'He was not speaking out of line' Sonam defends Harsh in Diljit row

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

fivestars

@fivestars

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: Angel-likeDevil
...and what's wrong with what she said? She is speaking as his sister.

I also think the world is being unnecessarily harsh on Harsh, as if he has committed some crime. YES his attitude is bad, wrong, but he is being bullied IMO.

This !!

I dont know defending family members is a crime here ! Having said that i still dont get what's wrong he said ...he has a valid point on debutant award !

Quote

1105912

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: starstruckk
Tiger lost to Fawad in Filmfare. In fact Fawad won for a film associated with Sonam and her family. Where was the hue and cry then? Tiger and his family didn't whine, neither did anyone from Sonam's side..but when it's your brother even if he was horrible..there's a point?
That doesn't make sense. Life isn't fair. Even accepting defeat with grace is a feat that some people need to learn in Bollywood.

THIS!

also including Dhanush who won for Raanjhanaa 🥱 #TwoFacedHypocrities

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

zehreeli.kheer

@zehreeli.kheer

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 8 years ago

#43

Easy peasy.. Sonam should return her FF award in support of her brother

Quote

Maraka_Musso89

@Maraka_Musso89

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: .rasgulla.
Easy peasy.. Sonam should return her FF award in support of her brother

Even if she returns it, she'd still have won it. It'll still be on the records.

Also, Sonam ddn't say she had anything about Filmfare per say ; simply that she doesn't understand why her brother is being bullied this much when he didn't say anything objectionalble.

Quote

zehreeli.kheer

@zehreeli.kheer

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 8 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: Madame_89

Even if she returns it, she'd still have won it. It'll still be on the records.

Also, Sonam ddn't say she had anything about Filmfare per say ; simply that she doesn't understand why her brother is being bullied this much when he didn't say anything objectionalble.

Return tou kare, records ki baad mein dekheinge😆

Of course she doesn't understand. I don't expect her to😆

Quote

Maraka_Musso89

@Maraka_Musso89

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: starstruckk
Tiger lost to Fawad in Filmfare. In fact Fawad won for a film associated with Sonam and her family. Where was the hue and cry then? Tiger and his family didn't whine, neither did anyone from Sonam's side..but when it's your brother even if he was horrible..there's a point?
That doesn't make sense. Life isn't fair. Even accepting defeat with grace is a feat that some people need to learn in Bollywood.

Fawad was far far far better that Tiger. Tiger's debut didn't excit anyone. It was a surprise hit and Tiger was being mocked at the time (people saying he looked like kareena and such...)

The Shroff family doesn't have the same clout than the Kapoor's, Khan's, Kumar...

It was Fawad first film in India so it may work in that sense.

Who knows if Harsh didn't think it was bullshit at the time? He simply ddn't have the plateform to express himself.

Quote

Something Or The Other

@ShadowKisses

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: Madame_89
Why should she keep mum when it's her brother that's beng attacked because he shared his opinion?
If you had siblings, you would let people attack them as they will? 👏

😆😆 Her brother isn't an eight-year-old kid who is being "bullied" by the big bad meanies at the playground.

He is an adult who whined on social media about losing an award and then, got pissy when people called him out on being bitter and entitled 😆 He can absolutely share his opinion - people can also absolutely share their opinion that he sounded like a sore loser (similar to the reaction Anushka got when she whined about Asin). What's the big issue that he needs his sister to come to his defense?
Save

Quote

starstruckk

@starstruckk

Inactive

Posted: 8 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: Madame_89

Fawad was far far far better that Tiger. Tiger's debut didn't excit anyone. It was a surprise hit and Tiger was being mocked at the time (people saying he looked like kareena and such...)

The Shroff family doesn't have the same clout than the Kapoor's, Khan's, Kumar...

It was Fawad first film in India so it may work in that sense.

Who knows if Harsh didn't think it was bullshit at the time? He simply ddn't have the plateform to express himself.

Fawad was far better than Tiger because he is actually EXPERIENCED. He wasn't exactly a "newcomer" either. Isn't that what Harsh tried proving somewhere down the line also? So, it's not okay when it involves him personally but it's whatever if it involves other people? If you're going to be THAT vocal about an issue, speak up for everyone, not just your bruised ego.

Why don't these people actually voice their opinion about how some of them get work solely based off off of nepotism even if they lack any ounce of talent? rather than pulling down and discouraging outsiders..work harder and prove yourself for next time so no Diljit, Fawad or Dhanush comes and takes your award.

Quote

Maraka_Musso89

@Maraka_Musso89

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: starstruckk

Twiitter spares no one. Harsh chose to speak out, what did he expect? No response in return? Give me a break.

Humility starts from home. I don't expect Sonam to bash her brother. Even if she decides to side with him merely because he's her brother, doesn't mean we have to agree with what she's saying. I disagree with her. Sorry, your brother WAS out of line..and if you don't want to admit it and defend him because he's family..that's fine..but don't make it seem like it was okay. It wasn't.

This kid is making it seem like if Diljit didn't win he was entitled to win. No he wasn't. So, accept it gracefully and move on. Harsh comes from a film family..he should be happy he even got a chance.

Also, you can protect your family without actually AGREEING with their stance...be it public or not. Sonam's "it wasn't out of line" is laughable.

What's your point if Twitter spares no one? Does it malke it right?

The worse thing is when some actors are rumored to have turned toward the bottle or being depressed ; the troll keep on trolling. Is it right?

If Sonam wants to back her brother she'll do it PERIOD! She's already been traolled too and doesn't want her brother to have to go through it. What's your problem with that??

Also read the article properly. She's never said it was right of him to say this. Simply that her brother didn't say anything that should have brought this kind of reaction and she's right!

Can't she defend her brother? Show me the exact line where she said people HAD TO agree with her brother's reasonning!

And were did Sonam say that she was agreeing with her brother's stand? She said : "And to troll him just because he made a point about the debutant's award, is just too unfair. He was speaking out of conviction. And according to me, he was not speaking out of line,"

Quote me an element showing that she ahe's agreeing with her brother's stance.

Coming to Harsh, can't he express himself if a journalist asks about his impression? Couldn't people have simply thught "he's being bitter" and move on? It's as if their wage depends on this issue.

Link me an article in which Harsh said "Diljit didn't deserve the award, IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN MINE" he didn't say that did he? He was very articulate abou the fact that

-Yes Diljit was very good but he had a body of work that enabled him to sharpen his acting skills

-He didn't say that he thought he should be the recipient of said award

LMAO and then people expect the celebs to react on public and national issues... No wonder they don't want to seeing the backlash Aamir and SRK got last year and the fuss created about a newbie sentiment about an award.

I, on a personnal level, will never care if my siblings say something ridiculous ; I'll stand by them. It'll be up to me to talk to them about what they did wrong.

How do you know Sonam or someone in their family didn't tell Harsh that he should be more careful next time about his choice of words? That, as a public person, what he can say in private might not transalte well in public?

Like you're entitled to your opinion, Harsh ws entitled to give his even if it didn't please you.

Also, Diljit himself said it was okay so why are people still on this case... THAT IS WHAT IS LAUGHABLE IMO.

Quote

1105912

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: Madame_89

Fawad was far far far better that Tiger. Tiger's debut didn't excit anyone. It was a surprise hit and Tiger was being mocked at the time (people saying he looked like kareena and such...)

The Shroff family doesn't have the same clout than the Kapoor's, Khan's, Kumar...

It was Fawad first film in India so it may work in that sense.

Who knows if Harsh didn't think it was bullshit at the time? He simply ddn't have the plateform to express himself.

And Diljit was far far far better than the talentless Harsh! At least Tiger's debut film was a HIT.
Mirzya on the other was a critical and commercial DISASTER.