I/O - And here we go!FreeSanayaholics! :p - Page 73

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

71.9k

Users

59

Likes

4k

Frequent Posters

aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: archana.mh17

Er... I am quite indifferent where Vivian is concerned but the guy has good fan following. And, it is Colors. He has a hit show with them. So, I don't see him getting sidelined. But they're screwing around too much with Sanaya's fans & it is becoming irritating. I don't know if it is because they want to use her popularity or some such thing but they are simply screwing around too much with her fans. And, Vivian is quite popular. He has a fandom that votes, too. Madan seems to slowly be getting sidelined. Or, I am just reading too much into crappy editing & absurd judging.


It is not only you Archana but most of us feel that the judging is ridiculous and they are absolutely scoring without any yardstick. What is applicable to one celeb is not applicable to another ...why so ?

I have several issues with how they have been scoring !
And yes I have big time issues with how VD is being over scored for no reason. It is out in the open and I cannot ignore it anymore. I have absolutely no issues to give credit where its due but not like this.

Last time , Kavita's prop or Mohit's too was way more difficult to handle. VD 's was good too I agree.

GH underscored Faisal despite dancing so amazingly citing there was no PROP use!! my question is why is there no deduction of marks if there is no or v less dance!! Again who comes into mind... VD!!

It's not like I am picking on him but I can't help it. They are shoving it down our throats and now its choking me !

Now this time...All performances on Saturday turn out to be WOW and none of the mentors feel the need to come onstage and demonstrate any step or show how a thing can be done differently!
Suddenly Lauren wants to see more and GH wants more drama !! Where was this mode on Saturday ! 😲

Sanaya deserved a 38 at least for this awesome performance and Mohit did not deserve 35 ! Bhawna needs to stop covering up for him right now and make him dance. The logic I read on the forum was that in a sensual dance no. there is not much for the male actor to do ...really ?
Please check performances in the past !! This is a v lame excuse !
I was ogling at the screen when her act started and then bam !! AD break ... it was so stupid really. They have repeated this strategy and it clears says they are using her to keep attention to the program intact !

I really really hope and pray things change for good.
Edited by aaliah3108 - 10 years ago
Rummykub thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
This is my first jdj so I would like to know how the judging is done.
I feel the problem basically lies in having four judges . It's maybe one too many. And no mutual consulting between them before judging a contestant.
It's not a live program right? So does the contestant get scores from all the four judges immediately after their act or are they marked after all the acts have finished. Is the marking done as standalone meaning just considering the contestants current act and their progression or is it marked in comparison to all the other contestants too who have performed?
I hope I am able to express myself here
While judging I feel all four of the judges should sit and mark the contestants only after all the acts have been performed . They need to make sure they consider all aspects of the act and come up with a final score out of 40 that reflects the overall worth of the act in comparison with other acts.
I don't think that is how it's done n that's why all this inconsistency and disparity is seen in the judging?
What say?
ShreeJaya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: archana.mh17

You gotta hand it to VD's fans, though. They seem to be taking all the criticism for VD being overscored like champs. I mean, I saw a couple of them making the same observation about the performance as others did, despite being his fans. So, that seems to be a cool bunch. I felt that she was being taken away from focus probably because she was so under focus in the initial weeks. And, the thing is, quite often, people who are working on other shows simultaneously have their performances on Saturday is what I heard. All hearsay, this. We can only speculate, at best, now.


VD fans in jhalak forum..are too good they don't get into bashing stuff..and they will only get surprised when he dance just 2 /3 steps !!! I like his 3rd week act!!!
Their 1st AT title was papu can't dance saal... They are taking this journey of their hero..in very cool way...
rehann thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: VIMAL.M

Colors want SI's star value for profit making .


Seeing Colors tactics I think they don't consider VD N RM has huge star value like SI.

They released sneak-peak without mentioning the episode no.Which they did previous week.So they wanted SI fans to watch Saturday episode also in a curiosity whether SI will perform or not.

Yest they did not show any ad breaks.As soon as SI act started.Ad break started .

Previous week SI performance was on Sunday but in every ad-break SI dance was showed as coming up.

They r using SI for the channel benefit.

I am worried .

Yeah I noticed that too... but from the seasons that I watched... the winner of JDJ maybe not the best but a good dancer... gurmeet, drashti, Ashish.

The same quality only match Sanaya... That's the reason they make her journey more crystal clear for the viewers... The journey of a non-dancer to a great dancer...

VD? he not even come near to that... I believe It's Colors tactics as they already predict the top 3/4 who will reach finale... and with VD's number of fans... they believe VD will stay until finale... how to make his stay more convince... they use this ladoos tactics...

In Finale stage I don't believe Colors will choose a winner who can't dance... and with Sanz's number of fans and popularity. I guess only hardworks needed and the trophy will be in her hand.
VIMAL.SM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
@Rehan - Hoping for the best .
archana.mh17 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: aaliah3108


It is not only you Archana but most of us feel that the judging is ridiculous and they are absolutely scoring without any yardstick. What is applicable to one celeb is not applicable to another ...why so ?

I have several issues with how they have been scoring !
And yes I have big time issues with how VD is being over scored for no reason. It is out in the open and I cannot ignore it anymore. I have absolutely no issues to give credit where its due but not like this.

Last time , Kavita's prop or Mohit's too was way more difficult to handle. VD 's was good too I agree.

GH underscored Faisal despite dancing so amazingly citing there was no PROP use!! my question is why is there no deduction of marks if there is no or v less dance!! Again who comes into mind... VD!!

It's not like I am picking on him but I can't help it. They are shoving it down our throats and now its choking me !

Now this time...All performances on Saturday turn out to be WOW and none of the mentors feel the need to come onstage and demonstrate any step or show how a thing can be done differently!
Suddenly Lauren wants to see more and GH wants more drama !! Where was this mode on Saturday ! 😲

Sanaya deserved a 38 at least for this awesome performance and Mohit did not deserve 35 ! Bhawna needs to stop covering up for him right now and make him dance. The logic I read on the forum was that in a sensual dance no. there is not much for the male actor to do ...really ?
Please check performances in the past !! This is a v lame excuse !
I was ogling at the screen when her act started and then bam !! AD break ... it was so stupid really. They have repeated this strategy and it clears says they are using her to keep attention to the program intact !

I really really hope and pray things change for good.

Honestly, I didn't think I would say this but the previous seasons' judging panel was much less absurd in their scoring. And, Mohit, poor guy, is always underscored. Vivian-the previous week was scored fine, he got a 36, I think. The prop was very difficult to handle but Mohit's was difficult because it required so much precision but Lauren decided to hand him a 9/10 & give Scarlett's act, which was scored 8/10 by others a 10/10! Like, what the hell was that! And, yes, I heard about the excuse being given for Vivian's non dancing in the episode. I haven't watched the performance, but the male is hardly passive in a sensual performance, at least not if the choreographer knows what to do. And, Bhawna is too bloody clever for her own good. While she made Tacker a brilliant dancer in the previous season, she is conveniently hiding Vivian's two left feet in this season. It is all getting extremely haphazard! And, for God's sake, can they stop pushing Sanaya's act to the last! Who even edits these things! Ads cut through her performances! And, her performances are usually the last or second to last! It isn't funny. They're screwing around with the scoring & editing. They better start rectifying these mistakes before they cost them their regular viewers. The fans will catch it, but not much of it will reflect in their ratings if the common people don't watch it. And, with such absurdity, I don't see why anyone would want to spend two weekend evenings on such a show.
rehann thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: VIMAL.M

@Rehan - Hoping for the best .

Yes hoping for the best... this week is the only biased week we have witness till now. I feel another reason that they gave 40 to VD is to balance the marks between 2 teams. one team was trained dancer and one team was non-dancer. At first maybe the ladoos place was for Shamita but she got into accident. hahaha maybe.😆
aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

@ archana : Thats true. Judging in all previous seasons I wont say has been upto the mark but this time it has gaping loopholes.
He got 38 not 36 dear. 😕

And I also want them to stop calling SAN as toothpick, candy bar etc or synonyms of being thin...it's like they have kind of shortlisted what all you can call her !

It's not humorous anymore ...its irritating and makes me angry. I am like...oh please not again !

Sigh!!! so much ranting I have done since last night..I am really tired.
Why are they not doing things correctly ?
archana.mh17 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
@Aaliah-I believe some people brought it to Manish's notice that their idea of humour isn't going down well with people. I mean, one should simply not make body image & body types as the sole source of all humour. The sad part is even the most popular stand-comedians don't know how to make people laugh without offending a section of them. The scriptwriter should really think & write. Not just Sanaya's section, the crassness in the whole drooling-over-the-American-woman is downright unpalatable. And, VD's previous week's performance was a tough one with a tough prop & he, actually danced, too. My issue with that week had been how they underscored Sanaya's act, & didn't give Mohit the perfect 40 that the man had earned.
aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: archana.mh17

@Aaliah-I believe some people brought it to Manish's notice that their idea of humour isn't going down well with people. I mean, one should simply not make body image & body types as the sole source of all humour. The sad part is even the most popular stand-comedians don't know how to make people laugh without offending a section of them. The scriptwriter should really think & write. Not just Sanaya's section, the crassness in the whole drooling-over-the-American-woman is downright unpalatable. And, VD's previous week's performance was a tough one with a tough prop & he, actually danced, too. My issue with that week had been how they underscored Sanaya's act, & didn't give Mohit the perfect 40 that the man had earned.


hey !! me is Ruchi !! 😃 aaliah is just a pseudo name on IF.

If it has been brought to Manish's notice then nothing like it and we will get to see how things go on from here in this perspective ! It would be good if the humor based on body image gets reduced.
Completely agree over the excessive drooling over the American women , it should not be encouraged in the manner its being done !
His last week's performance was better and I can even live with a 38 he got that time but not this one! and why everytime ...

Well they are over critical of her and you know I am kind of happy she is settling in the game slowly and is moving towards the ultimate prize because that is what growth actually is from a non - dancer to a dancer ! Her journey cannot be questioned by non fans either because she is improving and is also getting scored which in a way is making her put in more hard work. I am sure her hard work will pay off.

Still being a fan, give her a 40 so that I can do a happy dance too !! 😆If everyone is getting sweets, why we be left out.

As for Mohit, please give the guy a fair chance. He is indeed showing superlative improvement !


Edited by aaliah3108 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".