*Incognito Critics* #66 ~Invite Only~ COTW Pg 78 - Page 73

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

40.1k

Users

20

Frequent Posters

U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
Ok back :)
Ok guys, so we're having this debate in the debate mansion section. Should prostitution be legalized ?
what do you all think ?
293418 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
Neeta, I feel the same way about the issue that you do to be honest. Great post, there. But I will say that there is too much human trafficking in the world to begin with. And I don't even know if legalization will solve those problems. Of course, I did have a problem with some people equating homosexuality to prostitution. Those literally made me put my face in my hands.
To be honest, I have read alot of accounts of people, who choose to do in Nevada, where it is legal, have negative experiences. A moral matter is different than a legal one, but I guess the other problem is when it becomes legal in a country then pimps do kidnap and trick people from other places into it for money. There are so many pros and cons either way.
.driftingaway thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
lizz !!! dont leave ok ! .. im so bored =(
so wassup ?
U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: dizzyonlemonade

Neeta, I feel the same way about the issue that you do to be honest. Great post, there. But I will say that there is too much human trafficking in the world to begin with. And I don't even know if legalization will solve those problems. Of course, I did have a problem with some people equating homosexuality to prostitution. Those literally made me put my face in my hands.
To be honest, I have read alot of accounts of people, who choose to do in Nevada, where it is legal, have negative experiences. A moral matter is different than a legal one, but I guess the other problem is when it becomes legal in a country then pimps do kidnap and trick people from other places into it for money. There are so many pros and cons either way.

Legalization will defenitely not help decrease prostitution, but then, neither will the absence of it. Making it legal will simply provide a legal back-up to the people who are by choice or by persuasion, in this field. Access to basic rights like - Right to live in any respectable residential area, right to file a police complaint if someone ( a customer, for instance ) misbehaves, Right to demand their rightful pay, Right to say 'No' to provide services if someone refuses to use protection etc.
I think pimps trick people into this profession regardless. I agree that legalization might give a boost to pimps, but another positive aspect of legalization is that no one will be able to force someone to enter. Tricking someone is a different thing, I think it exists regardless of any rule or law. Perhaps because pimps are the 'hidden' identities. It is always the prostitutes that get into trouble. Pimps are more difficult to locate.
Edited by -Neetz- - 16 years ago
U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: KashFanatic

lizz !!! dont leave ok ! .. im so bored =(

so wassup ?

nofing mch..jst hving a debate in da DM section. wnna join ?
.driftingaway thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: -Neetz-

nofing mch..jst hving a debate in da DM section. wnna join ?

*rubs eyes* is it jst me or r u writng in shoet hand 😲😆
umm im having a bit of headache. I think i'll stick to spamming for now 😆
293418 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
It is one thing, you are right for the select few, who choose to get in such a career, to have some legal framework to protect them. That is indeed necessary. But along with that, I would like particularly for the law enforcement to try to curb underage prostitution, which I think is abuse. I read about a recent law passed in the U.S. and will share key sections of the article with you. Also, I need to find some stuff Dworkin has said on the matter because I don't know if even people do this stuff by their own will, does it not have some profound impact on their relationships later on? Street-walking is indeed a different matter than the high society escorts though in a more safe and secure environment.

Now 15, Amanda is rebuilding her life. Caught when a cop stopped one of her customers for a broken tail light, she was sent to Children of the Night, a residential program in suburban Los Angeles that rehabilitates teen prostitutes.

"All my life my plate was like overfilled with problems," she said. "I always asked God to give me something good, and this is it."

The fact that Amanda was rescued instead of arrested reflects not only a stroke of luck but a decidedly different take on tackling the juvenile sex trade. Courts and law enforcement are increasingly treating young prostitutes as child abuse victims — and their pimps as human traffickers.


This is an institutional shift," said Nancy O'Malley, an Alameda County prosecutor who wrote California's new sexually exploited minors law. "It's about getting people to shift their attention and judgment from the minor and seeing what's beyond this criminal behavior."

New York also has a new law that calls for underage prostitutes to be sent to rehabilitation programs instead of juvenile detention, along with more training for law enforcement in handling the troubled teenagers and taking a harder line on their pimps.

In many other states, prosecutors are charging pimps with human trafficking, or the transportation of people for illicit commercial purposes. Convictions can land traffickers in prison for decades.

The approach comes as pimps are getting increasingly sophisticated and harder to bust. They run loose networks across states lines that distribute girls like drugs and set up Internet sex operations that are tough to infiltrate.

http://abcnews.go.com/US/WireStory?id=7370496&page=1

The article is actually 3 pages, but I chose select portions. So I would not be at all comfortable with legalization in India at least or anywhere unless there are strong measures to prevent children from being involved. That being said, it is one of the oldest businesses in the world so it is going to go on, but it would be better if it is regulated at least to safeguard those, who are working as prostitutes.

U-No-Poo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: KashFanatic

*rubs eyes* is it jst me or r u writng in shoet hand 😲😆

umm im having a bit of headache. I think i'll stick to spamming for now 😆

ya i'm writing in shoet hnd. u hv a problm wid dat ?! then stay away ! 😡 dn't inject negativity hre !
293418 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

Hi Aisha. :) Don't go, I can spam too.

.driftingaway thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: -Neetz-

ya i'm writing in shoet hnd. u hv a problm wid dat ?! then stay away ! 😡 dn't inject negativity hre !

u woch sizar im goin2 destry u wiv ma shoet pinky 😡 i luv negativity OK !? negaativity forevaaaaaa

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".