Jab Tak Hai Jaan reviews! - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

667

Views

89.4k

Users

101

Likes

1.9k

Frequent Posters

gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago

Jab Tak Hai Jaan Movie Review

Comments
By Pooja Rao
Posted on 13 November 2012 in Movie Reviews, Movies, News, Reviews, Slider, Stars

A Love without life, or a life without love? Time is the strongest tests of relationships? Or something like that! Through Dil Toh Paagal Hai, Yash Chopra made famous the 'someone somewhere is made for you' belief. With Jab Tak Hai Jaan, he elucidates the concept of timeless love. Every relationship has its time, it's believed. If something is meant to happen or not is a trick of destiny, all you've got to give it is your honest best.

JTHJ is the story of Samar Anand (Shah Rukh Khan) tracing his life across a span of around 10 years–one as a young musician in London picking up odd jobs to make a honest yet cheerful livelihood while second as Major Samar Anand of the Indian army, where he's tagged as 'the man who cannot die' owing to his record of diffusing 98 bombs without any bomb suits or safety. While musician Samar is a carefree, extrovert, charming person who makes friends easily as he goes, Major Samar is a recluse, who mostly keeps to himself, playing the dutiful army officer one bomb at a time. Meera (Katrina Kaif) and Akira (Anushka Sharma) play the two loves, who enter at different stages of his life. What circumstances led the effervescent Samar to retreat into a life of solidarity, what's the emotional baggage he carries and what happens when the lives of the three characters intertwine forms the narrative of Jab Tak Hai Jaan.

Of the two leading ladies Anushka scores over her co-star. Her character as a fiery bindaas daredevil is perfectly written and she makes it to her advantage. The chemistry she shares with Shah Rukh continues in the same vein from RNBDJ.. not too subtle, not too over-played, she is a complete pleasure to watch. Katrina is comparatively average. While her character has a graph which requires her to be restrained at most times, that is no argument, especially in her scenes with SRK, where she falls immensely flat and looks confused. Coming to the man of the moment, Shah Rukh, looking decidedly dapper in bow-tie as ruggedly composed in army attire, makes JTHJ all about him. Effortless in a character only he could've pulled off with so much lan, he adopts Samar's arrogance and confidence with equal balance, proving exactly why his name is synonymous with romance. There are moments in the film you feel sorry for him having to work against a tide of flimsy material and weak chemistry, but against all odds, he manages to wax coat with SRK charm. There is a lovely casting of Rishi and Neetu Kapoor in a cameo and while the scene was meant to be between Neetu and Katrina, Rishi Kapoor steals it with an endearing grin and a wave of a wine glass.

The somgs, composed by A R Rahman penned by Gulzar already well received, is magnified on screen. I am not a particular fan of the album in its entirety, but you can't help enjoying the beats when 'Challa' plays (yes, plural!) or tap your feet at 'Ishq Shava', packaged very well with trick choreography, which surprisingly Shah Rukh pulls off quite convincingly. What doesn't work in its favor is the songs are too close within minutes of each other. Especially in the first half where most of the tracks are stacked up, while 'Saans' re-runs in the background score of the second-half make them a tedious watch after a point of which you wish you could reach out for the fast-forward button.

JTHJ is a Yash Chopra film of 2012. So the white chiffon sari is replaced with white night gown, Switzerland is traded for Kashmir, but the soul of a Yash Raj cinema is intact. At a gracious run-time of close to 3hours, JTHJ is a couple reels too long, but the filmmaker's zeal for cinema livens up the otherwise dull moments of the film. This is aptly put together in the end credits of the film, a montage of the film's making which shows Yash Chopra's excitement every time he screamt action, or the candid joyful expressions of seeing his actors enact his vision. Beneath a very routine motorbike sequence in the bare terrains of Ladakh, or a simple conversation at a park in London, there lies a Yash Chopra charisma that simply can't be stripped off or ignored. 'If you're not happy, you cannot make anyone else happy', a character says. Yash Chopra knew this too well. He enjoyed his work, he was happy, he tried to make sure others were happy as well thru his cinema.

For those with pre-conceived notions of this being an out-and-out soppy romantic tale, the screenplay by Aditya Chopra and Devika Bhagat is much more than that. In the midst of a love triangle, there is a story of survival, a tale of letting go, moving on, embracing life as it comes, questioning of faith, challenging of religious beliefs all done without any hum-drums of cheap innuendos, gags or toilet humor, just in shades of pristine white purity. Loaded with references from Yash Raj classics, maintaining an old world sincerity, JTHJ also treads into sub-plots of extra-marital affairs, a barter-trade like relationship with the Almighty, etc. Undoubtedly, the romantic scenes stand out the most, treated with substance and maturity in the experienced hands of Yash Chopra, executing them the way YRF knows best.

JTHJ will possibly not be heralded as a landmark film, it won't run for weeks together like its other predecessor from the production house; however it's one of the better romances to come out of Bollywood in recent times. Yes it's sloppy, yes it's amusingly clichd, loopholes/facts hard to look past, but SRK makes it work, one aviator-clad stubble form, one honest act, one engaging performance. Maybe sometimes that's all there is, Jab Tak Hai Khan.

Our rating:
426420 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Sunny Malik ?@sunnymalik

Was an emotional experience watching Yashji's final film.


aww.

naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Very Very Very Disappointing to say the least
Did not feel like a YC film at all. I respect yash ji and his past works a lot but this is his weakest and Worst film till date. I bet if he wouldn't have died the film would have fallen flat on it's face whatever business it's gonna do in coming days will be only because of the fact that it's his last.

To Me the best Part of the film Is the end credits and That's it it made me emotional and i got carried away Rest is TOOO BORINGGG and LONG And AWKWARD why so many awkward liplocks and the love making scene is Just gross not at all shot well .

P.s i have nothing against the actors i liek them All and i felt kat was better than her past work However, SRK & Kat has0 or shoul i say chemistry in Negative digits it's like non existant and they just look uncomfortable onscreen . Anushka did well as akira and really added some jaan to this Otherwise bejaan movie

my rating between 1.5 to 2 out of 5
Sorry it's the bitter truth
Raiinie2 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Well, seems like I am going to be in the minority who dint quite enjoy the film as i wanted too. I don't know why i feel apologetic about it, maybe cause this was Yash Raj's last film and i really wanted to like it. But somehow, i just couldn't make myself do so. The Yash Raj magic i expected, was a miss. The Yash Raj romance i yearned for wasn't there. The characters, i just couldn't relate too nor could i empathise with. Thus, maybe its the disconnect with the characters, that i wasn't fully able to emerse in the film and enjoy it. Sigh. The only good thing about the film were the locations- Ladakh and Kashmir. Ahhh what scenic beauties and very well captured in the film!
The film was tad lengthy, i mean i expected it to be long but this was LOOONG! SRK/Katrina/Anuskha were all good. SRK is seriously born for these romantic type roles, this is where he is best at and he does shine. WOW!!! At Katrina's dancing, before the ishq Shava song. Ahhh she looks so fitt!!! *thinspiration* Some scenes were unesseccary and uncomfortable to watch- the word 'cringe' comes to my mind!
It saddens me to say this but I would have probably suggested waiting on JTHJ to release on DVD, if it was not Yash Raj's last film!

P.S: Was SRK wearing coloured lens in the film???
426420 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

'Jab Tak Hai Jaan' review: Old wine in new bottle!


by Monika Rawal | on November 13th, 2012 |

If you plan to watch 'Jab Tak Hai Jaan' with huge expectations, I'd suggest don't, for there is nothing extraordinary about the film as such that will leave you awestruck. Except that JTHJ is a typical Yash Chopra film that is bound to touch your hearts and the 'happy ending' that leaves you with a smiling face.

Once again, it was a great script for Yash Chopra's favourite muse Shahrukh Khan and it indeed was a comeback for him. Being a die hard SRK fan, I can say this without much of a doubt. Portraying a soldier (Samar Anand) in the Indian army and playing a romantic 20 something hero, it's tough to ignore Shahrukh Khan's screen presence that dominated the screen throughout the length of the movie.

Contrary to how Yash Chopra heroines have been usually portrayed so far, 'Jab Tak Hai Jaan' has tactically replaced the chiffon saree clad heroines with hip and chic starlets. Watching Katrina Kaif (Meera) was actually a surprising treat. With acting par excellence, it looked as it she was made to do this role. Needless to mention Katrina proved once again that she is Bollywood's best import till date. Desi girl Anushka Sharma (Akira Rai) was no less either when it came to being at her chirpy and quirky best. The trio as a whole created an enigma that just managed to hold on to the movie lovers, even if they didn't wish to sit till the end.

Predictable story yet narrated in the most interesting way, JTHJ catches on minute details that eventually turn out to be high points of the film. Capturing the streets of the London in the most beautiful way and switch to picturesque Ladakh, the transition in the film was something that caught my eye. Each angle shot with a thought to make it look as larger-than-life as it can be. Something that only Yash Chopra could have done. The music might sound a bit unusual for a Yash Raj Film, still it manages to strike a chord with music buffs.

To sum up, I surely would say, 'Jab Tak Hai Jaan' came as an ultimate tribute to veteran filmmaker Yash Chopra and directing this film has been the best gift that he could have given to his fans before he walked his way to heaven. Thank you Yash Ji'

http://hotklixblog.com/jab-tak-hai-jaan-review-old-wine-in-new-bottle/
SRK-BEBO thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
after a long time, I watched a good commercial movie with out loud jokes, over the top masala, item numbers and screams.
The movie is good, I can give 4/5 , but I will settle for 3.75/5 as a strict cinema lover due to few flawa JTHJ carries.
Performances
Katrina- Its definitely her best if we avoid 3-4 scenes of her which is not up to the mark.
Anu- She did well in few parts, but surprisingly I found her over the top in few scenes
SRK- What can I say? He shows what a powerhouse performer he is.. Definitely the best commercial performance this year with out any doubt. I can say he exceeded Ranbi's brafi performance as the army officer. As younger Samar, except 2-3 scenes, he has done very well.
Editing: ahhh:X they could have trimmed 30 minutes easier and make this film as a great film, but they didnt. Its long specially the first half.
Katrina is the best dancer no doubt.
If you ever expect there will be another romanric movie which will be able to hold your breath from youngfer stars and younger directors, sorry there will be no more.
No body can ever do romance like SRK and make larger than life love stories like Yash ji.
'if you think there will another but better Mausam, sorry it will not happen. Romance is dying and you will not ablle to watch them in future flicks.
Dont expect another Veer zara kind of attachments. You wont sigh like SRK carries PZ over the bridge, you will not get shocked and emotional like when you see OLD PZ at Veer's home nor you will get tears rolling up and sighs like when they start playing Tere Liye.
This has its own story and own life of romance with a bit practical and modern touch.
Music- watch out for the song which is not released. Its the best. But Rahman's music just go with the story and connect with it. But not make a huge impact.
Direction- Yash ji will be missed. Breath taking visuals, have never seen such amazing visuals, camera angles.
Go and watch it. Highly recomend it. It's a muct watch and you will have great time.
ps: who the hell said movie is sad: huh..Movie is emotional and has touchy moments and specially a soul, but its not a depressing saga..lol at liers who spread bogus reviews.😳
I as a SRK fan, I am so happy with the movie. He delivers an awesome performance. I skipped all the reviews, I dont know what people are talking about. But I am sure no body will bash SRK's performance if he is not a hell biased person with some agenda. He carries the film and the life of the film. No one can do romance like him man. He specially in the second half, just act with his eyes.
I will still consider Swades as the best of him, cause it's not a larger than life role and that genre is my favorite.
Thanks
-SalShah4eva- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
My reviews for the movie:)

Movie starts with Yashji pic and his words which he mentioned in his birthday interview😊
Then SRK came there in the bike omg How hot he was looking
Everybody in the theater was whistling & was yeyyy SRK😆
I tell you he looked the best in the uniform. I cannot describe how good he looked☺️

Not going to mention anything about the plot do not want to spoil it for others.😳

I am sorry but I did not liked the first half of the movie. I thought everyone was loving it but I couldn't it I loved the movie after Intermission. It was not slow neither boring don't what people makes think that.
In the first half I liked the story after both were in love and how the movie spread away.
And there were some good parts and funny too. I liked that dialog "Done, Done London" 🤣

Coming to anushka, when the movie start it was okay she did over act in the begining but after intermission she was too adorable😳
Loved her scenes with SRK and it was cute. And those army officers and akira scenes😆
Too adorable. She was in love with Samar Anand and calls him "sexy" and talks about how she wants to do sex🤣
There were only like 2 or 3 scene where she over acted that was in the beginning of the movie but after that she was awesome. She was cutiepie😊

Yes, SRK kissed Kat but I won't call that Kiss🤣
But I am really disappointed with SRK why did he broke his rules. I am just thinking he refused to kiss in OSO isn't this unfair now😕
Their first kiss was needed but did not get it other ones😆
Omg that few sec sex in the saans song OMG😆

Coming back to Kat, the surprise pack of the movie was Katerina Kalf😲
First of all she looked so beautiful in all of her dresses and Indian clothes she wore too😊
Regarding her acting wow she improved so much👏 i am going to be honest there were only 2 or 3 scenes I thought she can be good @ it but its alright in other scenes she was good. I wont say wow she was perfect but deff improved and gave expression too and I mean it. Now people don't say it she doesnt know how to act
Thank god Kat surprised me with her this movie and till date this is best performance so far😳 Kat played her Meera role very well👍🏼 I would like to see her and SRK more movie woh bhi in a romantic movie😃

Not going to say anything about SRK because he was amazing in samar anad role the one with the beard. He little bit reminds me of Kabir Khan from CDI😆
Amit ji said after swades this was her best performance I can say hmm kinda but he was good in SA 😊

All three were good in their roles and yash ji choose right actors for Meera, Samar and akira role. Now I cannot imagine somebody else played by Samar Anand, Meera and akira😳

But overall, it was good movie and there were some beautiful moments. I especially, enjoyed the Ladak one more😛

If People are expecting this movie to be like Veer Zaara or another Yash ji then u guys are wrong. This movie is totally different than VZ and other Yash ji so don't expect anything.

There were 3 or 4 moments i got teary eyes did not cried I was about to but did not. And i really felt it scene between anu and SRK @ the airport😳
Everybody thought SRK would😆 but nothing happned like that
& aditi and every1 that person posted spoiler it was nothing like that😡
Jhoote log😡

All due to respect Yash ji. I enjoyed the movie and some of the parts were good and I dont think now we will see movie like this..
Yash ji Thank you so much🤗
RIP

I will give 3.5 out of 5 because my expectation were very high and it was below my expectation. Sorry, I have to be honest here😳

EDIT: Everyone has different opinion and different taste. So, this was mine😳
Hazardous thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
To be honest I do classify this movie as a sad film. At the end I did not feel light at all. My heart was heavy.
426420 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
WOW Glamsham the harsh site, gave it 4 stars YAY



Movies

Jab Tak Hai Jaan Movie Review


The lover boy is back!

Jab Tak Hai Jaan
Director : Yash Chopra
Music : A.R.Rahman
Lyrics : Gulzar and Aditya Chopra
Starring : Shah Rukh Khan, Katrina Kaif and Anushka Sharma
November 13, 2012 07:33:17 PM IST
By Martin D'Souza, Glamsham Editorial
Send to Friend



The late Yash Chopra is known for grandeur and an eye for detail. His last outing behind the camera is lavish on both counts. The splendor of Ladakh and London is captured beautifully - the detailing of scenes is impeccable. The late director infuses romance into every situation; capturing the mood of even the flowers in the vases! Every scene has a connotation to the ones preceding or the ones gone by. Only the length is a bit tiring as he labours to bring the love story to its ultimate end.

However, Yashji had a brilliant opportunity to stun the audience in the last scene as Major Samar (Shah Rukh Khan) goes about diffusing his last bomb. A change in the fate of this situation would, to my mind, have catapulted this film from a simple love story to an unforgettable one.

view JAB TAK HAI JAAN videos

Major Samar heads the Bomb Diffusing Squad in the Indian Army. He has diffused 98 bombs so far, all without a protective gear. We soon learn that there is a method to this madness of his. At every turn, he is embracing death, challenging the one above, because the love of his life Meera (Katrina Kaif) has decided to stay away from him so that he lives a long life.

The story begins with Samar diffusing one such bomb and then rushing into the cold waters of Leh to save another! This one is Akira (Anushka Sharma). Without so much as a backward glance, Samar moves off on his bike after rescuing Akira and putting on his jacket on her. Akira chances upon his personal diary in which Samar has penned his love story.

JAB TAK HAI JAAN then moves to London where Samar is making ends meet juggling between three jobs. He runs into Meera when he is cleaning the front of a Church.

The establishing of Samar and Meera and the blossoming of their love story is quick and to the point. The late director does not waste time in getting Samar make his feelings known to Meera and Meera recipocrating.

But here is when the twist in the tale appears. Meera is all set to break off her engagement to her childhood friend, when things go wrong for them.




Samar is forced to return to India. In retaliation, he joins the Indian Army and embraces death at every given opportunity.

Akira, a student learning the ropes of television journalism, who he had saved, gets to spend two weeks with his camp and here is when she does a Samar on him. Meaning: she expresses her love for him just as Samar had done with Meera at a London station - at a time least expected. But for Samar, there cannot be another Meera.

Akira's documentary on Samar gets her a ticket to Discovery Channel, but for that she has to get Samar to London. He agrees after first refusing. Once in London, things go wrong for Samar again.

Meera's help has to be sought as Akira goes in search of her. It's 10 years now since he last met Meera. What would the situation be like?


The styling of the film is super. No efforts are lacking in making it look and feel grand. The Music By A R Rahman, though not ranking among his best, does get you grooving. The choreography is splendid, especially the dance track where Meera lets her hair down with Samar. Awesome.

Shah Rukh Khan is back to his basic form - that of a lover boy. He essays his character effortlessly; carrying the weight of someone who can be dumped with bravado and then brooding over his lost love with aplomb. He balances the shift in roles with ease and even handles the advances of an enthusiastic and optimistic Akira with maturity.

Katrina Kaif is fabulous. Her transformation from a rich girl trapped in a fancy world who gets to let her hair down is fantastic. She carries off the farce while exposing who she really is on the inside is very emotional.


Yash Chopra had mentioned that this would be the last film he would direct. He has left a lasting impression with this one.

Will it be curtains now for grand romances? Only time will tell.

But for now, relish JAB TAK HAI JAAN!

PS: There is one huge flaw in the script that sends the film nose-diving. Akira making a mention of Meera to Samar in the most serious of situations. This, too, when their relationship has not yet been established. To the director's credit, he quickly submerges the flaw. But still, it does stick out like a sore thumb.

Anushka Sharma's character too is forced. Probably, if her character was done away with, the film would have been crisper.



Rating: 4.0
http://www.glamsham.com/movies/reviews/jab-tak-hai-jaan-movie-review-111202.asp
-SalShah4eva- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Raiinie2


🤗🤗 Seems like its only us two, who feels this way. Hmmm.. waiting to read other IF members review.

u guys can include me too..I only liked the movie after intermission
I liked the movie but nothing extra ordinary 😳

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

5 months ago

Hai Jawani Toh Ishq Hona Hai - Varun Dhawan Pooja Hegde

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/varun-dhawan-and-pooja-hegde-wrap-shoot-for-hai-jawani-toh-ishq-hona-hai-in-rishikesh-dive-in-the-ga_219729

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/varun-dhawan-and-pooja-hegde-wrap-shoot-for-hai-jawani-toh-ishq-hona-hai-in-rishikesh-dive-in-the-ga_219729
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

1 months ago

Dhadak 2 - Reviews And Box Office

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim Released on hotstar 25/7

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

1 months ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

1 months ago

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".