Hrithik Roshan breaks his silence on legal battle with Kangana Ranaut - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

90

Views

9.3k

Users

46

Likes

207

Frequent Posters

Illyrion thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: anonymous39

[quote]On the other hand what was he supposed to do. He could have gotten really dirty and started leaking her emails, images, and videos. He could have planted the same kinds of stories she planted about him. [/quote]

It's against the law to release private images especially if they classify as po*n. He couldn't have leaked that. Plus Kangana would know where it's coming from so it would have also started a war.

We also don't know if he did or didn't plant stories against her. There were blinds about Kangana sending nude pics to other people as well. That could very well be Hrithik in a tit-for-tat action for all the blinds she probably released about him.

[quote]. If he went to the police and does have any connection with the email account, both he - and more importantly - his lawyer are truly idiots. No matter what anyone thinks of HR surely his money can rent a non-idiot lawyer. [/quote]

The lawyers may be smart but they can only work with what the clients give them. If he says there is an imposter email account and he needs to file a complaint, the lawyers would help him do that. It's not like they're going to accuse their client of being a liar and making things up. Nobody would automatically assume that. They would not know any personal details about his life so they would take his word that he is having this problem.


I can not bold on my iPad. So frustrating. Regarding your lawyer comment - not true. Good lawyers try very hard to find the holes in their clients story (even when true) before going to court. A good lawyer would have made it very very clear to Hrithik that a forensic investigator will be able to retrieve deleted emails and identify IPs and will seize every electronic device you have, are you absolutely sure you want to proceed? Most high profile attorneys (at least where I'm from) investigate their own clients trying to proactively protect their weak spots.

Edit: about leaking photos. Of course he doesn't call midday and say, "Wow I, Hrithik, have got something great for you!" I was saying if he wanted to be dirty he could release them anonymously and then say he thought he deleted them from his computer and then threw the computer out, someone must have found it, etc. I am not BTW saying he should have - very glad he didn't.
Edited by Nova19 - 9 years ago
745671 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#72
Well his lawyers are not that smart if they decided to file a legal notice against a crazy person. Nobody in his team is very smart if they thought they were going to be able to control Kangana by scaring her into submission.

And that too by threatening to expose her naked pics and demanding an apology through a press conference! That just makes him look cheap.

Didn't anyone think there is a possibility she will release the notice to the public?

And I think it's possible he never even consulted a lawyer about his police complaint about an email imposter. These people have good relations with the cops. He probably went in for 5 minutes and submitted a complaint and walked out.

The cops don't seem interested in any investigation either (which is probably how Hrithik wants it) because they have already stated that the email domain belongs to the United States so they can't do anything about it.

(It's not that hard to track down where pics were released from especially if only Hrithik had them. He would be knowingly committing a big crime if he leaked them)
Edited by anonymous39 - 9 years ago
Illyrion thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#73
@anon 39 where did the KK - SK kissing mms come from? What about all the sex MMS clips that have come and gone? Anyone in prison? He would have had plausible deniability which is all he would have needed.
nierembergia thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: anonymous39

[quote]On the other hand what was he supposed to do. He could have gotten really dirty and started leaking her emails, images, and videos. He could have planted the same kinds of stories she planted about him. [/quote]

It's against the law to release private images especially if they classify as po*n. He couldn't have leaked that. Plus Kangana would know where it's coming from so it would have also started a war.

We also don't know if he did or didn't plant stories against her. There were blinds about Kangana sending nude pics to other people as well. That could very well be Hrithik in a tit-for-tat action for all the blinds she probably released about him.

[quote]. If he went to the police and does have any connection with the email account, both he - and more importantly - his lawyer are truly idiots. No matter what anyone thinks of HR surely his money can rent a non-idiot lawyer. [/quote]

The lawyers may be smart but they can only work with what the clients give them. If he says there is an imposter email account and he needs to file a complaint, the lawyers would help him do that. It's not like they're going to accuse their client of being a liar and making things up. Nobody would automatically assume that. They would not know any personal details about his life so they would take his word that he is having this problem.



I don't think the email account was his. I believe that side of the story. He is foolish, but surely he can't be that foolish.

This is a relationship that ended badly. Both Kangana and him seem extremely paranoid and distrustful of the other. Some of their accusations come across as irrational (not much evidence to prove them) and mostly dictated by their suspicion and paranoia.
745671 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#75
^kissing isn't po*n. There was no nudity in those Kareena Shahid mms.
A lot of those sex mms clips are actual po*n, just disguised to look "amateur" because some perverts get more excited if they think it's real.

And thirdly, naked photos of a big celebrity being released would be a HUGE scandal. It's not like she's some anonymous random girl without resources to fight against it. They even caught the guy that hacked icould and released naked photos of celebrities.

It would be much easier if only one person had them.
Edited by anonymous39 - 9 years ago
Illyrion thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#76
@Anon 39 clearly lots of people have them and the number is going up with every blind LOL. The Jennifer Lawrence et al. issue was very different, that was a guy who hacked accounts (or fished but still) embarrassing lots of people and Apple - not quite the same level. Also I'm sure there are some silly embarrassing yet not po*nographic things she sent as well. And I was talking about actresses SMSs - I don't keep track of that but I know there have been. The point is to embarrass and make her seem either straight up crazy or that she was stalking/harassing him. And again for anyone who comes late to the conversation, I am not saying he should have done this, I am saying he could have but didn't.

Edited by Nova19 - 9 years ago
Zee_RK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#77
the more I read about this mess the more I dislike hrithik... he should ve kept quiet... This whole scenario is going to damage his image more than any other party involved... he is obsessed with his image and is tarnishing it single handedly...
AllBlacks1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#78
So far, HR is winning. Ppls' comments here r also understandable to blame HR for being very smart and very dumb, very techno savvy and very old fashioned e-mail era chatter, Very vicious to bring mighty Kangy down and very innocent to dig a grave for himself, very scarred of Kangy and yet very bold to slap her with legal notice unlike any1 else in BW. Well, he can be all of those things rolled into one and thats why hez a Greek God. 😆
All the while.. "but Kangy is like that u know... she is a open book... u know.. she lies, she talks trash, she plays victim card, its all ok for her to do that coz u know.. shez just like that... u gotta undestand u know... Its okay to call some1 bad for his personality disorder narcissism when its not hurting others but U cant make fun of another disorder.. coz u know thats Kangy for U". 👏

Anyways, I am more interested in getting the whole picture cleared and there is one big piece of puzzle missing right now. WHO IS THAT IMPOSTER? Thats where it can turn in either direction.

How I read the whole saga is this: (Yes, I am a HR fan but not a blind one to defend him on every occasion, nor think he was ever a saint, genius or dumb in real life..)

They had a fling during K3 when all was not going well for HR's married life, they kept it secret, comfort in bedroom and then HR walked off. Marriage over, K3 Blockbuster, back to pick up the pieces and Mohengo Daro.

As these 2 r film stars and have hectic schedules, different places, countries, and so on... its not like having whatsapp chat and text ping pong our youth play these days.. so i blv e-mail is the thing.

Everything was done n dusted untill Ashiqui3 rumours came out. Anybody would be fool to say Kangy didnt mean HR when saying the silly ex who is stalking her, before even BW lovers on IF has to do brainworks, the media headlined it " Did Kangana just called HR her ex?" HR's tweet also didnt name her but of course it was meant for her and also media. Now, the question was more direct to Kangy abt what she thinks of HR's tweet and her replying of moving on from past relationship and stop playing games.." So, its not just silly-ex who is trying to woo her back, its actually accusing him of stalking and mind games and destroy her career.. to which HR has a choice- ignore or respond. He responded. Points- KR= minus 2 (for false accusation and public criticism without proof), HR= 2 (for confronting)

The legal notice was sent to her, not made public. The reply was given from Kangy's side and made public. In which the contents of the HR's notice was also given in the "words of the Kangy's lawyer" as he interpreted. Asperger was mentioned as something Kangy's sister told HR and crew to forgive Kangy's drunken ruckus behaviour on the sets and actually they did keep quiet about it as requested. Kangy's lawyer made it look like " HR accusing her of having that disorder that she imagines things". Points. Kangy= minus 5 for bringing the mental disorder thing in public and twisting it completely. HR= 2 for merely pointing it out as why he has been silent and forgiving for 2 years since he actually believed Kangy might have that.."

The whole Kangy's friend spilling the bins article.. its as good as c-grade sleazy titilating semi-po*n script from d- grade BW movie. The timelines and how things happened make no sense. Its like HR is some 16 years old who cant make up his mind abt divorce and proposal and switching from one end to another and all the while Kangy is spectator who accepts his proposal and still go on a date with young superstar.. load of rubbish. Points. Kangy= minus 5. HR- 0 (he has nothing to do)

Fake e-mail/ imposter- What and how much info and emotions Kangy shared on that would never be known unless Kangy has saved them. And this is 2 years old stuff, noway HR wud have predicted what wud happen in 2016 when Kangy wud explode like she has. If he knew he wud have stayed miles away from her. But he did make a police complaint abt the imposter, right thing to do. If that person can make Kangy blv its HR, then he/she cud do to others too. But since nothing much happened, no follow ups. HR= plus 2 for doing the right thing.

Real ID given. and then those barrage of e-mails from Kangy and none in reply from HR. Kangy accuses him of Hacking and later her friend says she gave HR her password. What? Even if U or some1 deletes/edit stuff from ur computer or account, its easy for computer forensic to retrieve them and authenticate. I am no computer savvy guy but I knwo this much. Money is no issue if U wanna prove ur innocence. Kangy= Minus 5. False accusation, inconsistent story, one-sided conversation amounting to stalking and invading some1's privacy and emotionally blackmailing the person in the name of mental disorder.

Why HR didnt block her? Who knows how to deal with a psycho? She happens to be his colleague, costar and a friend at least.. he may have asked her to stop it over the phone. But the content may be disturbing ad better to save it if the day arrives as it did. Hr= 5 (no harsh treatment by totally avoiding and provoking her, but keeping the content safe as a proof). It must be a nightmare for any sane person to get involved with some1 like Kangy. U r doomed either way.

Legal notice= HR 0. Kangy's lawyer took smart step. Rather than "show us the proof" in which case, HR can and will, and cant be framed for defamation... he asked him to " if show it and we will sue U for defamation". Either way, its clear who is the guilty party. If Kangy is innocent and HR is making things up, then " where is the proof" but here " no, dont show or else...". 😆

So, the respected members of the jury, I rest my case... until we find out who the real imposter was/is. 😉 Any guesses?



Edited by AllBlacks1 - 9 years ago
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: hermione82

As per legal notice Rangoli told HR that Kangana is suffering from asperger's syndrome and asked them to kept quite


k this makes so much sense now . so HR will not be stupid to make up a story about Kangy's mental illness. so if his lawyer claims that Rangoli told him about it then i think they might have some evidence too. A person like him who attains to be perfect will not solely ruin his image just on the basis of his own imaginations right ? i am saying this because i have followed him since years, i at least know that he is intelligent when it comes to controversies, but this time he is aggressive too, it makes me doubt that he has some nasty proofs too.

AllBlacks1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: SunHarsh4eva


k this makes so much sense now . so HR will not be stupid to make up a story about Kangy's mental illness. so if his lawyer claims that Rangoli told him about it then i think they might have some evidence too. A person like him who attains to be perfect will not solely ruin his image just on the basis of his own imaginations right ? i am saying this because i have followed him since years, i at least know that he is intelligent when it comes to controversies, but this time he is aggressive too, it makes me doubt that he has some nasty proofs too.


The whole crew as witness as Kangy did tamasha in drunken state. I do blv HR may have believed she has some mental problems... as any1 can see it from far away too. Too bad, he didnt see it during Kites or else there wont be any K3 for her and HR wud have stayed clear of her.

Most of industry folks wud do that now.. its sad. Kangy is such a good actress and she worked hard for it.

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: beena_jon · 2 months ago

According to Bar and Bench, the disagreement began when Salman Khan entered into a trademark licensing agreement with Jerai Fitness through his...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 3 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/abhishek-bachchan-seeks-action-as-ai-generated-videos-of-aishwarya-and-salman-khan-go-viral_227788

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: JackSparrowcraz · 3 months ago

https://www.thestatesman.com/entertainment/bollywood/amid-deepfake-disaster-bollywood-draws-the-legal-sword-1503486980.html

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: BhataktiJawani · 4 months ago

What’s the plot behind all this? These two brothers don’t get along https://www.instagram.com/p/DNaCjQlB_NN/?igsh=MWE1bjNidGhtbm9zYg==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DNaCjQlB_NN/?igsh=MWE1bjNidGhtbm9zYg==
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".