I don't think there is anything wrong, what is it about "Muslims" that turn you on?, and I assume you mean people from specific regions, in which case the non-Muslims from those areas should be just as appealing?
What turns me on the most is the taboo factor. I find a thrill in corruption and breaking convention. If I can break a resolve, alter a moral or open up experiences, it turns me on. I'll stop there before I delve into TMI. 😆
Logically, it should include Orthodox Jews, Orthodox Catholics, Conservative Hindus...to a certain extent it does...but for reasons I'm unaware of Islam thrills me the most. And I don't mean to be offensive to any religion by that.
21