Your lie or my truth - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.1k

Users

12

Likes

178

Frequent Posters

viji2111 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Sinha family will not let her go. Not because they are being mahan but because Suhasini believes that Swadheenta has been betrayed by Jilani family.
Regarding arvind why should it make a difference in their thinking?
Yesterday there were 3 terrorists and a mastermind and today there are 4.
But Asad still remains the killer.

All the evidence are against Jilanis. Asad had 3 best friends all 3 were terrorist. They were living in their flat. Mamu was caught with a bomb.

Watched the 3rd hearing segment. It is awesome. I dont know how much difference will allan broad thing make here but I am sure sinhas will start looking at the case in a different angle.
Sinhas have not framed Jilanis, they dont have any enimity with them. they are just believing the proofs shown to them.
pomegranate thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Gayatri I also know fighting within the system. I was only telling between Simmi and her, one might have to go. Simmi will bring to the position that's it.

@sur, pom I am not faulting the script. I also know what Sinhas are doing is pretense, while what Swa is doing is her duty. She is doing duty as a daughter and as a bahu. If her husband's family cannot see her doing the duty of a daughter then it is their problem, not her problem.


they understand she is doing her duty as a daughter but they think she is wrong. right now, it is more to do with their ego than anything otherwise such gross behaviour makes no sense. I wish she had it in her to put this family and that man behind her but now they are married
stunninstar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@Gayatri guest house that is my expectation. I want to see how Adarsh Sinha deals with it. You cant fault Simmi. Jaya can atleast think logically which she refuses, but what do you expect from Simmi. She has lost her husband, any other reaction from her would have been too much. She raised the right questions.

i agree.. And more over simmi lost her love her everything.. For a year of their marriage it was onky abhay who loved her in sinha house.. All these people with her now are only for a week or two.. So its natural that whn she hear swa is defending terrorist in court she reacted that way! But she doesnt know yet it is Haider mamu that Swa is defending.. I really hope Simmi gets some clue from abhay's voicemail or something and she start helping Swa ..

Dehleez for me has been better in potraying people realistic.. But why is it going a li'l illogical.. Points that need to be addressed are:
- If Haider and Asad are wrong, who is giving them the support? Why is there no questioning done on that? In reality if a person is caught that way, they will be inteerrogated to get info about others in their gang!
- No phone calls traced! This is first thing done to get clues on other activites
- No one spoke about Aravind.. If a person is caught they will interrogate all close ones.. Why was Aravind nit even spoken about?
- There would be so many CCTV cAamera's in malls and discos and even in sinha house.. They can easily check those for clues on aravind


Just to show Swa solving this single handedly, they are showing Police as a stupid department! Which dept will go to court for final hearing (as per adarsh) to get haider hanged before even completing the investigation right way?! Only sinhas are traumatised.. Not entire police dept and the nation..

Soapoperasrfun thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
Shruthi, this is one of the very rare times that it will happen. But I disagree with you today 😆. I share Viji's opinion in this, although I sense that we are a minority.

Swadheenta is a level headed girl. She understand's the challenges that her family is going through. Like Viji said, the Sinha's had no personal enemity with the Jilani's. They in fact got along very well. They are just believing the evidence that is being shown to them by a system that they are greatly a part of, and a system that to some extent they trust. They believe that the Jilani's have fooled Swadheenta, and are upset with her that despite all the happenings, Swadheenta is not being able to see the truth. As well as they may have known them in the last few months, their relationship with the Jilani's was that of acquaintances. They were not the best of friends, they were not yet family. So they don't have a need to go and prove their innocence to the world.

Swadheenta has that need. She knows her maamu, and she knows Asad. She knows they are incapable of the crimes that they are being accused of. And she wants to protect them. But she also has a new family to manage, a family that is not against her but against the Jilani's at the moment. A family that is not scheming and conniving, but a heart-broken one.

I do not mean to say that Swadheenta's position of fighting this battle alone is easy, or that she deserves what she is going through. Of-course not. Every time I see her on screen, I want to hold her tight and protect her, tell her everything will be alright and that I am there with her. But my only contention is that the Sinha's are not completely incorrect in their position. It is the situation that is wrong, not the people involved. Everyone is reacting the way we normally would.

I will also say this. The only reason Swadheenta is quiet now and at the listening end is because she does not have concrete evidence to prove the innocence of her family. She has means to refute circumstantial evidence, but not conclusively prove with credible proofs that her family had nothing to do with this. The day she does that, she will stop listening to the taunts. She will speak then. Today she has the right intentions, but not all the answers.

Adarsh is not keeping Swadheenta in the house because he wants to show to the world that he is mahaan. He still loves the girl. Nothing has changed that fact. She is still his wife. Today, he has no reason and no means to defend her against the world because even he believes that she is on the wrong. The day he realizes that she is not, he will still fight the world for her. It will happen.
Jemimah90 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Mehek25

@Shruthi...

Very well written Dear...have yet o watch the episode but did read up...
As for Swa leaving the house actually that would be a good thing for her...unless suhasini again becomes all 'mahaan' and stops her with her same dialogue if no Sinha D-I-L is ever to leave...etc etc...

@Yawfeh...
Loved the last bit dear...yes I too want rose the shame in their eyes for not having faith in Swadheenta's faith in her mamu and brother...

Tonk yeah😆😳
BenNevis thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
Very nice post Shruthi
You just speak my mind.
MuguetDScorpion thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
Suhasini was shown very smart and now she looks blinded. So it gets hard to digest it. 😕

I so want Swa to leave the house because they are all insulting her even Adarsh. How can Swa stay calm. If I were Swa I would have left the house and not accept any apologies that easily. 🤢
Sur89 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: MuguetDScorpion

Suhasini was shown very smart and now she looks blinded. So it gets hard to digest it. 😕

I so want Swa to leave the house because they are all insulting her even Adarsh. How can Swa stay calm. If I were Swa I would have left the house and not accept any apologies that easily. 🤢


Yes even i thought a lawyer of her caliber will start seeing things now but instead she said hearing ke bad mera bharosa or pakka hogaya hai ki ye sab gilani's ne hi karvaya. In the banwarilal case it was suha who right away said that the man is not lying and told swa to look into the matter, that tells about her expertise and smartess. It is very disappointing that just to show that swa has to deal with this all alone cv's have made all other smart people dumb.
Edited by Sur89 - 9 years ago
MuguetDScorpion thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Sur89


Yes even i thought a lawyer of her caliber will start seeing things now but instead she said hearing a bad mera bharosa or pakka hogaya hai ki ye sab gilani's ne hi karvaya. In the banwarilal case ot was suha who right away said that the man is not lying and told swa to look into the matter. It is very disappointing that just to show that swa has to deal with this all alone cv's have made all other smart people dumb.



They just want to show Swa vs Suha. 🥱 Which I wanted to see from the starting of the show but not this way. I thought Suha will fight for the wrong things and Swa for the good. I never thought Suha will be shown blinded like this. 😕
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
@priti I am not telling you are wrong. And I understand Suha here is looking here unilaterally because she is not looking at the case as a lawyer, but as a mother. A grieved mother, that's why many points are missed.
Same with Adarsh. He is also looking at it as a grieved brother not as an IAS officer. The day they look at it as a lawyer and an IAS officer things changes.
Swa is looking at the case as a daughter as well as a lawyer. I really loved the FB she had when Suha told her they didnt keep a daughter, but a lawyer at home. Her justification was based on her past feelings, not just one incident.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".