Originally posted by: 1t1svat1t1s
In terms of privilege he definitely is at Alia and Ranbir level , if not above them. He literally has the entire country’s distributors and producers at his beck and call thanks to his superstar producer dad Allu Aravind. His dad usurped the careers of a couple of the then upcoming stars like Raja, Uday Koran etc to give space to his son. Allu Arjun definitely is a very talented actor now but he didn’t start this way and needed a lot of projects specially curated for him to reach to this level today. Same with Nagarjuna, Venkatesh etc. Hrithik Roshan is the one who is least privileged amongst these and there is no comparison between his journey and Allu Arjun’s.
+1
And I would add/correct the following, looking at some other posts. The nepotism angle has been presented neatly, so nothing to add to it also.
1. Allu Arjun's debut Gangotri (03), was a blockbuster. Its collections were bigger than Parbhas' Raghavendra, Pawan Kalyan's Johnny, and Mahesh Babu's Nijam released in the same summer. AA crossed Gangotri's numbers with Deshamuduru (07).
2. Allu Arjun's journey is 100% similar to Alia or Ranbir at a higher level privilege-wise concerning the projects. All his films barring Naa Peru Surya, were with blockbuster directors or with directors who delivered a blockbuster previously. Its called Padding** among Telugu fans. This includes even a different attempt (considering industry standards) like Vedam that came after Gamyam.
3. Naa Peru Suriya is the ONLY disaster in Allu Arjun's career that was made with a debut director (the second one after Arya). Varudu is the ONLY flop. Happy, Badrinath, Iddarammayilatho are Bel-avg affairs. His success rate is staggering, the best compared to the rest of the Telugu stars. So, box office wise closer to Alia Bhatt than Ranbir. In either case (2&3) no comparison with Hrithik who was an overnight star and tier 1 hero from the debut.
4. The reason why there was/is no noise regarding the privilege is because everyone else floats on the same boat, and Allu Arjun is far lesser a star compared to them. Mahesh Babu actually gets called out for the same as an Alia or Ranbir. He is branded as a padding star**. Personally, I don't think it's wrong working in combo films; Chiranjeevi does that, Rajini does that, and so do many other Superstars, but then the combos have to set the box office on fire like those stars do. It didn't happen with Mahesh Babu, which is why the flak. His contemporaries Pawan Kalyan and Jr NTR (not age-wise) put records with far lesser combos. And Allu Arjun was nowhere near Mahesh Babu until recently.
5. There is no denying the hard work of Allu Arjun. But he wasn't a tier-one star, to begin with, despite a blockbuster debut. Despite his remarkable change in looks, he was still criticised very much as an actor and also for his looks. The perception changed only in the last few years. Again, it is all due to his hard work.
6. Allu Arjun is yet to give an Opening Week Record. His "First" opening week record in a territory (Nizam) came recently with Pushpa. Prabhas had them all with Baahubali. Now, AA is most likely to have them all with Pushpa 2. That would be in 2023, after his debut in 2003.
7. Given this track record, many feel Allu Arjun has been shoved down the throat. A padding star who wouldn't be where he is without the combos "curated" for him by his father. But, the "Mega" brand was too big to have an effect on him. His overwhelming hard work and sustained success have also helped him. He was like Alia Bhatt but at a lower level compared to the big stars. But, tables have turned now, and to show him as a "Superstar", a tier one star from the start, the new narrative of the Allu family/legacy is brought out.
8. The future looks perfect for Allu Arjun "now". He could be the dominating star from Pushpa -2 given his extraordinary PR/marketing team. Prabhas and Jr NTR are his only competition, especially the latter.
9. Charan will always be there, but he doesn't seem to have that passion to be number one. Prabhas too has same issue, but he is relatively on his own for a long time with no legacy issues, so it eases out pressure on him to live up to certain expectations. It helps in selecting subjects and, thereby, the box office.
Obviously not a fan of Allu Arjun 😉, but I am curious to see his star trajectory for the rest of the decade. He could be (or not) number one. He is ambitious and has all the machinery at his disposal. The Khans are old, and younger ones lack the "Masala Swag/Screen Presence". Right "now" he is the "Sixth" biggest star in TFI, though.
6