Just how original is Queen?

chimchimcher-ee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Just how original is Queen?

By Ankur PathakAnkur Pathak, Mumbai Mirror | Apr 24, 2014, 04.02 AM IST
Just how original is Queen?
A still from Queen, (inset) Synopsis of The Art of Travel according to IMDB


Loading
The 'honeymoon alone' twist resounds in the American indie, The Art of Travel.

A scuppered wedding, heartbreak and then the bride-tobe going off on her honeymoon alone, Vikas Bahl's Queen is being celebrated for being fiercely original. But Mirror has stumbled upon a 2008 American indie drama, The Art of Travel, which has some striking similarities with Bahl's film.

The difference is that in the film directed by Thomas Whelan, it is the groom-to-be who discovers that his bride has been cheating on him and calls off the wedding as they are about to exchange vows. Then, like Rani, this Raja too sets off on his honeymoon alone, setting aside parental apprehensions. On the way, he meets with an eclectic bunch and they become elemental in his quest of self-discovery.

Even though Conner's forest adventure is nothing like Rani's drunken escapades, the novel 'honeymoon without a husband (or a wife)' twist that has caught the imagination of the Indian viewers, cannot be discounted.

We called Bahl to check whether the American drama had inspired Queen, but he didn't respond to our calls or text messages. However, his spokesperson later called in to say, "Sex in the City, Under the Tuscan Sun, Eat Pray and Love also have the same story, so does that mean they are all inspired by each other? And Queen also is inspired by them?"

This is not the first time Queen has faced a plagiarism charge. In the past, writer Abhigyan Jha claimed that several scenes from the film had been lifted from the Parvati Balagopalan-directed Phir Zindagi, which was shown to Bahl during his tenure as the head of UTV Spotboy. Phir Zindagi never got a theatrical release.
Edited by eeyoretel - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.4k

Users

12

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

KuKKad_MalHOTra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
If Queen was a flop, nobody would have bothered.
Kahan kahan se chale aa jate hain!🥱
TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I had read somewhere that there are hardly 4-5 original stories and the rest are all versions of the same 4-5 stories. Maybe its the same case with Queen as far as the American film is concerned though Jha's claims seem pretty legit as he had given Bahl the script.
Edited by RockChicGirl - 11 years ago
.Bongsookie. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Then 90% of Bollywood films aren't original. Same story:

Boy meets girl, both fall in love. Want to get married, both set of parents disagree and boy and girl work together to make the parents agree for the wedding. 😆
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
😆😆 Kuch bhi ! I liked the answer of Bahl's spokesperson.. Right response to an over-inquisitive and gossip-freak journo ! 😵
salta thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Well does it really matter? I mean even the most celebrated writers do take inspirations are sometimes just rewrite the whole thing... And chalo yaar american movie se hi toh inspiration li hai...itna toh aaram se chalta hai.The noticeable point is they picked a story, and didn't screwed it up, but made a story in Indian background; also here it was a girl, and a girl in Indian context changes lots of things altogether in itself.
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Actually there only 7 foundational themes or plots in the world. It's how you tell the story, shape the characters, change the setting, explore the charcter flaws that makes an idea original.

Some will say Queen is very much like JWM in a sense that a girl is growing and discovering herself, and sort of a coming-of-age type theme. But all the stuff in between is where the freshness lies. And I love the ending: she walks out and is independent. She doesn't end up with a love interest and is still finding herself. Now that's original for a BW film.

Either way, if the film had flopped no one cares, but b/c it's a success everyone does. So they did something right. Besides, how recycled are masala flicks and yet the audience flocks to go watch them. At least this one isn't the same contrite formula with a macho hero saving the damsel in distress all wrapped together with a perfectly timed item song. 😆
return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Nothing in this world is original. Anything you have thought of. Someone else has thought of already.

chimchimcher-ee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

I think it's Bahl's PR who published this one; so that, people find it ridiculous & forget that Bahl had stolen a few scenes from that Parvathy Balagopalan movie.

Remember the fake audio tape Sallu & his lawyers released? People laughed at the tape & dismissed it.. though only police had the original audio tape.

809123 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

Nothing in this world is original. Anything you have thought of. Someone else has thought of already.


everything is a copy of a copy of a copy of a copy of a copy...

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: mintyblue · 1 months ago

...

Expand â–¼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: cougarTown · 29 days ago

https://youtu.be/voqgf54vZ7Y?si=V0KS37XqQEId8OTu It took 23 years to find this gem. After PC..finally we have a beauty queen who is truly...

https://youtu.be/voqgf54vZ7Y?si=V0KS37XqQEId8OTu
Expand â–¼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/kangana-ranaut-set-to-juggle-two-major-sequels-as-queen-2-tanu-weds-manu-3-get-rolling_226563

Expand â–¼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: BhataktiJawani · 5 months ago

Let’s hear it from the Horses mouth herself https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIO32QGB3uB/?igsh=cjJ4MXhqYTk4OGZ6

Expand â–¼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 6 months ago

https://www.mid-day.com/entertainment/bollywood-news/article/shekhar-kapur-bandit-queen-ott-cut-without-permission-amazon-prime-video-23501776

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".