Aish vs Kat in Dhoom series

CONTEST : IPL 2026 Prediction Game

Page

Next Last

664269

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

many arguements and fights took place..

Aish fans claimed Aish was a better dancer and had a lead role in the film..

not only that she had been put in the centre of the poster and highlighted in D2 trailer..

Kat fans refuted , that Kat wasnt much in the trailer becos makers want to keep her role a mystery and shock the audience..

They also said Aish overacted in her sunehri role, and Kat has a hotter body, and bets dance moves..

she is definitely the best dhoom girl, her song got this million hits in utube, she has proven it...

Deepika will be forgotten after dhoom3 is released...

so as the film released, and everything is clarified, i wana say that no matter how Aish acted in D2, she still had the best role after Hrithik, the role was as par to him... their chemistry is considered as iconic whereas Kat doenst even get to romance Aamir onscreen apart from the kiss..LOL..

So, Aish still remains the best dhoom girl.

Quote

Frequent Posters

zara321

@zara321

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

Aish is better because poor kat got literally a few songs and about 4 scenes in the movie. Aish was the second lead in dhoom 2 and in the movie from start to finish.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

643898

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

Its not even a competition now😆 Kat should be compared with rimi sen

Quote

Winzy

@nicegirl_good

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

If aish worked with aamir the same Thing would happen to her

The bigger , the more star power goes to aamir

And aish did have a lead role , and hritik is not aamir who cuts screen time 🤢

I am so disappointed in the makers , they promoted kat like no tomorrow

But the actual film barely shows her

I loved the movie though , the script was good

But the fan in me is disappointed !!

Quote

ashna

@ashna26

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Totally agree!! Dhoom 2 was all about Hrithik and Aishwarya. They were a hot couple. Just love their chemistry. They just have to look at each other! And you go wow!! 😊

Quote

664269

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ilovedhanjanird
If aish worked with aamir the same Thing would happen to her
The bigger , the more star power goes to aamir
And aish did have a lead role , and hritik is not aamir who cuts screen time 🤢
I am so disappointed in the makers , they promoted kat like no tomorrow
But the actual film barely shows her
I loved the movie though , the script was good
But the fan in me is disappointed !!

plss be logical atleast when u defend the blunders that have happened..

Kat is not a C-grade newcomer, whose role will be cut and she wouldnt have a knowledge pls..

Stop blaming Aamir for her blunder, she is mature enuff to know about her role and then do the film, and she obviously knew what big role she had in the film..

Aamir can edit one-two scenes here and there, but he cannot edit a 2 hour role of any actor in a 3 hr long film ...

Aish would not do such a role only becos she was doing a 200 cr film, she did bad films too, but she had prominent roles in them..

Quote

Winzy

@nicegirl_good

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

plss be logical atleast when u defend the blunders that have happened..
Kat is not a C-grade newcomer, whose role will be cut and she wouldnt have a knowledge pls..
Stop blaming Aamir for her blunder, she is mature enuff to know about her role and then do the film, and she obviously knew what big role she had in the film..
Aamir can edit one-two scenes here and there, but he cannot edit a 2 hour role of any actor in a 3 hr long film ...

Aish would not do such a role only becos she was doing a 200 cr film, she did bad films too, but she had prominent roles in them..

When was the last time aamir gave a prominent role to his female co stars ?

Even talaash had rani in a short role and Kareena too

And I'm sure kat didn't shoot for 3 scenes only

How is that even possible

I'm sure the movie was edited like no tomorrow

And okay aish is a goddess landed on earth 👏

But she never had a film with aamir in 2013 so the comparison is unfair

And it's always the lead actors who decide who get the most screen timescreen time😲

Quote

JodhaBai

@JodhaBai

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

Aishwarya acted with Rajnikanth and had a big role. That doesn't happen in Rajni masala movies but it happens with Aishwarya

Quote

AllBlacks1

@AllBlacks1

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Aamir does have influence in editing dept.. for any of his films.. but he does it to the best intrest of the film.

Why wud he chop off Kat's scenes when actually Kat is Samar- his dumb brother's (himself of corse) love interest? With every Kat scenes there wud be Aamir with her.. so chopping Kat;s scenes means hez chopping off his own scenes too. Why wud he do that?

The film is long enuff and doesnt make u fell bored..

Feel sorry for Kat but she must have knew b4hand. I wud have really loved to see her assisting Aamir in heist with her acrobatic stunts being used for a purpose. But.. well 😕

Quote

AllBlacks1

@AllBlacks1

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

As for Aish.. yes she was irritating with her "what the... funny guy.. " kinda dialogs.. but that her role.. be annoying 😆 And yes with HR ... the screen is on fire.. The russian rullete scene.. wow. She acted with her eyes.. 😲

Its not fair for Kat to compare with Aish.. Kat just didnt have the role.