Basis of judging

Page

Anu Gupta

@anugupta

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

Hi Everyone,

It seems as though in DPL there is too much confusion. First of all, Shaimak's role is completely pointless. Secondly, the judges don't seem to have a great sense of judgment when it comes to dancing. Either they are completely relentless and offer a 0 on a great performance.....or then they go overboard and give a 6 to what would be a average/good performance.

I feel they need to realize that both concept AND dancing are important and you cannot give marks solely based on one. In this show concept is given more importance and dancing is left wayyy behind. Desi Pardesi's got away because of their concept when their dancing is very average and their coordination is horrendous.

Rani also needs to be consistent with her marks because she gets swayed over by favoritism and emotion and doesnt give marks based on the actual dancing...

What do you all think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

fungrl

@fungrl

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

well desi pardesi are my favorite, but I do agree, the judging is pointless, there has to be set parameters- are they grading on dancing skills, concept, of the complexity etc.. The dancing to me is below par compared to that of DID. I also think passion is missing, it just seems like that the coaches don't really care about all the mistakes the dances make. Shaimak and Rani both should have equal rights so that the scoring could be fair.....this show is a mess

Quote

Basis of judging

Related Topics

Explore Topics