I hate Mithun... today he proved that...(SPOILER) - Page 5

i too hate mithun's judgement. he doesn't know but say that old steriotype praising words. he should be kicked out of the show.

totally agreed...he is not perfect 2 b a grandmaster....i jus dont lyk his judgement sometymz

so far I've agreed with most of his judgments except for Shubu....although I also think Bhavna had a very weak performance last week, but the weakest out of the girls is Khushboo...she needs to be nominated!

I think if anything the choreographers (Geeta and Remo) need to be fair in their nominations. Terrence is the only one who is fair when he chooses his nominees and he also gives a direct reasoning behind it.

Where Mithunda has gone completely wrong is not in his judgement per se but in the packaging and explaining of his judgement.

Originally posted by: andysah

Where Mithunda has gone completely wrong is not in his judgement per se but in the packaging and explaining of his judgement.

He is a man of few words albeit hackneyed. If he is not able to speak extempore he should wrote his thoughts down and recite from there like Lil Mama (ABDC).

Still now not all is lost. I do not see Sunita or Shubo or even Mandakini having the dancing chops to win it all. So even though their elimination is unfair, at the end it would have evened out.

But just wait (because of this 1 girl, 1 boy policy - sounds kind of like family planning) when Alisha or Siddesh or Jai gets eliminated. The knives will really be sharpened then.

Also astounding is, all judges are rating Noni or Rakhi highly. Are we all watching different shows??

guys,great going..good to see all yr views and thoughts.makes interesting reading,

I do not find Alisha chunky, as I was saying it seems we are watching different shows.

u cant blame mithun man.. i mean every1 is a gud dancer.. i think he goes according to da 3 amigos...wht eva negative point dey say he keeps tht in mind n on tht basis he eliminates sum1

Originally posted by: andysah

I do not find Alisha chunky, as I was saying it seems we are watching different shows.

Mandakini lost because of bad choreography, in between the dances the pause was so great it was like an intermission in the theater. Blame it on Geeta or blame it on her because she was possibly clumsy in putting on the prop but she is out because of the glaring mistake. This is probably what's going to happen among the boys, Mithun going to rate which dance had mistakes and eliminate based on that.

With all due respect man, I really think mandakini's body language was awesome. I have watched so many dancers over the years. She is sleek, quick, elegant and expressive. Her choreography was so smooth, it wasnt rushed like most girls performances. She really came out like a peacock. If you watch the steps where she lifts her legs and does some intricate moves with her hands... its so extremely flawless. Also I adore so much of the choreography in other parts of the dance. I agree she found it difficult to put on the feathers, but for her to dance with the feathers on too...thats simply commendable. Again, I disagree what are you talking about the breaks b/w dances the pause was so great? She connected all the steps extremely well. I really think you know nothing or very little about dance. Also she is the only contestant among girls who can do cartwheel and flips. Her flexibility and athleticism is top notch. Thats why I said compared to her other dancers are chunky. (Maybe for indian standards they are not chunky but for western stanadars they definitely are)

Alisha is second best according to my opinion and sunita/vrushali comes third. Alisha's salsa performance was really good...but after that the two performances she gave, I didnt like that very much.