Kriti Sanon rakes in rave reviews for her performance in Luka Chuppi - Page 4

Originally posted by: sania349

but she is not overrated. she has done a film like bareilly ki barfi. and she was not even rated. where as alia would be praised beyond limits.

so I am praising her because she deserves it. if alia is good, I would praise her too.

the whole industry roots for alia and overrates her, dont think its a big deal for giving an actress praise on IF when it is deserved😆

(a) BKB was praised by almost every critic, got good reviews from insiders too.
While Kriti was praised as well, not her fault or people's fault if Raj Kumar Rao went out with all the limelight.



(b)Secondly, you say you don't Alia because she is overrated, but here you are overrating her by comparing with Alia's solo movie, just because it collected some 50 lakhs more, despite being released in more screens, having a more successful album and a more popular male star(Vicky wasn't even known well by public when Raazi released).
it isnt about IF, its about you contradicting yourself.

Wait for two more months when Arjun Patiala releases we wlii know her actual star power 😆

Good for her.. I liked her acting in BKB. But better than Alia? No. Not until now. Alia is in a different league altogether after GB (for me atleast) .

Alia has done alot more meatier roles her films USP has been the content. If you have a good director overlooking the project its safe to say that you will be in good hands. Alia has worked with the best so the comparison should not be there.

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

(a) BKB was praised by almost every critic, got good reviews from insiders too.
While Kriti was praised as well, not her fault or people's fault if Raj Kumar Rao went out with all the limelight.



(b)Secondly, you say you don't Alia because she is overrated, but here you are overrating her by comparing with Alia's solo movie, just because it collected some 50 lakhs more, despite being released in more screens, having a more successful album and a more popular male star(Vicky wasn't even known well by public when Raazi released).
it isnt about IF, its about you contradicting yourself.

Originally posted by: sania349

How am I overrating her? you cant say for sure that kartik was the only selling factor.

and alia is a bigger star than kriti, but their films managed to rake in a similar amounts despite this. this is what I am saying. I dont care if kartik is involved...he may have some part in pulling in crowd, but def not all of it. the fact that alia is supposingly a hige crowd puller but rakes in similar amounts means she is hyped and overrated from an industry perspective. outsiders such as kriti and kaarthik can rake in and do similar types of roles as say a varun and alia.

so based on this...alia IS overrated. and kriti is underrated.

this is not contradiction

you are seriously comparing Raazi with Luka Chupi? A serious looking movie with female solo movie with no male star(yes Vicky was hardly known by anyone at that time) with a romantic comedy with hit music, the most hyped youngster coming from a 100 crores movie, and giving all credit to Kriti? Tomorrow someone will say Kriti is underrated and Deepika is overrated because Piku opened less than Heropanti. than someone will say Jhanvi is a bigger star than Alia, because Dhadak opened more than Raazi.
And yes you are over rating Kriti by giving box office opening credit of Luki Chuppi to her and comparing it with Alia's Raazi. See this thread could have gone well with everyone praising Kriti for her performance, but no jab tak Alia ki buria nahi hogi, Kriti ki praise puri nahi hogi.

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

you are seriously comparing Raazi with Luka Chupi? A serious looking movie with female solo movie with no male star(yes Vicky was hardly known by anyone at that time) with a romantic comedy with hit music, the most hyped youngster coming from a 100 crores movie, and giving all credit to Kriti? Tomorrow someone will say Kriti is underrated and Deepika is overrated because Piku opened less than Heropanti. than someone will say Jhanvi is a bigger star than Alia, because Dhadak opened more than Raazi.
And yes you are over rating Kriti by giving box office opening credit of Luki Chuppi to her and comparing it with Alia's Raazi. See this thread could have gone well with everyone praising Kriti for her performance, but no jab tak Alia ki buria nahi hogi, Kriti ki praise puri nahi hogi.

Originally posted by: sania349

I am not talking about films. I am talking about in general, as performers. I think you were the one who came into the thread and started talking about alia and I responded.

and yes why not the comparisons? If alia is such a huge star as the INDUSTRY makes her out to be and overrates her as, why didnt her movie make more on opening day?

I dont think the comparisons are unfair with two new outsiders when the industry categorizes alia as some huge revelation. and iconic meryl streep

so yes it is probably unfair to compare film genres as luka has an advantage and more draw in content. but unfair comparisons can be made when their is unfair privileges are given to certain actresses. just my opinion.

I didn't brought Alia in this thread, it was you and others, who could not stop from belittling Alia instead of praising.
I just responded to your outlandish claim that since LC opened bigger than Raazi, Kriti deserves as much praise as Alia, while totally forgetting that Alia was the only drawing factor in the movie.
Raazi is the second highest grossing ever for a female oriented movie and was one of the highest opening female lead movies when it was released.

If you really wanna compare Luka Chupi, than do that to Alia in 2 States and Humpty years ago, lesser screens, lesser ticket prices and more tax cost.

What I like about Kriti is that she is completely an outsider, had no godfather at all, rarely tried to get any attention by linking herself up with the A-lister actors, and still managed to reach where she is today.