Aishwarya or Kareena, better actress? - Page 5

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Aishwarya acted very well in Sarbjit! She was loud cuz the character herself was loud and behaved that way. She nailed the Punjabi accent as well

I beg your pardon? 🤣 Her acting in Sarabjit was annoying af that it gave me a headache. There are loud roles that you can play without taking a toll on the audiences' system. Karisma in Fiza was loud, but she didn't give a headache. You only have to look at Ash's expression when she gets hit by a rod (or whatever) to see how bad she was 😆

That said, Ash does do some subtle roles well. Raincoat and Jodhaa Akbar are good examples of that.

Kareena - loud roles

Aish - subtle roles

They are both atrocious when the roles are reversed in my eyes.

Kareena overacts and so aishwarya but not as loud as kareena. Still Kareena is better actress.. I have never seen Aish as a good actress or dancer...she tries very hard and it’s visible.

Aish for me. One of my favorite scenes of hers in her entire career is in Mohabbatein when Bg B she can't marry SRK and he won't accep it. She was in the middle of sewing and she continues to put the thread to the needle with a single tear and doesn't utter a word. She has a lot of these magical moments where she won't say anything and her eyes do a lot of talking. Like the "come here" in Ankhiyon ki Ghustakhiyan song, the whole eyebrow seductive scene in ADHM at the table with Ranbir...KJo even said he explained the emotion he wanted and when she did, he never he couldn't have casted anyone else. She's just ever expressive without being over the top. And I lowkey love Sunehri lol she had the right kind of attitude without being bratty.

The one weakness Aish has is comedy, she doesn't have the natural spunk in her that Madhuri, Juhi or Sri Devi. I think in thid department Kareena is definitely miles ahead b/c she actually does comedy in a way that makes me laugh out loud, especially in Veere.

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

Kareena Kapoor has made me want to punch the TV screen whether it’s from her exaggerated eye pop-out expressions or her pathetic dance moves (with that awkward limp hand). At this point, any actress (except for Katrina & Sonam) would win over her for me.

LMAO Main Prem Ki Diwana Hoon is atrocious yet for some real I still watch it time to time along with Khushi. I don't know why, I hate her acting in it but she's still fun to watch 😆

Imo, Kareena was ok as geet. But i watched main prem ki deewani after seeing pretentious reviews. Ever since, I am unable to see her in any other character. There is always a bit of main prem ki deewani in her every character and the multi colored parrot in her shoulder. My eyes can never unsee that movie. And kareena's characters do not help yaadein, asoka, k3g, ki and ka, fida, ra.one.

Aish bad movies are still bearable so.

Originally posted by: ChinChinChooo

I beg your pardon? 🤣 Her acting in Sarabjit was annoying af that it gave me a headache. There are loud roles that you can play without taking a toll on the audiences' system. Karisma in Fiza was loud, but she didn't give a headache. You only have to look at Ash's expression when she gets hit by a rod (or whatever) to see how bad she was 😆

That said, Ash does do some subtle roles well. Raincoat and Jodhaa Akbar are good examples of that.

Ok well that’s your opinion? I’ve seen lots of reviews where people loved Ash. If we can appreciate low gutter level of acting from certain star daughters then Ash’s acting has higher standards than the foolery that’s in the market today.

Aishwarya has her weaknesses but we only have to look at Kareena's mujra performance in Agent Vinod to see how Ash pretty much blows her out of the water.

But sure Kareena does the Bhatinda wali loudmouth well in JWM -- even though she's pretty much playing herself on steroids there.

So it's all about what you like watching. I pick Ash any given day for a better cinematic experience.

Originally posted by: coldbrew

Aishwarya has her weaknesses but we only have to look at Kareena's mujra performance in Agent Vinod to see how Ash pretty much blows her out of the water.

But sure Kareena does the Bhatinda wali loudmouth well in JWM -- even though she's pretty much playing herself on steroids there.

So it's all about what you like watching. I pick Ash any given day for a better cinematic experience.

🤣