bips thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
week after week ........
her last three performances have been ordinary ..... she looks great dancing but they are not a "competition" level dances .... its something like a tv star would do for an award's night .....
of course, if anyone pointed this out to pyaari geeta ma, she will jump on them with all her claws out 😛 ...... she will say - no binny was very versatile, she has done bellydancing, that wheel thing and the dance with diyas .... conveniently forgetting that her bellydance section was for 10 seconds, the wheel prop was utter nonsense with her just going round and round with firecrackers and that diya thing was utterly gimmicky ......
i have yet to see her give a great performance like she gave in "o re piya" ..... she just does bollywood/ freestyle and gets away without any strong criticism ...... she was my favourite for some time but now she is just *yawn*
..... and i hate this veera nonsense .... doesn't anyone remember how 'veer' was a big flop 😉 .... salman khan has moved on to his next film, so why is DID still stuck there ...
......... someone like shakti is strongly pulled up for repititions or keeping steps simple whereas what binny does is ok because time was short, and its not her shailee ( how i have come to hate this word! ) and so the dance was kept basic (i.e the bungee dance)
This is not a binny vs shakti rant but i just feel that some get away with anything and mild reminders at worst whereas others are criticised and analysed way too much ................. of this season, TKT (with the exception of jack) seem to bearing most of the criticism, GKG are let off the hook too easily accompanied by some fierce championing from Maa and RKR look to be keeping a low profile - neither too many brickbats nor too much appreciation ..........

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

4.4k

Users

22

Likes

105

Frequent Posters

akanna thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
LOL... I like Binny a lot... I like to see her in the finale from GKG as she is my most favorite in GKG... But I agree with what you are saying... I couldnt help laughing how Geeta made Binny tie those diyas on her head and so she couldnt move freely, and so she didnt do much in the second part of that act.. And then Geeta was telling Amar that he could have done a lot more with his wheel..!!! LOL... Her belly dance had basic steps and more break dance moves and she did the same kind of moves in her previous solo too - that "Leke Pehla Pehla" mixed style act... But she has very good stage presence that her flaws go unnoticed...
medha_1310 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
yes ur right i cant connect with binny's acts except ' o re piya'.her performance r all abt hard probs,her flexibility and cute smile.
when shakti did her classical solo geeta said that the steps were very basic but when did the dhom ta na and ur my love steps were far more basic but geeta doesnt mine.instead she said that ur expressions were fab,ur looking beautiful.ur skirt is so bueatiful and all nonsense.😆
shakti di did a pure hip hop and even got the POW but still she said that shakti wasnt very gud.
and i ve noticed that geeta ki pyaari beti veera is going geeta way, shes always talking that how hard shes working,the prop is painful but still i know i will do this etc.
so now it really irritates me.

gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Binny was my favorite in GKG, but slowly, she's failing to impress. Yes, she looks beautiful when she dances and has stage presence but her performances aren't anything wonderful enough to make anybody jump up and down and go "wow" imo. O re piya was amazing--what's happened to that Binny? Where has she disappeared off too? Somewhere, I feel she's gotten overshadowed by Amrita a lot, becuse technically speaking, Amrita's a much better dancer.
Geeta Ma has a separate set of comments for her contestants and another set for the other contestants. And Shakti is one of the biggest threats to Geeta's gang, and now she's getting more and more votes as well, so get ready for more claws to come out.
kirtixyz thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
I think binny is lucky with her looks...im not saying shes getting away with it coz of her looks but i guess thats her biggest asset. She is ofcourse a good dancer but what i donot like about her is that her dances are not effortless, some how her effort always shows, especially while doing stunts. So in that sense i think Amrita is technically better, like her dance is smooth & easy flowing. i guess Alisha (season1) has set a bar so high its going to be difficult for any girl to really match up to that :)
MKrayZee thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
agreed. she needs to REALLY push her limits. show more dancing. i would love to see a zero prop performance! i know amrita and shakti would shine...kruti and nikitasha would too...(i hope GM brings back kruti!!!!)
that said, i do like binny alot more than amrita - for some reason, amrita irritates me! (im sorry if im offending anyone, but she really does!)
not related to the topic but i really wish we could have a masters special. where all contestants are choreographed by one master...i can tell how terrence would make binny do a marvelous act! each master should have their own shailee..as in, terrence should choreograph ballroom dancing/contemporary, remo - freestyle/hip hop and geeta should choreograph indian/bollywood (but not the kind she did for prince and mayuresh last season!)
dodosri thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
i think it will be unfair to others(who r more deserving ) if she will sail to the top 5 through awsome looks & ordinary dance.........
josh135 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Binny is good...shes done a variety of dances i agree but shes not tooo great..n yea i agree nowdays her difficulty level of dancing has been very low.. ..I prefer Shakti more..Shakti's dance is outstanding.
Lak001 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Would prefer Amritha over Binny any day. Of course, Amrita's a trained dancer and binny can't come no where near her in technicalities. Amrita's execution is sharp and neat. Her only drawback is her looks. It's a pity how lot of people go for looks 😕
Edited by Lak001 - 16 years ago
nimmysnv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
I like Binny allot and all her moves are so good and beautiful that I just fell into her dancing she actually creates magic with her moves and she delivers it so well.

Thanks

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".