No, no and a firm NO.
Ash is here purely due to her beauty.
Ash, Sush, Sonali, Sonam, Kat, Deepika, Asin, Shilpa, Lara, Bipasha, Diya etc are NOT good actors at all.
Ash was hamming in most of her films. She was bad in HDDCS and Devdas.
Madhuri ate her alive in Devdas IMO in terms of acting.
Ash is a good actor only in fantasies of her fans.
23