I'd rate JHMS over ADHM

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Till the Hawayein promo came out, I had no excitement for JHMS. I love SRK, Anushka and Imtiaz Ali movies (most of them anyway) but I was like meh whatever. Bollywood doesn't excite me in general anymore unlike how I felt in the 90s & early 00s growing up. Anyway, that's not what the topic is about. So I had got my hopes up after the Hawayein promo and thought ok this film could be something special and then stupidly I read feedback on the movie this morning on Twitter & of course here. I've generally stopped looking up Bollywood reviews so may be this came up as quite a shocker though it's a norm for most people here(?!)...but what I couldn't understand is how people are DESPERATE to spread negativity on social media and by desperate, I mean writing the worst things on social media to make sure that their most hated celeb's film is brought down.

I assume Khan fans are all against each other and this is the norm? How disgusting isn't it? Seeing as though Bollywood is generally in quite a shit position, the mango people are using social media to dissuade people from going to the theatres, though mind you I don't know how much of this feedback on Twitter or even here is GENUINE?!

I went in to the cinema hall thinking once again a SRK film will disappoint as his recent films have done but actually it turned out to be a very refreshing rom-com! Like we BARELY have them anymore and when a decent one does come along, we bash it because...well I don't know why we bash it? For one, JHMS had no cringey scenes, the acting was genuinely brilliant and it was just a feel good love story with perhaps subtle complexities on surface. It does NOT have to be epic! It's a nice film, go watch it for yourself...I don't think SRK or Anushka hit a false note with this one. Yes, the second half does falter like most Imtiaz Ali films do including his classic JWM which goes through a slow phase without Geet.

I'd rate this movie above ADHM because the second half of that completely lost me. Cancer track out of nowhere because if Alizeh could not be with Ayan then she must be killed off *facepalm* ! JHMS doesn't try to be great but it's treatment is refreshing and it's worth a watch! I just don't get the OTT negativity!

It's DAY 1 of the movie's release - how do people jump to seal the fate so quickly and so HAPPILY? How sad is that!

P.S. I compared ADHM & JHMS mostly because they're in the 'love story'' genre & by two filmmakers who everyone seems to have a love-hate relationship with
Edited by *Reemz* - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

64

Views

6.7k

Users

28

Likes

137

Frequent Posters

Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Reemz - I agree about the negativity of fandoms. There are many clips from movie that are posted on Twitter. These fan wars on SM will bring BW down.

On JHMS being better than ADHM - I'll comment tomorrow after watching JHMS. I am sure I'll disagree😆
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Ranbirrocks

Reemz - I agree about the negativity of fandoms. There are many clips from movie that are posted on Twitter. These fan wars on SM will bring BW down.


On JHMS being better than ADHM - I'll comment tomorrow after watching JHMS. I am sure I'll disagree😆



It's disgusting! Even here, like people are waiting ke kab film release ho & flop hojaye so we can mock and rejoice. Like do they even see that all the stars are pretty much failing somewhere? Who is winning out of this?

Haha regarding ADHM. You may well do! I have a soft spot for SRK but I love Ranbir as an actor so much. It's just that ADHM disappointed me quite a bit due to the unnecessary cancer track!
princessunara thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
I'd say every single thing u said about JHMS is a ditto for me.. and about this OTT negative feedback on ANY movie, not just my favs movies is just so annoying! That's why I'm super glad to be in UAE and have a chance to go and watch it for myself and decide before other people ruin it for me.
Anyway yah it's a simple fun frothy rom com.. no messages, no philosophy nothing.. just a light time pass movie, a superbly acted one at that which is why I love it! The way they play off each other is so much fun!!

@RR - lol I'm going again tomorrow morning and I'm tied btw which one I love more.. sort of slightly leaning towards JHMS? 😆 (still not fully decided lol.. if I decide I'll tell 😆)
Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: *Reemz*



It's disgusting! Even here, like people are waiting ke kab film release ho & flop hojaye so we can mock and rejoice. Like do they even see that all the stars are pretty much failing somewhere? Who is winning out of this?

Haha regarding ADHM. You may well do! I have a soft spot for SRK but I love Ranbir as an actor so much. It's just that ADHM disappointed me quite a bit due to the unnecessary cancer track!


I'll compare JHMS with Tamasha , not ADHM . Both are Imtiaz movies , so comparison is easier.


Regarding negativity, I have accepted that its a way of life here and since everyone's movie will fail, we all get equal opportunity to bash😆

I don't mind trolling but when movie clips are leaked to sabotage , it affects business. I have seen - SRK entry, Anu Entry and Climax scenes on Twitter being leaked. This is very negative trend.
Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: princessunara

I'd say every single thing u said about JHMS is a ditto for me.. and about this OTT negative feedback on ANY movie, not just my favs movies is just so annoying! That's why I'm super glad to be in UAE and have a chance to go and watch it for myself and decide before other people ruin it for me.
Anyway yah it's a simple fun frothy rom com.. no messages, no philosophy nothing.. just a light time pass movie, a superbly acted one at that which is why I love it! The way they play off each other is so much fun!!

@RR - lol I'm going again tomorrow morning and I'm tied btw which one I love more.. sort of slightly leaning towards JHMS? 😆 (still not fully decided lol.. if I decide I'll tell 😆)


Sunara you can't ditch Alizeh for Sejal😡😆.

You sold the Cancer track so well that now I love it !!
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Im so glad you LOVED the movie, most regular folks are saying they loved the movie
Critics are usually nose up in the air for rom-coms so their opinions dont matter
and critics reviews hardly decide the fate of a movie.
Then Fan with the raving reviews would have been a hit
Its the regular audience who decides if a movie is good or bad,
This one is entertaining and with great performance by SRK Anu that is audience feedback

Dont bother with this forum or social media...they are always like this with SRK movies

This forum also bashed and trashed Raees and it turned out to be the year's highest Grosser till now 😆

Regarding these twitter fandoms pulling down a movie, this guy summed it up the BEST

Aavishkar Gawande @aavishhkar
More

On One side - Writers , Second Side CBFC , 3rd Side Piracy, and On 4th Side Twitter Negativity. Charo taraf se Baj raha hai Bollywood aaj

10 replies15 retweets54 likes
Reply
Retweet
Like

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: princessunara

I'd say every single thing u said about JHMS is a ditto for me.. and about this OTT negative feedback on ANY movie, not just my favs movies is just so annoying! That's why I'm super glad to be in UAE and have a chance to go and watch it for myself and decide before other people ruin it for me.
Anyway yah it's a simple fun frothy rom com.. no messages, no philosophy nothing.. just a light time pass movie, a superbly acted one at that which is why I love it! The way they play off each other is so much fun!!

@RR - lol I'm going again tomorrow morning and I'm tied btw which one I love more.. sort of slightly leaning towards JHMS? 😆 (still not fully decided lol.. if I decide I'll tell 😆)



Exactly - not every film requires complexities. It's not like there was none in the film but it was more so implied with Harry's emptiness and sometimes that's enough for a film like this. SRK & Anushka really played off each other so well.

I know a girl like sejal so it felt a bit strange to watch. Like there people shallow & selfish yet loveable like her I guess.
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Ranbirrocks


I'll compare JHMS with Tamasha , not ADHM . Both are Imtiaz movies , so comparison is easier.


Regarding negativity, I have accepted that its a way of life here and since everyone's movie will fail, we all get equal opportunity to bash😆

I don't mind trolling but when movie clips are leaked to sabotage , it affects business. I have seen - SRK entry, Anu Entry and Climax scenes on Twitter being leaked. This is very negative trend.


@Bold: that is indeed DISGUSTING 🤢
The extent to which these twitter trolls will descend to bring down SRK movie
and I know exactly which 2 fandoms are doing this

*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Ranbirrocks



I'll compare JHMS with Tamasha , not ADHM . Both are Imtiaz movies , so comparison is easier.


Regarding negativity, I have accepted that its a way of life here and since everyone's movie will fail, we all get equal opportunity to bash😆

I don't mind trolling but when movie clips are leaked to sabotage , it affects business. I have seen - SRK entry, Anu Entry and Climax scenes on Twitter being leaked. This is very negative trend.



If I were to compare JHMS & Tamasha, it would be like comparing Apple and pears. Ved's psyche was really dwelled in to where as the likes of Sejal & Harry, though they feel incomplete they are not expanded on much at all.

Let's not forget we had Anushka too in both films and I'd also say her performance as Sejal was more natural too.

I saw some clips uploaded earlier too on twitter! What a bloody shame.!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".