Has Kareena surpassed Rani and Aish? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Elvis12

Box office wise all three are has beens...

Kareena is a bigger star and is more popular

Rani is a better actress

bahurani took over almost everyone after HDDCS, Taal, Devdas, but her pathetic acting showed true colours with floppy ka bhandaar...the list is so endless...unbearable. koi fayda nahi to even go there.

begum came with a bang thinking that she going to cake walk , but stinky attitude, overacting, over confidence , arrogance, pathetic dancing, hit hard and rock bottom she went. thanks to jwm , she got 2nd innings and never looked back.

rani...average initially but picked up fast and became a good actor. she was exceptional in black! i wouldn't say greatest yada..but good to ok very good.

I would rate: rani=begum...pargo ahead punish me. watch talaash and then you will know if given opportunity how begum can seriously do some dhulai to other good actresses.

bahurani is not an actor. she is model, a gorgeous one.

^Kareena is the best actress from 2000s. The only problem is she is lazy and doesn’t pick good roles. She overshadowing Aamir in Talaash is the biggest example of her being the best.

I would say from 2000-2010, it was Ash-Rani’s time. While Kareena did do well in that decade she picked up much later.

I think as women over 40, Kareena is ahead now. During their younger days, Ash/Rani were definitely better.

Originally posted by: Briaahna

bahurani is not an actor. she is model, a gorgeous one.

Kareena was iconic as Poo and Geet. Her roles as Chameli and Taalash were also really great.

Rani probably could not pull off a Geet/Poo , but she was exceptional in Black. I loved her in Paheli and MrsChatterjeevsNorway as well as her romantic roles in Hum Tum, Chalte Chalte etc.

Ash was a dream in HDDCS, Devdas, JA and also showed her acting chops in Raincoat, Choker Bali etc.

In short, I think all three should be appreciated as each have done awesome roles.

I honestly can't choose.

Aish hasnt been relevant in ages; except for some side roles she is not even active as an actor. Rani and Kareena are still working and managing to give hits, so so kudos to them. I personally think Kareena is ahead as an star, rani ahead as actress.

As a star yes, but as an actor Rani is wayyy ahead!!