Nonactor vs overactor? - Page 10

hrithik hamming in all his movies...pari nd anushka's loud acting in all movies...katrina's expressionless face in all movies...aur bahot hain..

Their stardom is unmatchable. Yes there are hrithiks ranbirs ranveers but no one can match khans stardom.

Originally posted by: Nilofar0416

I think TM just gave Salman and SRK as examples..He/She actually meant which one we prefer to watch Non Actor or Over Actor in general 😆

I generally prefer Subtle acting over OTT acting who has some fixed expressions like rolling or popping out eyes and mouthing dialogues in an annoyed voice. 😆 But unfortunately in BW over actors are known as best actors. 😆

Some 1 said if I keep opening topics like...? Ahem, I hardly open many topics. And thanx to those who think I have uinited sallu srk fans. And sorry to HR fans.. bechara bich me aa gaya.. 😆😆

Originally posted by: AllBlacks1

Some 1 said if I keep opening topics like...? Ahem, I hardly open many topics. And thanx to those who think I have uinited sallu srk fans. And sorry to HR fans.. bechara bich me aa gaya.. 😆😆

I have it b4 too. 😆 But for reason other than my disliking of both khans.

HR had to get a mention, who can beat his overacting in MPKDH...SRK with all his hamfest don't stand a chance against it 😆

Originally posted by: Breeezy

HR had to get a mention, who can beat his overacting in MPKDH...SRK with all his hamfest don't stand a chance against it 😆

If you ask me, both non actors and over actors cannot be watched for long. We need variety which is why all sorts of stars exist.

Originally posted by: AllBlacks1

FINALLY some1 got it what I was asking. Acc. to ma and for sure many others Srk is over actor and Salman is non-actor. Its my opinion and I gave it that as an example.

BUT if dont agree with that.. and think both 2 gr8 actors or whatever u think is also ur POV. I have no probs with that. How many BBs they gave, who cares since they r superstars, enterainers, no need to work hard since even crap mvies become BBs etc.. r all ok.

I also knew since I m HR fan there wud be backlash against HR too.😆And also knew Srk- Salman fans will unite and bash me or HR.😆

I think HR deserved all the applades, critical and BO for KMG act. He deserved it more than his KNPH... which btw got 102 awards in total. a record... he had toughest cometition that year.. and no he cant buy all awards.. But still some1 didnt like the perf. well, each to their own. Therez one movie HR surpassed srk's overacting in MPKDH.. and most HR fans will agree that (except shezadisakeena i guess). I cudnt made it DFDS and next day, WOM was so crap i watched it on DVD..But somehow i manged to finish the movie. I cudnt finish AMALL in cinema.. The movie signed by HR b4 KNPH realeased and Fiza and MK too. Vikram tried to reshot some scenes and songs to make it look like A grade movie which was B grade anyways..and Amisha' ashma attack sobbing thruout.. gosh horrible. K Mohammad or VVC didnt chnage the script or reshot some extra scenes for HR.. Fiza remains Karishma's movie with HR doing a 2nd fiddle. MK also had Sanju, HR and Jackie doing roles acc.to script.. and screen time. And these 3 movies made me HR fan.

Most HR fans will agree HR is weak in comedy dept. Srk and Sallu and Akshay r much better in comedy actor than him. Hez a method actor.. and comedy requires loosening up. sponteous, timing. No shame in admitting that. But if u say he hams or overacts in his all films.. I totally disagree. He gets into the skin of the character and method actor he is.. he pulls it off variety of roles. Proud to be HR fan.

Now back to the real question. If u have a choice of watching 2 movies.. ur fav. genre but both ave. by WOM. U r not fan of either leads of the movies but u know one is non actor and one overactor. Which movie wud go to?

Now, I say my opinion, I have liked Both Dabangs, Salman did just waht he was supposed to do. And we dont have to wait till last 15 min. when villain get bashed and untill then we have to go trhu torture of villani's atyachar.😆But then havent seen many salman movies, so it wasnt overdose.

Srk- since OSO never dared to watch any srk movie. I will watch Raees if the promos r prmosing.

So, If its a good mvoie i prefer non actor over over actor. If its ave. again the same. If its bad movie.. i wont watch it.

Edited .. typos

Coming to film choices, my preference is good looks, good music, comedy and feel good movies..I watch movies just like any general audience not like some pseudo intellectuals who did Masters in Movies. 😆 coz I watch movies only for entertainment purpose not for my thesis purpose.

If I have to choose the films as neutral then I go for subtle actor who has good looks. 😆 I watch bit loud films also but not too OTT. I think it's mix of subtle and loud. 😆 say for ex, I liked Salman's HDDCS, Tere Naam and at the same time Dabang..

I personally think except Katrina we don't have any non actor in BW..We have 2 kind of actors, subtle and OTT and some mix of both.

Salman is subtle actor, he isn't non actor..SRK is mix of subtle and OTT and HR is also mix of subtle and OTT. 😛

Coming to HR topic: I didn't see KMG, but I did see Krish , I enjoyed it as it has good visuals, music and looks.. 😆 His first movie was a rage, I remember we had HR's huge poster in our hostel room when the film KNPH was released and my city is not famous for hindi films and they hardly release. 😆 Actually what we enjoyed was his dances as they were new at that time. I liked his eyes..I have a fetish for eyes and my frd has lips. We didn't analyze abt acting skills and all in online forums. 😆

But HR can go too OTT in films and can be subtle. I personally liked him in subtle acting like JA, Agneepath coz when he goes OTT it's unbearable to watch. 😆 I liked him in Dhoom2 coz of his dances. 😆

Coming to BB Topic: I wonder how some people give films BB status whole credit to only male actors as in all BB there are other factors also like Music, Direction, good production values and most importantly their female partners.. I mean in all SRK BB's except CDI his female partners have equally imp role and they aren't flowerpot roles and had gr8 music coz his 99% success ratio is romantic genre where music and female partners also paly imp role. 😉 Same with Salman, check his ATBB HAHK, infact MD was hero of the movie, her backless blouses , her DIDI Tera song saree and dances in that film were a rage when it was released..MPK also had both hero and heroine had equal roles and music had gr8 impact. 😆 Even it applies to HR.. I'm just giving examples. It applies to all so called super stars.. 😆 If people really come to theatres only to watch Salman and SRK or for that matter any other super stars without any good script, music, gorgeous heroines then their Swadesh and Jai Ho would have became ATBB, there are many other such films. 😉 😆

😆 But I hardly watch movies in theatres..I watch them in DISH TV.. 🤣

@ Nirofar.. liked ur post. Didnt like salman Hr comaprision in terms of acting, but its cool.