Are we responsible for making/breaking CB?

gardes thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I know I have been negative about the episodes in recent months and there is a reason behind it. No, not the usual negative blah, blah, blah about DJs and Zee TV Creative teams.
This time it is with less disdain and more sympathy. Yes, really! Me! 😉
My reason for being negative until recently was that the Creative team had a short term plan on this story that never went beyond the wedding. They thought that adding some formula stuff will keep them in the limelight. Well, it did not work out that ways!
Since none of the other characters were ever developed, the Creative team was and is restricted in developing stories around Dev and Radhika only . The leads and the other characters are twisted to fit the story, making it go nowhere but in circles.
The TRPs have plummeted and now the show is being overhauled. If you pay close attention to recent episodes, the Creatives are trying to get away from the whole Vrindavan and RP theme and overhauling the characters.
Why? Because.....
We did not like the ONS track, we pointed to violating Kaanha and Vrindavan theme and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
We did not like the idea of Shaantanu leering Radhika, pointed to Radhika and Dev's eternal and divine love and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
We saw that some were meted out Kaanha's justice, others went scot free and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
Radhika being forced into widowhood was gruesome to watch and we went tsk, tsk, tsk!
The famous Mishti circles are introduced and the tsk, tsk, tsk, starts at each attempt!
Lately every attempt they make to chase the TRPs, we go tsk, tsk, tsk at the Creatives!
It seems that we the forumers have trapped the Creative teams in their own Chakravyuh. I have not watched recent episodes with as much interest and have not watched since last week at all due to family committments, but I have read updates and MIs almost daily.
Slowly and steadily, I have noticed that there is less and less Kaanha involvement. There are less rituals, less aarti and mostly, they moved from under the RP umbrella in Delhi and now Vrindavan and moved to Agra. This will allow the Creatives to introduce more and more formula stuff in their chase after the all-elusive TRPs. It will give them the freedom to take liberties with the characters, let go of some and introduce some new ones.
If anyone believes that this story will revert back to old Vrindavan, Kaanha Bhakt and divine love story, think again. Forget Dev and Radhika and their divine love. Forget how the story started in December 2008. Forget RPship. The Creatives JUST CANNOT SUSTAIN THE THEME ANY MORE!!
It ain't happening, folks! You are in for a chilla-chaalu soap opera with triangles and shifting characters. The fact that they are dependent on us to provide fodder says a lot. Dev and Radhika will struggle and the story will be like any other soap opera on TV these days.
I, for one, will watch when I can and read when I can't watch. All I can say is, please stop looking for logic or continuity. The Creatives are trapped and the standard soap opear route is all that they can produce!
Poor dears! 😃

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.9k

Users

10

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

JustShanta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: gardes

I know I have been negative about the episodes in recent months and there is a reason behind it. No, not the usual negative blah, blah, blah about DJs and Zee TV Creative teams.

This time it is with less disdain and more sympathy. Yes, really! Me! 😉
My reason for being negative until recently was that the Creative team had a short term plan on this story that never went beyond the wedding. They thought that adding some formula stuff will keep them in the limelight. Well, it did not work out that ways!
Since none of the other characters were ever developed, the Creative team was and is restricted in developing stories around Dev and Radhika only . The leads and the other characters are twisted to fit the story, making it go nowhere but in circles.
The TRPs have plummeted and now the show is being overhauled. If you pay close attention to recent episodes, the Creatives are trying to get away from the whole Vrindavan and RP theme and overhauling the characters.
Why? Because.....
We did not like the ONS track, we pointed to violating Kaanha and Vrindavan theme and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
We did not like the idea of Shaantanu leering Radhika, pointed to Radhika and Dev's eternal and divine love and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
We saw that some were meted out Kaanha's justice, others went scot free and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
Radhika being forced into widowhood was gruesome to watch and we went tsk, tsk, tsk!
The famous Mishti circles are introduced and the tsk, tsk, tsk, starts at each attempt!
Lately every attempt they make to chase the TRPs, we go tsk, tsk, tsk at the Creatives!
It seems that we the forumers have trapped the Creative teams in their own Chakravyuh. I have not watched recent episodes with as much interest and have not watched since last week at all due to family committments, but I have read updates and MIs almost daily.
Slowly and steadily, I have noticed that there is less and less Kaanha involvement. There are less rituals, less aarti and mostly, they moved from under the RP umbrella in Delhi and now Vrindavan and moved to Agra. This will allow the Creatives to introduce more and more formula stuff in their chase after the all-elusive TRPs. It will give them the freedom to take liberties with the characters, let go of some and introduce some new ones.
think again. Forget Dev
If anyone believes that this story will revert back to old Vrindavan, Kaanha Bhakt and divine love story, and Radhika and their divine love. Forget how the story started in December 2008. Forget RPship. The Creatives JUST CANNOT SUSTAIN THE THEME ANY MORE!!
It ain't happening, folks! You are in for a chilla-chaalu soap opera with triangles and shifting characters. The fact that they are dependent on us to provide fodder says a lot. Dev and Radhika will struggle and the story will be like any other soap opera on TV these days.
I, for one, will watch when I can and read when I can't watch. All I can say is, please stop looking for logic or continuity. The Creatives are trapped and the standard soap opear route is all that they can produce!
Poor dears! 😃



im so scared now

Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Gardes,

I agree with your last comments about it moving away from the divine love, bhakti etc to more typical soap stories. So, we should not compare it with last year. I also have a feeling that creatives are looking at an end date for this show and maybe in last 15 days of the show, they will show Dev getting RP, everyone becoming good (even Amma as it is related to typical soap type story with no punishment), Dev and Radhika getting reunited and living happily ever after. They may even show them having a waaris where they will completely forget their waaris story. It is meaningless in any case now.
However, I don't agree that we forum viewers trapped them into a chakravyuh. They did it to themselves as they got greedy (by they I mean the production house and the channel) and started going over these weekly tracks for their ratings. The viewers hated burning track, but they showed it anyway. I wasn't disappointed with Shantanu leering at Radhika, but more with his inconsistent portrayal of stalker, Karan and an evil person. In fact, he could have cared and even loved Radhika, but if they had shown proper reasons for it - stuck by Radhika's innocence and beauty, jealousy of Dev and affinity with Radhika for being abandoned by her family and still having that goodness in her. They could have easily shown him going after Radhika as he wanted to take the most precious things from Dev - the pampered prince. It was his stalkish characterization as well as the evilness in killing Dev combined with the gruesome torture of Radhika during the widow ceremony which didn't go with PF's history that didn't sit well with the audience and the ratings fell. They didn't develop the characters of PF members as they wanted to keep their two favorite characters - Amma and Vishaka for ever and that brought down the ratings.
In any case, I have now no expectations of the previous greatness from this show. All the shows become really typical soap after one year anyway. I used to watch Agle Janam, but I have stopped watching it as it is not good anymore. Fortunately, I was attached to the story and not the main characters, so it is easy to stop watching it. With CB, I got attached not only to the story, but also to Dev and Radhika and hence am unable to give it up for now unless it becomes too unbearable. So, I still watch it even if I end up fast forwarding most of it. Once it closes shop, it would be over for me as far as the soap world is concerned (unless they come up with another unique new show).
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
gardes,
Yes, I understand the part when you said, this time you are writing with less disdain and more sympathy ...bcos I have almost reached that stage myself too.

With so much crap, now I don't even feel like reading or writing on the forum. Whats the point.

I agree, they did not develop any other character initially and concentrated only on Dev & Rad .. but since they had such a solid material at hand, they were good for so many months. Still even during those times, some people really got fed up of Radhika and left the show.

Now, after they have exhausted their solid material, they tried all the "antics" they could , (to which I give 0 marks) and they failed miserably, the all-time low TRPs as the proof. Here again instead of writing something good, they tell themselves what the formula was for their good TRPs earlier and chalk out a plan to do the same with a slight twist that makes it happen (which is accident and memory loss crap).

So, with this accident and memory loss, they can separate Dev & rad though keep them close and make one pursue the other. For this Shantanu was made the bali-ka-bakra and hence they did not give importance to Shantanu-vaishali tracks. ONS backfired and rightly so, bcos of the range of audience they have for this show. Bride set afire for no reason. Everything forgotten and forgiven very simply.

Hence, can I say they are not planning? No, they are planning, but in a wrong direction. They don't read the comments they should and they don't take the TRPs the way they should. I just pity them for this kind of thinking. Thats all. So, all these days of Radhika shooting her mouth off was to say their crappy story ahead.

Now, they are again back to showing Radhika bechari and mahaan ... super-imposing their story.

BTW, I read that they have dismantled the set which was PB earlier, so the story will not be going back there, going forward. So, they aren't going to close any of the loose ends that they have created in the last 1 month just like they haven't shown closing of a lot of dangling storylines. As number of viewer, there would be that many view points. There are a lot of things thats written on forum, but can't they in their full sense pick what is right for their theme of story and continue to say that? I agree to you fully when you say that the forumers have trapped the Creative teams in their own chakravyuh and actually this is what I was thinking since the last few days .. and Yes, I say the same .. tsk tsk tsk!

And being on air for one of years (as someone said) is no reason to have this poor show in the recent past. The shoddy work is bcos of a reason that goes way long back. Some of the shows that enjoy the higher TRPs are bcos of a reason and its high time the DJs stop this shoddy work and give this serial a decent ending that they started in the name of Kanha.


bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Why3,
I just read your comments after I posted mine and wanted to clarify that I wasn't referring to you when I wrote one of the stmts that seems its against what you are saying.

misti73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: gardes

I know I have been negative about the episodes in recent months and there is a reason behind it. No, not the usual negative blah, blah, blah about DJs and Zee TV Creative teams.

Gardes you being negative?......from my point of view you are being realistic......being realistic is different from being negative....this is how I think and interpret your writings.
This time it is with less disdain and more sympathy. Yes, really! Me! 😉
My reason for being negative until recently was that the Creative team had a short term plan on this story that never went beyond the wedding. They thought that adding some formula stuff will keep them in the limelight. Well, it did not work out that ways!
Since none of the other characters were ever developed, the Creative team was and is restricted in developing stories around Dev and Radhika only . The leads and the other characters are twisted to fit the story, making it go nowhere but in circles.
This is also one of the resons for their failure as creatives.....not developing the secondary characters.......any decent screenplay writer knows that a drama serial cannot go on for more than a year just around the central characters........it can only go around the central characters if these characters are distorted or made weak and thats what the CB creatives are doing.....they still have the scope to develop the secondary characters.......but do they have the guts for it because that would mean giving up on TRPs for some weeks and just spending time with character developement.......or do these creatives have that capability?
The TRPs have plummeted and now the show is being overhauled. If you pay close attention to recent episodes, the Creatives are trying to get away from the whole Vrindavan and RP theme and overhauling the characters.
Why? Because.....
We did not like the ONS track, we pointed to violating Kaanha and Vrindavan theme and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
ONS track was the creatives decision and not ours........if they as creatives had realised what CB was all about then they would not have taken that route.....they chose a track which clashed with CB main story and hence the audience left and TRPS plumetted........so thats not our fault.
We did not like the idea of Shaantanu leering Radhika, pointed to Radhika and Dev's eternal and divine love and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
Actually the creatives lost a golden oppurtunity with Shantanus track....if only they had used Shantanu as a psychological weapon...........and not a stick beating murderer the track would have become interesting......but again the creatives were more interested in the TRPs so kept on changing Shantanu as per TRPs and that messed up the track. Personally I lost interest because I got confused as to what Shantanu is in this story.
We saw that some were meted out Kaanha's justice, others went scot free and went tsk, tsk, tsk!
Again inconsistency shown by the creatives, confusing the audience and driving them away.
Radhika being forced into widowhood was gruesome to watch and we went tsk, tsk, tsk!
Using regressive rituals will drive people away.
The famous Mishti circles are introduced and the tsk, tsk, tsk, starts at each attempt!
Ah my circles.......actually they are not mine, they are the creatives......I just picked them up........I actually don't mind the circles.......infact if they use it properly then they can get tracks out of them even now......but the circles do make the story boring, becuase the audience can predict what is going to happen.
Lately every attempt they make to chase the TRPs, we go tsk, tsk, tsk at the Creatives!
Well if the attempts are ridiculous then the audience will go tsk tsk....
It seems that we the forumers have trapped the Creative teams in their own Chakravyuh. I have not watched recent episodes with as much interest and have not watched since last week at all due to family committments, but I have read updates and MIs almost daily.
I am not with you on this one....it is the creatives who have trapped themselves into this chkravyuh and it started from July last year.......when they started playing with the characters and the story line......The problem was they never expected his serial to be so popular so were not prepared when the TRPs started coming in......and once they got addicted to the high TRPs it became quite difficult for them to get over this addiction.
Slowly and steadily, I have noticed that there is less and less Kaanha involvement. There are less rituals, less aarti and mostly, they moved from under the RP umbrella in Delhi and now Vrindavan and moved to Agra. This will allow the Creatives to introduce more and more formula stuff in their chase after the all-elusive TRPs. It will give them the freedom to take liberties with the characters, let go of some and introduce some new ones.
If anyone believes that this story will revert back to old Vrindavan, Kaanha Bhakt and divine love story, think again. Forget Dev and Radhika and their divine love. Forget how the story started in December 2008. Forget RPship. The Creatives JUST CANNOT SUSTAIN THE THEME ANY MORE!!
It ain't happening, folks! You are in for a chilla-chaalu soap opera with triangles and shifting characters. The fact that they are dependent on us to provide fodder says a lot. Dev and Radhika will struggle and the story will be like any other soap opera on TV these days.
Yes it is true that the spiritual aspect has gone and now it is more the normal soap formula.......this two women and one man is the current in fashion formula. But there is still scope for it to recover........but as I have said before for that to happen the creatives have to forget about TRPS for some weeks.........also I don't think it is possible by this current group of creatives...........for that they need to spend money and get some good writers, which for some reason they are not interesed in doing.
I, for one, will watch when I can and read when I can't watch. All I can say is, please stop looking for logic or continuity. The Creatives are trapped and the standard soap opear route is all that they can produce!
Well I have my humour.😉
Poor dears! 😃
😉

gardes thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Shanta, what is there to be scared about? The original story will always be there to fall back on. A triangle is already in the making but we also know the outcome down the line. Don't worry. It is only a soap opera!
gardes thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: bee5

gardes,
Yes, I understand the part when you said, this time you are writing with less disdain and more sympathy ...bcos I have almost reached that stage myself too.

With so much crap, now I don't even feel like reading or writing on the forum. Whats the point.

I agree, they did not develop any other character initially and concentrated only on Dev & Rad .. but since they had such a solid material at hand, they were good for so many months. Still even during those times, some people really got fed up of Radhika and left the show.

Now, after they have exhausted their solid material, they tried all the "antics" they could , (to which I give 0 marks) and they failed miserably, the all-time low TRPs as the proof. Here again instead of writing something good, they tell themselves what the formula was for their good TRPs earlier and chalk out a plan to do the same with a slight twist that makes it happen (which is accident and memory loss crap).

So, with this accident and memory loss, they can separate Dev & rad though keep them close and make one pursue the other. For this Shantanu was made the bali-ka-bakra and hence they did not give importance to Shantanu-vaishali tracks. ONS backfired and rightly so, bcos of the range of audience they have for this show. Bride set afire for no reason. Everything forgotten and forgiven very simply.

Hence, can I say they are not planning? No, they are planning, but in a wrong direction. They don't read the comments they should and they don't take the TRPs the way they should. I just pity them for this kind of thinking. Thats all. So, all these days of Radhika shooting her mouth off was to say their crappy story ahead.

Now, they are again back to showing Radhika bechari and mahaan ... super-imposing their story.

BTW, I read that they have dismantled the set which was PB earlier, so the story will not be going back there, going forward. So, they aren't going to close any of the loose ends that they have created in the last 1 month just like they haven't shown closing of a lot of dangling storylines. As number of viewer, there would be that many view points. There are a lot of things thats written on forum, but can't they in their full sense pick what is right for their theme of story and continue to say that? I agree to you fully when you say that the forumers have trapped the Creative teams in their own chakravyuh and actually this is what I was thinking since the last few days .. and Yes, I say the same .. tsk tsk tsk!

And being on air for one of years (as someone said) is no reason to have this poor show in the recent past. The shoddy work is bcos of a reason that goes way long back. Some of the shows that enjoy the higher TRPs are bcos of a reason and its high time the DJs stop this shoddy work and give this serial a decent ending that they started in the name of Kanha.


Bee, you understood and elaborated on my thoughts and explained them away well. Thanks. The Creatives are counterbalancing the predictability of the stories with something way out there and failing miserably. Loose ends galore, senseless tracks, what else is left anymore? What a pity!
Naivedya thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
Gardes EXCELLENT post! You and Why3 echo my sentiments exactly. I agree with her that we viewers did not break CB, the unintelligent, uncreative makers did that on their own. We even openly invited them to come here and blatantly copy our members' ideas to use in the show...heck, Misti and evasumi even wrote dialogues and script ideas for them to use! Unfortunately they took what they thought useful, twisted it around until all circulation was cut off and the track fizzled and died, then started playing "ring around the roses" with us. As you said, the supporting characters were never developed and the writers made RaDev flip flop so much in their behaviour that all things about them that should've remained consistent often did not. The quality of the writing plunged after Damini Shetty left and the directing and editing was usually sub par too. The show really lost significance for me at the time of the ONS. The burning track and portrayal of Kanha's attitude towards his most ardent devotee did not sit well with me, but I hung on because I knew Dev would be shown doing right by Radhika and marrying her. But when Vishaka's shaky return and mysterious goonda chases started, the show became stale for me, and her character was completely destroyed when she brought up the divorce papers, forced her way into PB, and eventually propositioned Dev. With Shantanu's entry, I was hoping for a powerful Mahabharat-style track which would culminate in a brotherly reunion of Dev and Shantanu brought on by Radhika reforming Shantanu. Again I was terribly disappointed with the sudden and untimley accident of Dev and death of Shantanu. In all honesty I just cannot be upset about or emotionally invested in this show anymore. I watch only for Avinash and Rubina because I love and admire them and feel that they work extremely hard to entertain their fans/audiences. After reading dg86's post about her visit to the sets witnessing first hand the below average working conditions and without-warning call times (Avi wasn't supposed to be shooting one day but happened to be on set and was suddenly roped in to shoot a dream sequence!) I really feel for Avina. They are so young and their lives are consumed by CB. For me this show lost its charm a long time ago and I feed my desire for a dose of CB by turning to the old episodes. Thankfully I have them archived on dvd so I can get my fix for the old glory days whenever I want to!
Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bee5

Why3,
I just read your comments after I posted mine and wanted to clarify that I wasn't referring to you when I wrote one of the stmts that seems its against what you are saying.

Bee, I didn't take offense at any of your stuff as what you said is true anyway. Also, I have posted similar comments many times because sometimes two people are writing at the same time and hence don't read other's comments. As far as this show is concerned, I agree that just because it is one and a half year old, there is no excuse for this kind of story. But, it seems to be a norm these days in soap world due to competing channels, short attention span and what not. So, all of them want to make a quick buck. When a story starts, there is some initial plan that works up to a year if it is a good story to begin with. Afterwards, the success of it goes to creatives' and channel's head and they start playing with it to get more money. They know that if it fails, they can always go to the next show and so on. Who cares about the viewers. Since all the channels do the same, viewers end up watching garbage anyway. If a story is good, viewers get attached to a particular show one for one reason or the other and watch it until it gets cancelled.
I could never understand the attachment people had towards any TV show. I myself watched CB on and off until July (didn't miss a episode in April and May, but skipped some in June and July) of last year. I too was one of the viewers who lost sympathy for Radhika in June and July with her behavior towards Dev. But since I had liked her in the beginning, I kind of stuck around hoping that once she is reunited with Dev, her character would show growth. I sort of got attached to the show when I started participating in the forum around end of October and there were several good episodes at that time. I also got attached to the pairing of Dev and Radhika and were rooting for them to be happy. The story of none of other shows excited me to get involved with any of them. In other words, somehow the forum, story of this show, pairing of Dev and RAdhika got me attached to the show and I am unable to totally cut myself off from it. But, I know the show is not going to last beyond this year based on the storylines they have shown this year. So, I am ok having this partial attachment (call it a habit) towards the show. Also, I have made several friends here and like to read their views.
I am not that attached that I get upset with it anymore (burning track and ONS were the ones that really made me mad). If I want to remember the good old days, I just watch few of the last year's episode. In any case, I am still hoping that they will not stretch this track too much and won't show stupidity such as 5 year leap and "fake" clingy wife for 5 years.Also, I am hoping that the creatives may still end it at a high note even though the probability of that happening is close to 0.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".