What a MOTHER! Waah! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

1.9k

Users

9

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

Anchit thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Agree Divya that going to hospital is important than pooja.. And assume CC is not aware of time, in that case did CV's not make of mistake of giving some dialogues to CC to defend or support her case? To educate that going to doc is important than pooja.. May be they will show it in next episodes.. but as of now the message is incomplete and shown as UB is right and she came down to an extent that she is fine taking kids to hospital

But just out of my curiosity, it was only vaccination right which could waited at least till evening or so.. And moreover it is not like vaccination start reacting immediately it would take couple of weeks. So there was an interaction with other kids who has Chicken pox, this vaccination will not hel., pls correct me if am wrong

My only point here is to CV not to show CC that innocent , give strong dialogues to counter UB

Originally posted by: DiyaS



And holding a puja to prevent chicken pox is an emergency?!😲

I don't think Chhanchhan knew there was a particular time for the puja ... and being a doc I am completely sceptical of pujas as holding any relevance whatsoever in warding off illnesses. Puja is the least important thing as far as preventing chicken pox is concerned ... it definitely comes lower on the emergency scale than a visit to a doctor. Even bath with neem water and using neem leaves on the bed is more useful than a visit to Sheetla mata's temple - those remedies I agree with ... having blind faith in temples and pujas to ward off illness is stupidity! The temple visit and puja is ONLY to satisfy Umaben's superstitions, it has NO other relevance whatsoever!

Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
^ u r right unchit... the vaccine takes time to make a body immune... correct me if i am wrong... and chicken pox spread during the peel off session... i dont think the vaccine would be of any help even if the effected kid had recently...

i might be wrong.. but this is the knowledge i have and i suffered from chicken pox my self when i was a kid... after day 7-10 the peel of session starts and total thing lasts for 21 days.
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Anchit

Agree Divya that going to hospital is important than pooja.. And assume CC is not aware of time, in that case did CV's not make of mistake of giving some dialogues to CC to defend or support her case? To educate that going to doc is important than pooja.. May be they will show it in next episodes.. but as of now the message is incomplete and shown as UB is right and she came down to an extent that she is fine taking kids to hospital

But just out of my curiosity, it was only vaccination right which could waited at least till evening or so.. And moreover it is not like vaccination start reacting immediately it would take couple of weeks. So there was an interaction with other kids who has Chicken pox, this vaccination will not hel., pls correct me if am wrong

My only point here is to CV not to show CC that innocent , give strong dialogues to counter UB



Re your last point, I agree ... they should have given some strong dialogue to Chhanchhan to the effect that she did not know the time of pooja, they got held up otherwise they would have been back on time, and she did feel that getting the shots was more important than the pooja ...

Regarding vaccination ... if the kids were being given immunoglobulin as preventive, which would be the case here, then it IS important to give it as soon as possible, definitely withing 24-48 hours, but the sooner the better. Since this was a post-exposure preventive, it would be the immunoglobulin now, and the regular vaccination later. Hence the sooner the better, and definitely taking precedence over any poojas!

The flip side is that normally if kids are exposed to chicken pox, if they are in good health, immunoglobulin is not really required ... UNLESS there are other susceptible people in the house who could get the infection, among which include pregnant women, or women who might be pregnant in very early stages - that's when infection is the most dangerous, when they might not even know yet they are pregnant. And with four young bahus in the house, that is always a possibility.

Besides the kids had apparently not received any vaccinations at all after one year of age, so they were way behind! Starting off the backlog of missed shots certainly ranks higher in importance in my mind than any pooja. Shots will have some benefit ... pooja has none ... it is ONLY for the benefit of Umaben's superstitions ... no other reason. I see no reason to pander to such beliefs at all ... they are to be discouraged ... and the first step is to show that they are unimportant.

I hope that some of the kids' friends who have religiously gone through the poojas at the right time and ignored their shots, actually get the disease, while these three kids stay safe ... hence Chhanchhan's point will be proved.

Umm ... I am Diya ... not Divya 😛
Edited by DiyaS - 12 years ago
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: appy_indy-KD

^ u r right unchit... the vaccine takes time to make a body immune... correct me if i am wrong... and chicken pox spread during the peel off session... i dont think the vaccine would be of any help even if the effected kid had recently...


i might be wrong.. but this is the knowledge i have and i suffered from chicken pox my self when i was a kid... after day 7-10 the peel of session starts and total thing lasts for 21 days.



No appy, chicken pox is infectious from before the rash even appears till the vesicles are wet, or filled with fluid. Once all of them are dry, it is not infectious. The fluid in the vesicles contains live virus which is infectious.
Beauceant thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: appy_indy-KD


no offense but are you a mother yourself? i am sure you are not seeing this statement... i would say when you become one then you would understand what i have mentioned... 😊

it is insane to ask such a thing what Uma ben is shown at that crucial moment... there was not even a bit of concern... she didnot check with chhanchhan also whether her son was fine for not. a mother never assumes

None taken. And no, i'm not a mother jus a member of the audience of indian tv shows who is too used to justify or condone watever nonsense they show.. So much that now its a reflex😊 Dint mean to say u weren't right with wat u said, which is wat i mentioned in the second part-- not jus UB even Ranjana n Kaumudi should ve been shown to be concerned abt their kids' welfare.
Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Msfrootie

None taken. And no, i'm not a mother jus a member of the audience of indian tv shows who is too used to justify or condone watever nonsense they show.. So much that now its a reflex😊 Dint mean to say u weren't right with wat u said, which is wat i mentioned in the second part-- not jus UB even Ranjana n Kaumudi should ve been shown to be concerned abt their kids' welfare.


i had just answered UB's part... as ranjana and sanjana are immaterial in the show. they are just their i dont expect directors to elaborate on their role... 😆
kairavi. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
I agree it would have been nice for UB to show a little more concern for both CC and Manav but I don't think it was the end of the world that she didn't because neither had any sign of an injury plus they were coming back from the hospital where they had taken the other driver because she was hurt.
The pace of this show is fast and because of that may be losing out on some depth emotionally but honestly for this scene if it was a choice between this and a scene in which we had to see the reaction of each person in the room 3 times and everyone hovering over Manav looking for non existant wounds then I prefer what we got.
I forgot to say that at that point Manav seemed to be fine and she was actually more concerned about her grandchildren not receiving the blessings she felt they needed for protection.

Edited by kairavi. - 12 years ago
lrlpam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
I feel the reason UB dint enquire further abt manav is dat she got to that it was the lady n not chhanman who met with accident n gt injured
Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
^ still... do you think a mother wont be concerned for her child's well being? and jumping into questioning session?
SpellofJoy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
haven't watched the ep

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".