Has Deepika Padukone surpassed Aishwarya Rai Bachchan? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

7k

Users

36

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#41
Definitely not.

The problem with Aishwarya is that her good work is extremely underrated and because of her war with the Khans, her achievements would always be downplayed. Otherwise I think her roles in Chokar Bali, Raincoat, Provoked, and even Umrao Jaan would have made a lot of noise. She got snubbed and ignored many times for giving good performances like in Guru, Jodha Akbar, Guzarish. I guess she doesn't have the time or the need to do extracurricular activities to get noticed or hyped up.

The industry was very hard on her...she never even got credit for the huge hit that Robot was, one of the first movies to reach 200 crore mark - but then the industry has no problem crediting Katrina for Dhoom-3 or Deepika for Race-2 where they had no roles.

Also, Bride & Prejudice, is the only film with an Indian female lead that was a huge world-wide hit. For its time, that was massive. But because it was a flop in India, people cant seem to think beyond that.


As for Deepika, she may have beat Ash in terms of having so many hits, but with those hits it doesn't mean anything. Katrina has the most hits, has she surpassed anyone?

Like someone said, Aishwarya is BEYOND her movies. If we look at numbers and the "technical" side then ya maybe Deepiak is doing better...but in terms of being an icon, superstar, celebrity - Aishwarya is in a different galaxy then Deepika.

Deepika belongs in the category of the "Rani and Preity's"...Within 5 years, nobody will care about her, but Aishwarya will still be relevant.

The fact that Deepika is even being compared to Aishwarya says a lot in itself. I mean you wouldn't compare her to Amisha Patel or Lara Dutta right? Her success, star power, and name is hugly underrated - She didn't make it to Time Magazines Most Influential List for NO REASON>
Edited by Shaitan-Haiwan - 11 years ago
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#42
Do you know that Aish is actually one of Deepika's inspiration along with PC and Bipasha too?!

I've seen Dippy model her career off of Aish b/c both are outsiders, beautiful faces, model turn actresses and both at the start of their careers faced criticisms like "wooden planks", "Another pretty face", "can't act", etc. Like Aish, Dippy has made sure that she chooses performance-oriented scripts. If she does a rom-com or a masala flick like CE, she sure made sure she wasn't a pretty piece of furniture or it wasn't a flowerpot role. And I see that similarity with Aish who has doen films like Robot and AR and got a meaty role.

Either way, Aish in her own league with a body of work that speaks for itself. I remember the days when this forum as a majority thought she can't act and how the dynamics have changed, where more of the majority are finally given Aish her due.

Dippy had a great year and has improved a lot and if she keeps it up, she's be in her own league. But I think it's too early to say if she's surpass ARB b/c Aishwarya Rai isn't just a name anymore, it's like a brand in a way. Like till date her name sells, people are curious about her, and she gets big film offers from big names. And def means Aish has achieved a lot.

desigal90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#43
I dont think Deepika has "surpassed" any of the past "top heroines" tbh.
She IS on the rise, but everything she's achieved, her contempories/past top actresses have already achieved.

Awards? Yeah, Kareena, Aish, Rani garnered a plenty.

Hits? Yeah, same there.

Top films with the Khans and superstars? Yeah, all of them also had those days where they had all the producers clamoring for them.

She has a long way to go, coz in addition to those, those girls also made a mark somewhere else somehow.

Aish has her international fame, Rani has done ICONIC films, Kareena has one of the longest career spans for bollywood actress and a statue in Madame Tussauds, etc etc.

Only one she's really already surpassed is Katrina, coz all there was to Kat was the hits, which dpad has easly accumulated in one year.
Edited by desigal90 - 11 years ago
JungFrau thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44
Ash has been in her own league all her career. Somehow her popularity has nothing to do with her movies or acting. So, acting wise even if kareena or PC or Rani have been superior, they never really surpassed Ash in popularity. Neither will Katrina or deepika. She will remain as popular 5 years down the line too I guess.
Enycedoll thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45
Aishwarya honestly only had a few notable performances in her career and they werent commercial successes. She is not a great actress, her strength was always her dancing abilities and her beauty with the latter taking her far.
Deepika may make it farther than Ash in the acting department but shes yet to do anything thats made me stand up and say: hey, that was great. shes too new right now and shes only getting settled in.

so, no. she hasnt surpassed Ash...yet.


also...are we discussing performances or popularity? because from im reading alot of people have the two mixed up.
Edited by Enycedoll - 11 years ago
.khoobsurat. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#46
Popuarity wise..I think Aish is more popular. Deepika's hype has started only this year so we have to see if she can keep her popularity in the upcoming years.
Acting wise...I think Aish is a better actress. There are tons of Aish performances I loved..but none of Deepika's performances were good enough for me. She was good in Coctail and CE..but not good enough for me to go WOW..her performance was brilliant. I never want to watch any of Deepika's films because of her performance...but with Aish..films like HDDCS and Taal..I want to see it for her performance and beauty. And I have watched these films a million times because of Aish's performance.
Edited by beboholic - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

Has Saiyaara 2025 Surpassed Aashiqui 1990 In Terms Of Popularity Aahan And Aneet Vs Rahul And Anu

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: fazgostoso · 3 days ago

Angry Salman Khan would say Aishwarya Rai thinks she looks beautiful, 'usko bolo Waheeda Rahman ko dekhe', recalls Himani Shivpuri | Hindi Movie...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 7 days ago

...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 15 days ago

https://telanganatoday.com/aishwarya-rai-moves-delhi-hc-to-protect-personality-rights-seeks-action-against-ai-generated-obscene-content

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: fazgostoso · 11 days ago

I feel it has been to many years now since she has done a Bollywood movie. 7 years I want her to do a role again but it has to be meaty and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".