Rani vs Vidya

wouldnt OH LALA and AGA BAI be better comparison

i doubt many have even seen these yet

vidya's mala dau crap crap was such a joke 😆 poor girl gets carried away, its always tough to be just an actor, they always want more and end up making disasters

agreed

rani is one of the best dancers around, vidya has two left feet, she cant even move properly. period!

Originally posted by: SRK_fanatic

Rani obviously a better dancer and her moves were better.Vidya's attire and choreography of the song suckedd!

Rani might be a good dancer but as an actress i would rank Vidya higher anyday
Vidya is versatile and bold.She didnt need Khans to make her a big name in industry
Rani would've ruined TDP like she did with Dil bole hadippa,Bunty aur bubbly with her loud overacting.Dont think she is a complete package at all .She was epic fail in bubbly roles from DBH to BnB to now Aiyya.Cant ever forget her hilarious modern avatar in Ta rum pum songs with Saif.Like Vidya she is also average looking.She cant do glamorous roles like Aish or Kareena.Though she was considered the queen of BW for 1-2 yrs she could never gather an opening like Kareena did with heroine.So yes she is overrated ,especially as a 'star' 😛

Originally posted by: PandorasBox

While we both agree on somethings, I'd have to disagree with you on Rani. Rani is a great actress. I never really appreciated her until all the oldies went on hiatus and we were left with the likes of Katrina, Deepika (although she is improving), Sonam.

As for looking average, that really is a matter of opinion. Both Rani and Vidya have a classical beauty to them. I'd rate Rani's face better than Katrina's or Kareenaas. We go gaga over Katrina because of her hot body and light-skinned face and Kareena because of her paleness. I don't wanna sound like I'm anti white (I think Amy Jackson and that lady from Love Aaj Kaal to be beautiful while I find Freida Pinto average-looking) Rani is short so when she gains weight she doesn't look good. Both Vidya and Rani are being like most Indian women and not exercising. While it may be okay for the average women to do that, as actresses they should work on that if they want to be popular. Long story short, I think they are both very pretty (excuse me for all that rambling)

Rani could have been the complete package had she taken a better route with her career. She should have kept her body hot-looking and also acted in better films. She would have been #1 actress at the moment had she put more focus on her work. But she's too busy playing ghar with her boyfriend and "ghost-directing" his movies.