Originally posted by: capricornrcks
Shakun Batra and Sid Anand belong to the new gen directors who are enamored with Hollywood. Many of their movies are set abroad.More so with Shakun as he went to film school in America. They'd rather work there but are settling for Bollywood. It is just that it's so obvious in Gehraiyaan with the clothes and the atmosphere. Draping someone in a sari doesn't make them Indian. There are some idiosyncrasies and behaviors that are uniquely Indian. We do not react always in the same way an American might react in the same situation. Society and family definitely has more say in the personal lives of Indians. Whether it be marriage or adoption or whatever. But in Shakun's movies the characters react as if they are in a Hollywood movie. I'm not saying that their movies aren't well-made. But they lack something that's uniquely Indian.
well said!!! In fact I think most directors don’t know what is Indian anymore. They just build on their own sensibilities. Farnham Akhtar’s DCH, Zoya Akhtar’s DDD, ZNMD, Ayan Mukherjee’s YJHD are all built on their lives and friends, however they find ways to keep the language, the grammar of the film urban and yet relatable for many. They hire Hindi dialogue writers, who have finesse in the language.
this is very different from say a Vishal Bharadwaj who first chooses a storyline ((often inspired by Shakespere) and sets it in a place in India which he spends time researching, building characters. So while not all his movies work all the time, you know he is forever learning.
My irritation with this trailer is no doubt the overuse of English, but also the thematic set up which can’t be relatable to 97% of India. Meeting your cousin on a Yatch!!! That’s where the rich kids do drugs make worst life choices!! 🙄 Moreover, DP bs claims like there has never been a role like this in Indian cinema, dude you are cheating on your husband, believe me there have been enough stories and roles like this. Adultery was a theme in parallel Hindi cinema in the 80s - Ek Pal, Arth, Libaas, Astitva, Maya Memsaab, Masoom. All of them deal with adultery through a woman’s lens. But the problem is Shakun, DP a never watched fabulous Hindi cinema, they watched flaky YRF and Dharma movies and Hollywood.
I am glad that it’s going straight to OTT.
8