VB : I am not anti-national but will comment on what is anti-human! - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

124

Views

12.3k

Users

29

Likes

250

Frequent Posters

ViccoTurmeric thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
The film is one dimensional


Doesn't show plight and tourture Kashmiri Pandits faced!
Army was shown to Benin negative light whereas really terriorts /reason behind whole scenario was ignored! Eg- Irfan Khan is terriorst in film but viewer starts to feel pity for him!

Film shouldn't be quoted with real scenario of Kashmir because there is lot not told in the film
-ajna- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Kashmir is a flash point not easy for anyone to unravel . We need to understand that not all Muslims are bad and neither are all Hindus good. The good and the bad co-exist in society and that dilemma gets magnified tenfold in Kashmir as it has remained the unresolved enigma of our country with so much Inter border intervention. As a result all have suffered manifold and continue to do so...unfortunately this year a natural disaster of mammoth scale escalated the suffering further.
The Army is an institution and tries to maintain order but as in any institution excesses will occur and these need to be identified and corrected.
It is the breed of politicians that prey on wounded emotions not letting any semblance of sanctity to return to the valley which must be one of the most beautiful places on the face of the earth.
As elsewhere it is the common man who is the sufferer as they try their best to live a normal life ...and the blood of the common man is easily dispensed with.
VB has made a valiant attempt and I found the movie remarkable in effort.I did not get the feeling that he was demonizing the Army or eulogizing the terrorist / separatist.
He was purely presenting the case of a normal family caught in the web and unable to extricate itself from it ..getting ground to smithereens between the nexus ...like wheat turning to atta in a chakki .
Such an effort needs to be applauded even if you disagree as cinema is a medium that elucidates the message increasing awareness .
If you disagree present the other side ..we will be waiting. Just do not compel others to hide the dust under the carpet .
And this is the power of democracy ..everyone can yet present their case unlike elsewhere where common voices are muzzled out.


-ajna- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: anoo67

i don't know if the film was anti army.i felt it was more pro terrorist.in the film,shahid kapoors father is not shown to be a decent law abiding citizen.he is shown to collaborate with known terrorists and harbouring and sheltering them.tabu,who is shown to be scared of her husbands doings,which is probably why she looks for support in kk,ironically,an advocate for human rights,who sympathizes with the state.a woman who is disconnected from her husband due to his terrorist leanings,blurts out to her lover that she is terrified of her situation,that is the trigger that sets off everyting,that is her betrayal.so wanting a normal life or living like a law abiding citizen is projected as a crime and that's where the bias shows.


The best assessment in my opinion !

anoo you have got the gist absolutely correct. I feel most are digressing from VB's theme and seeing things through their own experiences...some of which do no constitute the Haider story...or rather should the film have been called Ghazala instead ?
Both the story as well as acting wise Ghazala /Tabu steal the show !

For me it is Ghazala ..and VB missed out there ...he was not brave enough to make it a women centric film. Never mind Hamlet ...he said it is an adaptation did he not ?

But it takes a lot more courage to make a woman the central theme in India ! I would have clapped louder had he broken that barrier...because make no bones about it ...the women in Kashmir have borne the brunt of the horrors more then the men.

So why did VB back out there ...why did he not call his endeavour Ghazala ?

982969 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: anoo67

i don't know if the film was anti army.i felt it was more pro terrorist.in the film,shahid kapoors father is not shown to be a decent law abiding citizen.he is shown to collaborate with known terrorists and harbouring and sheltering them.tabu,who is shown to be scared of her husbands doings,which is probably why she looks for support in kk,ironically,an advocate for human rights,who sympathizes with the state.a woman who is disconnected from her husband due to his terrorist leanings,blurts out to her lover that she is terrified of her situation,that is the trigger that sets off everyting,that is her betrayal.so wanting a normal life or living like a law abiding citizen is projected as a crime and that's where the bias shows.



+1

Now that I have seen the movie, I agree with this as well...
nonam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
I think Haider's ending is very anti terrorist?

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche · 16 days ago

https://x.com/teamsrkfc/status/1966129713065369959

https://x.com/teamsrkfc/status/1966129713065369959
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche · 26 days ago

https://x.com/iamsrk/status/1962412795477233896?s=46

https://x.com/iamsrk/status/1962412795477233896?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Shamita Shetty slammed for not respecting the national anthem https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNYJmiOqe4s/?igsh=NmcyaXpva3pwdnox

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Sparkle_Soul · 1 months ago

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/urvashi-questions-criterion-for-choosing-national-award-for-best-actress/article69893815.ece/amp/...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche · 1 months ago

https://x.com/gulteofficial/status/1951217330458943759?s=46

https://x.com/gulteofficial/status/1951217330458943759?s=46
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".