CIDian Idol Contest 2013 - Entry Discussion Thread !!! - Page 31

Created

Last reply

Replies

353

Views

20.4k

Users

28

Likes

453

Frequent Posters

Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: gadhadada


plz any one tell Me the Movie names of these Songs from Entries as...

Song number 9 as JANEE DO NA

song number 10

song number 15 as ABHI ABHI

I am really Pleased if Someone help Me...😃
thanks in Advance...😊


abhi abhi is from jism 2 i think

rest i dont know 🤔
gadhadada thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: appy_indy-KD


abhi abhi is from jism 2 i think

rest i dont know 🤔


thank You Boss...😳
misha.as thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
My reviews :

Entry 1 : Really very sweet voice u have. Loved it. Very well👏

Entry 2 : Sweet voice... 😃

Entry 3 : Nice voice 👏

Entry 4 : Wow😃
Nice and sweet...amazing👏

Entry 5 : Really nice...the background and song are equally amazing⭐️
Great...

Entry 6 : Nice voice...😊

Entry 7 : Good 😃

Entry 8 : One of my fave songs...
Very well sung👏

Entry 9 :Nice 😊

Entry 10 : There is a lot of disturbance, but
Very Nice song and sweet voice...
I loved it 👏

Entry 11 : well sung😊

Entry 12 : Nice 😊

Entry 13 : well sung 😊

Entry 14 : Beautiful song and well sung👏

Entry 15 : Nice singing😃


All the best 😊
anjali_mahajan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
still nt get time to listen the great voices ...bt ill listen the all asap nd will give reviews 😊
Minionite thumbnail

Team Silver Trio

Posted: 12 years ago
The songs were all great...will give reviews soon though I've rated them all. 😃
gadhadada thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago


First a Big Round and applause to All the Participants and taking part in any Contest meant U already won half of it so all participants are the Winners...👏👏

A Big Clap for ASTO who Organised this Contest with Her Hard Work...👏👏

the Enthusiasam, Excitment, Support, Help, Wishes for Every Member from Every Member of Forum would be Appreciated too...👏👏

As I dont know anything about Music/Notes/Nodes/Flow/Lyrics/Composition/Execution?voice/Quality/Pitch but I am a Good Listener like BHAI said in Killer Whistle " Main Music kay baaray mein Achi jaankari rakhta hun, Music sunta hun main" so I m also following on His Path...😉

If any member feels Bad/sad/Angry on My Comments, I Appologize but it Does not mean that U have any Problem with Ur Voice/Accent/Music or anything... it just meant that I Encouraged U to move with much more Spirit as U all are the Shinning Raising Bright Star and will get Success in Ur Future...⭐️⭐️⭐️


Entry 1: WADA RAHA PYAR SAY PYAR KA, Official track from the Movie KHAKEE sung by UDIT and SHERYA GHOSHAL, I really enjoyed a Low background of Karoke, the Voice is Pretty and at some notes gives the shades of SHERYA voice, the Singer sung it Nicely with Calm and Clear effect which Executed Nicely, I really Admired the Effort...!👏👏


Entry 2: SAWAAR LOON, Official track from the Movie LOOTERA sung by MONALI THAKUR, Again the Singer sung it with Karoke but I feel the Nervouness in Her Sweet Voice, at some moments the Gaps little Confuse the Listener that might be the Singer Forgets the Lyrics, I like the BG still in Low Tone but somehow Singer did not Sung it with Clear effect... I enjoyed it...!👏


Entry 3: AAO NA AAO NA, Official track from the Movie KYUN HO GAYA NA sung by UDIT and SADHNA SARGAM, the Singer sung it with Karoke Effect which is Nice, I like the way She sung it either at Some place She was little Delayed the Lyrics, Voice is Sweet but Clearity was little Missing just because She sung it in below Notes, but I really Praise it...!👏


Entry 4: LUG JA GALY, Official track from the 60's Movie sung by the Melodious Queen LATA Jee, the Singer sung it without Karoke but what a Lovely Effect Sprinkled over Listener, it was really One of the Best Entry as the Voice really Claen, Melodious and Soft, I really feel to went to that Era where SADHNA Jee as playing the character of SANDHIYA singing it for stopping Dr. ANAND played by MANOJ KUMAR, I really Applause for Her Excillent Performance...!👏⭐️


Entry 5: PANI DA RUNG, Official track from the Movie VICKY DONOR sung by AYUSMAN KHURRANA, the Singer sung it with playing Guitar by Herself, Honestly this was called a True and perfect Performance, yes the way She sung with Her totally Melodious, Swash Voice bring Us to Listen Her "LIVE", No Doubt She is the Fabulous Singer but this time Her Guitar took the Place, Lovely notes, Strings and Somehow at Some Stanza the Voice bit low down as She was so Involved in Guataring like Us, Yes She Sung but this time Her "FINGERS" sung more on those Strings which takes Us to a place where really We wanted to saw the Shades of all Colors of this Colorless Gift of LORD, My Standing Ovation for Her either somehow She was Little Low from Her Last Year Performance...!⭐️⭐️⭐️


Entry 6: JAANY KYUN LOG MUHABBAT, Official track from the 70's era Movie MEHBOOB KI MEHNDI sung by none other than LATA Jee, the Singer sung it without any Karoke Effect, She has a Nice voice, Claerity was there, High Pitch also be there but Somehow the Singing was Flat without any Emotion and Feel, I like the way She Work Hard and tried to giver Her Good short...!👏


Entry 7: MERA MULK MERA DESH, Official track from the Movie DIL JALE sung by KUMAR SANU and ADITYA NARAYAN, the Singer sung it without Karoke Effect but the way She sung it with a Patriatic feel was Really Appreciatable, She sung it Simply, Claenly and with a Nice pace although I feel that I went to My School and watching INDEPENDANCE DAY Celebration, Lovely and Good Effort...!👏👏


Entry 8: MERI MAA, Official track from the Movie TAARE ZAMEEN PER sung by EHSAAN, obviously We all knew that Singer who sung it with Karoke Effect but really this time I did not find that Feel,Flavour which turned My room into a Rocking Floor Last year, Somehow the Karoke was moved Fastly so the Singer sung it little Hurry which really Effect the Flow of that Song, I really Adore the Voice of Singer
but this time it was Not create that Aura even over Me, The Clarity in Voice, the Melodity, Quality, Pitch all be there but the FEEL was Missing but as The Singer Voice coming, No Doubt He is One of Finest Singer of Our Forum...!👏⭐️


Entry 9: JAANE DO NA, Official track from the Movie CHEENI KUM sung by SHERYA GHOSHAL, the Singer sung Exceptionally Well, Yes the way She sung this Song with a Flair and little Wittiness, I really Admired, She really takes a Song which suits on Her Voice, Clear, little Lower but really Lovely... Excillent Attempt...!👏⭐️

Entry 10: KAHEIN YE WO TOU NAHI, Official track from the 60's era Movie HAQEEQAT sung by LATA Jee, I really Like the Depth in the Voice of the Singer, the way She handled Her Voice, never Slipped from the Flow and move with ease in Such Distrubanvce of Hammering, Car Noise, Horns, Vehicle Moving, Murmuring even someone Yawining too, I really Appreacite that in Such I clearly Heard Her Voice with Softness, She really tried Best to gives Her Besst Short and She definitely Successeded on it...!👏👏


Entry 11: DO LAFZUN KI HAY, Official track from the Movie THE GREAT GAMBLER sung by ASHA BHONSLE Jee and AMITABH BACCHAN Jee, the Singer sung it with a Beautiful LALALA Effect which gives Her a Good Flow to Move on, She tried to little sung in shade of ASHA Jee so at Somepoint the Notes was too much High, I really Like the Flavour either the Accent was Not upto the mark but I really Enjoyed it with moving My Head and Humming with it, Really Fantabulous Effort...!👏⭐️


Entry 12: CHITTHI NA KOI SANDES, Official track from the Movie DUSHMAN sung by Late JAGJIT SINGH Jee, the Singer sung it Nice but the Tension, Nerviousness and Hurry easily grasped by the Listener, She really has a Sweet and Soft voice, Clearity and Pitch was Good, Really Good Work...!👏


Entry 13: MAULA MERAY MAULA, Official track from the Movie DELHI-6 sung by SWAROOP KHAN and NAUSHAD ALI, the Singer sung it with Karoke Effect but the Effect She used Excillently, I gives Her a Big Appreciation as She really select Very Tough Song with a Qawaali shade but the way She sung it, really She will Deserve such a Big Big Claps as the Lyrics was too Tough as based on SALEES URDU, the Taan, the Tone, the Handeling but really She did it with so much Enthusiasam and I really Loved it, the ALAP, the Lyrics She gripped Everything so Well except the Accent in Some Words, She really Blast, I really see Her in Top Three Position at Victory stand...!⭐️⭐️


Entry 14: ABHI NA JAO CHOR KAR, Official track from the 60's Movie HUM DONO sung by RAFI Sahab and ASHA Jee, and RESUNG by SHERYA GHOSHAL in Movie MAUSAM, the Singer sung it Very well, the Stanza's really have that Flick which gives U Some Spark of Two Singers of Different Era's, I Admired the Voice Sweet and Swash voice with little Low Pitch, its really a Lovey Dovy Attempt...!👏⭐️


Entry 15: ABHI ABHI TOU MILY HO, Official track from the Movie JISM-2 sung by KK and SHERYA GHOSHAL, the Singer sung it with a Little Low Notes but with a Good Pace, I really Enjoyed the Pitch which She Raise with Ease without Scratching in Her Voice, I really Enjoyed Her Sweet, Nice and Neat Voice, Really Appreciatable Attempt...!👏👏


Now, I tried to give My Reviews, if it Hurts, I say SORRY from Bottom of My Heart and asking FORGIVENESS😊, if it gives U Encouragement, Support or Happiness, I really feel Satisfaction...😳

I think in this Contest Some Head to Head Fight between Entries numbers 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 14 and its really Flair a Cool Fire which Excited all members alot...😉😃

ASTO I only Suggest or say Requested that Plz if anyone Organize this Contest or any Singing Contest again in Forum, plz Allow All participant to Sing with KAROKE or without KAROKE...😊

I mean Compulsary the KAROKE for all participants or Banned for All who will take part, the Claw where Some Participants Used it and some not Use iit create Difficulties for Both, The Participants and Especially the Listener and Voters...😕

As u know any background Music gives a Flow, Rhythum either gives any Singer the ups and Downs and Notes of Starting and Finishing Yaar... U said in Rating Thread that We gives marks only on Voice Quality but its almost Imposible na, Plz from Next time, think on this Aspect as well na...😊

Edited by gadhadada - 12 years ago
visrom thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: gadhadada

ASTO I only Suggest or say Requested that Plz if anyone Organize this Contest or any Singing Contest again in Forum, plz Allow All participant to Sing with KAROKE or without KAROKE...😊

I mean Compulsary the KAROKE for all participants or Banned for All who will take part, the Claw where Some Participants Used it and some not Use iit create Difficulties for Both, The Participants and Especially the Listener and Voters...😕

As u know any background Music gives a Flow, Rhythum either gives any Singer the ups and Downs and Notes of Starting and Finishing Yaar... U said in Rating Thread that We gives marks only on Voice Quality but its almost Imposible na, Plz from Next time, think on this Aspect as well na...😊

Tthere are a few things...if someone decides a song, the karaoke may not be available. If it is available, the pitch may not be within the singer's range. So some singers may choose to sing without any karaoke.
But as you said, it may not be fair judge singers with karaoke and without karaoke on the same plane.
1. Singers without karaoke have to maintain their pitch and rhythm without any help. This is very tough. You may start at one pitch and end at another. Someone with a good knowledge of sur and taal can catch these easily.
2. Singers with karaoke have to sing along with a music over which they have no control. If they miss one word, the entire song will go out of control and they have to restart from the beginning.
I have seen singers being judged on both these rounds separately in Sonu Nigam's Sa Re Ga Ma in the 1990s.
Frankly I feel it's better to have 2 categories. Now it's left to Asto.
Edited by visrom - 12 years ago
.KupKakes thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: visrom

Tthere are a few things...if someone decides a song, the karaoke may not be available. If it is available, the pitch may not be within the singer's range. So some singers may choose to sing without any karaoke.

But as you said, it may not be fair judge singers with karaoke and without karaoke on the same plane.
1. Singers without karaoke have to maintain their pitch and rhythm without any help. This is very tough. You may start at one pitch and end at another. Someone with a good knowledge of sur and taal can catch these easily.
2. Singers with karaoke have to sing along with a music over which they have no control. If they miss one word, the entire song will go out of control and they have to restart from the beginning.
I have seen singers being judged on both these rounds separately in Sonu Nigam's Sa Re Ga Ma in the 1990s.
Frankly I feel it's better to have 2 categories. Now it's left to Asto.

I agree with you guys!
Though we may try to be unbiased, it is but natural for the human ear to favour the more pleasing one which might be at many times the one with karaoke.
And as Vis di mentioned, a karaoke singer will have some trouble if he goes wrong with even a single note. Even a quarter beat miss may spell disaster for the whole song!
But having 2 categories is not a practical option according to me because we have with difficulty something like 15 entries...!!
So 2 categories would mean no competition...
I think the best way is that next time, the organizer should clearly decide whether or not to allow karaoke. Leaving the option to the participants doesn't seem to work out!
Anyway, just my views... It's upto Asto di to decide...😃
visrom thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
See it's still possible...the marks are given as usual...then Asto can post winners in both categories. It's not going to cause any trouble. It's left to her anyway.
But if next time Asto says that only karaoke is allowed or karaoke is not allowed at all we'll not get so many participants. There'll be some 3 or 4...that's all. I have seen this in VM contests...where they give a tough theme with rules and very few are able to follow all rules.
So, it's better to leave it to participants, but declare winners in both categories.
.KupKakes thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: visrom

See it's still possible...the marks are given as usual...then Asto can post winners in both categories. It's not going to cause any trouble. It's left to her anyway.

But if next time Asto says that only karaoke is allowed or karaoke is not allowed at all we'll not get so many participants. There'll be some 3 or 4...that's all. I have seen this in VM contests...where they give a tough theme with rules and very few are able to follow all rules.
So, it's better to leave it to participants, but declare winners in both categories.

hmm...
u r right...
but still 15 se zada participants hona unlikely h
like abhi IF Idol me 2 categories karo to matlab h
but single forums me...
but still declaring winners in both categories is not a bad idea...
anyway its up to asto di so our discussion doesn't actually figure anywhere...😆

Related Topics

CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 Results

Hello everyone, it is with great pleasure that I announce the BC is now over and we have a fresh new banner for the forum! Firstly our runner-up...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

GossipTV: ACP Pradyuman to make grand re-entry soon

Chalo what we expected is happening. https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1910646926372118984

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1910646926372118984
Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

5 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 Voting

Hello everyone, It is time for the CID Banner Contest Voting round. Before you jump in, please do read the rules. You can vote for TWO Banners...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Minionite

6 months ago

CID Banner Contest 2025 (Date Extended)

Hello folks! With the return of CID we obviously need a new banner, so it's time for CID Banner Contest 2025. Before you jump in, please do read...

Expand ▼
CID Thumbnail
CID

Posted by: Nikita_99503

8 months ago

CID BTS/Spoilers & Social Media updates Thread #01

Hello everyone!!! Welcome to the CID BTS, Social Media updates and spoilers thread. Kindly share all updates regarding the show here in this...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".