Do you guys agree with Mumtaz's take on Boney/Sridevi? - Page 17

Created

Last reply

Replies

183

Views

21.3k

Users

37

Likes

414

Frequent Posters

BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Thanks for the warmth, love 🤗 It always triggers me when people insist on being together for the kids, despite their obvious unhappiness. I have seen the repercussions too up close to ever ask anyone to compromise with their lives.

I don't know if I will get a closure or whether I already have it 😆 But I am grateful, even for the earlier pain. It made me softer, but also tougher where it matters. More than anything, I am relieved to be an adult and no longer a child. The freedom to be able to take my own decisions and leave a toxic atmosphere is just incomparable.

Thank you for your kindness. That quality always touches me and I will remember it ❤️

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten


Lots and lots of hugs to you 🤗 Time has unpredictable ways of coming around and giving you closures on things when you least expect them, I'm sure you'll find yours too. :)


Thank you also for being brave enough to come forward with your personal story ... ❤️ and sharing how it shapes your outlook/opinion on the topic at hand.

BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Thank you so much ❤️ The love means a lot to me. It was cathartic to share, even if it has been years.

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche


T4S


A million hugs and kisses to you ❤️❤️

1194442 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: BlackWitch

Thanks for the warmth, love 🤗 It always triggers me when people insist on being together for the kids, despite their obvious unhappiness. I have seen the repercussions too up close to ever ask anyone to compromise with their lives.

I don't know if I will get a closure or whether I already have it 😆 But I am grateful, even for the earlier pain. It made me softer, but also tougher where it matters. More than anything, I am relieved to be an adult and no longer a child. The freedom to be able to take my own decisions and leave a toxic atmosphere is just incomparable.

Thank you for your kindness. That quality always touches me and I will remember it ❤️


Of course. :) You're definitely not alone. :) Coldness, lack of affection and two people just going through the motions of life are some of the byproducts of sticking it out just for the kid .... and that's something I experienced as a child. The quality of life is very subpar that way and by the time you're an adult, you don't have that many family experiences to look back on. Unhealthy coping ways left my parents emotionally unavailable and incapable despite being together on paper. Details might differ but they lead to the same point that two people who don't want to be together, shouldn't have to be. I also noticed that a lot of people who grew up in non-dysfunctional families look up to their parents but I make a conscious effort to be like anything but them. 😆


I think we need to acknowledge that people aren't bots and that they will reach their breaking points sooner or later even if they manage to play a happy family for a short while. I would call them human for not being able to manage that perfectly in the long run, not selfish pricks. But then again, humans are inherently very selfish creatures, so that might be fair game too.😆

Haiwan thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: BlackWitch

I was 8, when my parents asked me who do I love more. I said “both of you equally.” I saw the disbelief on their faces, as they reiterated that they won’t mind if I spoke my truth. I insisted “both of you equally!” . They finally gave up and moved on to another topic. But I remember the frustration their disbelief caused me as a child. How could I choose one part of my heart over another?


My father was a quiet man, content to sit in a corner and read his books. He was in the army, had simple needs and was away on another posting for majority of the time. My mother was a vivacious model, who loved sparkling conversations and parties. Coming from a stifling and violent household, she was experiencing freedom for the first time and wanted it all. The glitz, the glamour, the sophisticated and powerful people of show biz that gave her the platform to shine.

They got married too early and grew up apart, each leading a life that the other would not get interested in. They could not talk on things that mattered to them. And so, the silence became lengthier. Their primary conversation became just me.

From quiet acceptance, resentment creeped in. It covered the floor, the walls, creeping into my room where I prayed for the fights to stop till I fell asleep. When I woke up, there would be a coldness in my home. That coldness became a friend that greeted me when I came back from school each day.

The first time my parents discussed the possibility of separating, I cried. I locked myself in my room and I cried till the tears won’t fall. It was my first heart break.

The last time they told me, I locked myself in my room and I cried. I fell to my knees and cried, but this time mixed with grief was relief. With the relief, came guilt. Was I happy that my parents were separating? Yes, I was happy. I wanted the biting cold in my home gone.

So, when my parents gave me a choice again, I chose my mother. My father held me on the kitchen floor, wept and promised never to leave me. I clung onto him and that promise, never believing that other half of my heart was to be punished for my choice.

My father married again, and never looked back at me. I learnt as a child not to trust promises, never to believe that those who love you, can’t just get up and leave. At some point, as I grew up and reached out to him for comfort, he told me that he can’t talk and doesn’t owe me anything.

It’s then that my love for him withered and died.


All I want to say by sharing my story is that if you’re unhappy in your marriage, please leave. Don’t stay for your child. Don’t hand them memories of a cold home. Don’t let them suffocate in a place where their parents don’t love each other. Resentment, even of the quiet kind, has a deafening sound.


But if you can, please love your children beyond your marriage. Please care when they are hurt. Please talk to them. Please let them believe in promises and the sanctimony of love. They want very little, just your happiness and a tiny irreplaceable corner in your heart. I hope you can do that much.

Appreciate your candor in sharing this with us.

Sending lots of love and best wishes your way! ❤️🤗

BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Thank you so much. Accepting all the love and best wishes with only gratitude and more love ❤️❤️

Originally posted by: tapori

Appreciate your candor in sharing this with us.

Sending lots of love and best wishes your way! ❤️🤗

BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Oh, this certainly happens way more often that I realise. Lots of love and hugs to you for sharing this ❤️ I shouldn't be surprised, but I am. Perhaps, its because you always sound so sorted.

My mother was emotionally withdrawn too. She saw Taare Zameen Par one day, looked at me with misty eyes and for three days after that gave some random hugs out of the blue 🤣

I used to envy every kid who had a normal life. When my husband holds my hand, looks into my eyes, and asks me to believe that he will stay no matter what, I just...can't. How do I even begin to believe this? It's moments like these where I wish my parents had just fckin left before they traumatised me for life.

I relate to this so much. I try so hard to not be like my parents too. But as one grows up, there are some unavoidable traits that creep up in certain life moments. I am ashamed of those parts of me. I just want to be normal.

You said it perfectly. I had this line in my mind for a while that we keep urging humans to not be selfish, but perhaps, to be selfish is being human. Without it, everything is chaos.

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten


Of course. :) You're definitely not alone. :) Coldness, lack of affection and two people just going through the motions of life are some of the byproducts of sticking it out just for the kid .... and that's something I experienced as a child. The quality of life is very subpar that way and by the time you're an adult, you don't have that many family experiences to look back on. Unhealthy coping ways left my parents emotionally unavailable and incapable despite being together on paper. Details might differ but they lead to the same point that two people who don't want to be together, shouldn't have to be. I also noticed that a lot of people who grew up in non-dysfunctional families look up to their parents but I make a conscious effort to be like anything but them. 😆


I think we need to acknowledge that people aren't bots and that they will reach their breaking points sooner or later even if they manage to play a happy family for a short while. I would call them human for not being able to manage that perfectly in the long run, not selfish pricks. But then again, humans are inherently very selfish creatures, so that might be fair game too.😆

Maroonporsche thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: BlackWitch

Thank you so much ❤️ The love means a lot to me. It was cathartic to share, even if it has been years.


I know. Being Cathartic is needed sometimes 👏


Even those of us crazy people 😆

1194442 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: BlackWitch

Oh, this certainly happens way more often that I realise. Lots of love and hugs to you for sharing this ❤️ I shouldn't be surprised, but I am. Perhaps, its because you always sound so sorted.

My mother was emotionally withdrawn too. She saw Taare Zameen Par one day, looked at me with misty eyes and for three days after that gave some random hugs out of the blue 🤣

I used to envy every kid who had a normal life. When my husband holds my hand, looks into my eyes, and asks me to believe that he will stay no matter what, I just...can't. How do I even begin to believe this? It's moments like these where I wish my parents had just fckin left before they traumatised me for life.

I relate to this so much. I try so hard to not be like my parents too. But as one grows up, there are some unavoidable traits that creep up in certain life moments. I am ashamed of those parts of me. I just want to be normal.

You said it perfectly. I had this line in my mind for a while that we keep urging humans to not be selfish, but perhaps, to be selfish is being human. Without it, everything is chaos.


I have been putting on a showbiz level of acting and coming across as sorted even though I might not be. 😆😆 Kidding there but I think a lot of people do that on some level.

Besides, I revisit bad memories and can analyze them objectively like a bad dream of sorts, it doesn't really trigger me or anything. Tell me about those hugs though! Even casual hugs from friends is a constant reminder of what I was missing but I can easily brush it off. Abandonment issue is another one .... I am never ever "comfortable" with the fact that someone actually can be in it for the long haul, it's just not believable. We're very similar that way. :)

BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Haha, yes, I do think we are similar in our coping mechanisms 😆 In interviews where you have to display maturity and mental strength, I deliberately pick up this part of my life to talk about. I was giving an SSB interview (for the Indian army) once and my childhood experiences and factual way of speaking about them shocked the interviewer. He batted for me with other officers, even though my psych assessment said I may be all kinds of wonky 🤣 I can speak about it casually, but when I stop and write, the demons are unleashed.


Ah, those hugs. I always found them weird when I was a kid and managed to do without them for the most part. I am very lucky to have a husband who is deliberate about hugging and touching. Otherwise I may forget about it 🤭 I do love it when people hug me, but it makes me uncomfortable too. It’s like a gift I don’t quite know how to accept and whether this person is the one I want to accept it from.

More than the staying being believable, I feel like I may jinx it. I have a fear that I may lose it, if I love it too much. I find myself telling my husband not to go out when it’s dark, take the cab and not the bike if he has to travel far, like I am his Mum

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten


I have been putting on a showbiz level of acting and coming across as sorted even though I might not be. 😆😆 Kidding there but I think a lot of people do that on some level.

Besides, I revisit bad memories and can analyze them objectively like a bad dream of sorts, it doesn't really trigger me or anything. Tell me about those hugs though! Even casual hugs from friends is a constant reminder of what I was missing but I can easily brush it off. Abandonment issue is another one .... I am never ever "comfortable" with the fact that someone actually can be in it for the long haul, it's just not believable. We're very similar that way. :)

1194442 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: BlackWitch

Haha, yes, I do think we are similar in our coping mechanisms 😆 In interviews where you have to display maturity and mental strength, I deliberately pick up this part of my life to talk about. I was giving an SSB interview (for the Indian army) once and my childhood experiences and factual way of speaking about them shocked the interviewer. He batted for me with other officers, even though my psych assessment said I may be all kinds of wonky 🤣 I can speak about it casually, but when I stop and write, the demons are unleashed.


Ah, those hugs. I always found them weird when I was a kid and managed to do without them for the most part. I am very lucky to have a husband who is deliberate about hugging and touching. Otherwise I may forget about it 🤭 I do love it when people hug me, but it makes me uncomfortable too. It’s like a gift I don’t quite know how to accept and whether this person is the one I want to accept it from.

More than the staying being believable, I feel like I may jinx it. I have a fear that I may lose it, if I love it too much. I find myself telling my husband not to go out when it’s dark, take the cab and not the bike if he has to travel far, like I am his Mum


Yes, once I start writing, it all pours out effortlessly. And when I read it all up at the end, I surprise myself with everything that I was keeping in. Not exactly holding it in on purpose but I surprise myself with what I was *not* expressing cuz there never was a situation that demanded it.


Gotta get back to work now, I-F is gonna be the death of me. 😆

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: WormikaGrubby · 4 months ago

https://youtu.be/sDCtuCcbsXQ?si=F5Dg3vFlcIa2S5ky

https://youtu.be/sDCtuCcbsXQ?si=F5Dg3vFlcIa2S5ky
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

https://www.mid-day.com/entertainment/bollywood-news/article/boney-kapoor-moves-to-madras-hc-over-claims-on-sridevi-chennai-property-23591183

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Amira21 · 2 months ago

Suddenly, he is losing his weight and trying to look good and handsome. He is definitely trying to look fit. He even acted on a movie after...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/boney-kapoors-weight-loss-gets-the-internet-divided-ozempic-or-discipline_225073

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: beena_jon · 5 months ago

Nirmala Kapoor, the beloved mother of Bollywood stars Anil Kapoor, Boney Kapoor, and Sanjay Kapoor, passed away on May 2, 2025, at the age of 90...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".