation; especially for a girl.
It definitely is "Imprisonment"... Good Luck to the ladies.😭
Funny thing is that if a Guy were to live in the girls home, it will not be so bad generally as men are less fastidious.😆
Summer3 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
One of my friend's wife looked after her mother in law as they all stayed under one roof, the father in law having passed away many years ago.
She really looked after the MIL so well eventhough the MIL was sick, had diabetes and other ailments.
To such women I truly salute and have the greatest respect !👍🏼
maha2us thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Summer, Definitely your friend's wife deserves to be respected. While I accept her MIL was sick, diabetic and had other ailments. Was her MIL kind and loving o her? The kindness of MIL helps a lot. Sickness does not prevent a person from being loving. I know women who tell me their MILs were nice persons.
DonnaHarvey thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I live in a big city. My colleagues pay as much as $3000 per month for childcare. I would never give away that much money. So, I have two options: never have a child or have mine/my partner's parents help out if and when I do.
Atleast here, I am not defaulted into choosing his parents. In fact, a lot of the times it is the woman's parents who help out.
Plus, you don't have to live with them. Ideally, one would like to have personal space as well as give the elderly couple some space too.
The best option is to be cordial but not in each other's business.
It is only when difficult decisions such as palliative care come into play that moving in will be an option.
What I am trying to say is, the culture here is different. People make their own life decisions and the society seems to be okay with it.
If it weren't my choice, I don't know what I'd do. Not marry someone who would make me compromise I suppose.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".