ACTRESSES who survived without the Khans!!! - Page 17

Created

Last reply

Replies

218

Views

18.2k

Users

43

Likes

486

Frequent Posters

532095 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
Maddy, of course I will do what you want! 😛 A topic on male actors will be coming, you be prepared for another tamasha! 🤣
joyce_k thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ladygaga

Well she hasn't gotten any rave reviews.. in author backed roles like Raavan.. she isn't versatile enough to do masala.. she was ripped apart in Action replay.. and Robot...till this date.. a lot of people just call her a pretty face.. she hasn't been able to rise above that designation.. as far as i can perceive things.. even actors like Tushar kapoor have some good performances.. where critics have loved him.. ofcourse if you hang around in the instustry for such a long time.. you are bound to have a few good performances... but there is a thing called consistency also.. like how an actor performs.. in basic.. masala roles like Action replay after being in the industry since forever..

Most of the time when I watch her movies I feel she is not atall in character like she never comes out this thought "I am the aishwarya rai"
_rose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ladygaga

I have always wondered this and i am not being sarcastic.. as to why there is always this struggle.. almost even after years to prove that ash can act... so many actresses from her time.. there is priety.. rani.. karishma.. there are others.. like look at now there is priyanka.. kareena.. everyone has had a time.. where people thought that following actresses couldn't act.. but after a movie like JWM for Kareena.. this criticism usually died down for most of the actresses.. at the end.. we don't see many debates to prove that kajol can act... or preity can act.... or kareena can act or not.. but even after spending years in the industry.. and working with some of the best directors.. there is this struggle that is still there to prove that ash can act.. a large section of audience.. and reviewers still questions ash's basic acting skills.. yes there are opinions here and there which rate some of the actresses that i have mentioned as overrated too.. but those opinions are far and few.. at large most of the actresses have been widely accepted.. but with ash.. after so many films.. and everything.. we are sometimes still stuck to prove that she has basic acting skills..

Lol but you don't like Aish.. you have said it many times 😆 ... so off course you going to say.. aish sucks at acting. and no one accept her... how do you know she isn't accepted in acting...?? It is your opinion only? And I don't agree with your opinion?
Edited by sapna27 - 14 years ago
ladygaga thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: sapna27

Lol but you don't like Aish.. you have said it many times 😆 ... so off course you going to say.. aish sucks at acting. and no one accept her... how do you know she isn't accepted in acting...?? It is your opinion only? And I don't agree with your opinion?

Here's another guy who thinks like me....
😆
Well my opinion is backed by her being called wooden.. plastic by national international critics.. her not being able to rise above her just a pretty face tag... and her recent flops.. and unimpressive reviews.. that she has gotten.....
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ladygaga

Well she hasn't gotten any rave reviews.. in author backed roles like Raavan.. she isn't versatile enough to do masala.. she was ripped apart in Action replay.. and Robot...till this date.. a lot of people just call her a pretty face.. she hasn't been able to rise above that designation.. as far as i can perceive things.. even actors like Tushar kapoor have some good performances.. where critics have loved him.. ofcourse if you hang around in the instustry for such a long time.. you are bound to have a few good performances... but there is a thing called consistency also.. like how an actor performs.. in basic.. masala roles like Action replay after being in the industry since forever..

Hey actually she has gotten rave reviews for Raincoat, Chokher Bali, Devdas, Hum Dil, JA, Guzaarish, and even for Provoked, and ppl loved her in HDAPH....yeah I agree she was torn apart in AR and Ravaan (by some)...but that doesn't mean she lacks BASIC acting skills! She is versatile b/c she tried out and has done a variety of roles...she hasn't ALWAYS succeeded, but she also hasn't always FAILED!
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ladygaga

Here's another guy who thinks like me....
😆
Well my opinion is backed by her being called wooden.. plastic by national international critics.. her not being able to rise above her just a pretty face tag... and her recent flops.. and unimpressive reviews.. that she has gotten.....


Russell Peters?! REALLY?!😆

He's NOT an "national international critic"....he's a comedian that in IMO isn't even that funny! This doesn't really BACK your opinion!!!

A lot of INTERNATIONAL critics have praised her for Devdas, Provoked, Guru and recently Ravaan....and at the Venice Film Festival after the film was screened it was given a standing ovation!

Matthew McConaughey loved her in Devdas, Nicole Kidman praised her in Bride and Prejudice, and Roger Ebert raved about her performance in Guru and BP!
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: sapna27

Lol but you don't like Aish.. you have said it many times 😆 ... so off course you going to say.. aish sucks at acting. and no one accept her... how do you know she isn't accepted in acting...?? It is your opinion only? And I don't agree with your opinion?


I agree this the above!

@ladygaga: Also, Kareena faced a lot of heat for her role in KI and so did PC in the recent SKM...no one really questions Aishu's ability to act....b/c she's proven with so many films that she CAN! Now clearly you and I are both bias for different reasons (obviously)...you find she can't act and I think she can! You can't claim that only few ppl think she can act and the majority think she can't just b/c she is someone who don't like.

I don't know if you actually read all of her reviews, but I do and even for Guzaarish she and Hrithik were raved by more than the MAJORITY for their acting talents!
ladygaga thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
DID I say that RP is a national or international critic.. i just said here is someone who agrees with me... and in that link itself that i posted.. it says how a prominent UK critic ripped her apart in Mistress of spices.. and said that she has a pretty face but cannot act.. a lot of critics have said that.. and they say that... agian.. like i said before.. there is always this debate going on about her acting.. why not about Preity.. karishma.. priyanka.. kareena.. no one doubts their basic acting skills.. why just ash?? in this thread itself.. there are others besides me.. arguing about and doubting her basic acting skills..
qwww thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
All I have to say is this
Opinions are like armpits…..yours stink and mine smell like morning meadows…or sport
😆 Even if someone here claims Aishwarya is from Venus - we can find plently of people arguing in favor and against the statement. Acting is subjective just because someone doesnt like a star's acting it doesnt mean that is the absolute truth. Its just an opinion and you already know what I think about opinions😛😆
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ladygaga

DID I say that RP is a national or international critic.. i just said here is someone who agrees with me... and in that link itself that i posted.. it says how a prominent UK critic ripped her apart in Mistress of spices.. and said that she has a pretty face but cannot act.. a lot of critics have said that.. and they say that... agian.. like i said before.. there is always this debate going on about her acting.. why not about Preity.. karishma.. priyanka.. kareena.. no one doubts their basic acting skills.. why just ash?? in this thread itself.. there are others besides me.. arguing about and doubting her basic acting skills..


probably b/c no matter how stunning her performance...some ppl never look past her beauty OR if you dislike than she can give a chilling performance like in Raincoat, but it doesn't matter!
And Kareena and PC like I said have also been critiqued in some of their most recent films too! And no one questions their basic acting b/c even ppl who dislike them aren't as harsh as Aishu's critics...check out some of the criticism on PV and YT!

For the RP as critic...you wrote that after the link so I was assuming you meant him....my mistake!

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: woodland

4 months ago

Why Kangana will never work with the Khans

“I refused Khan-led films,” Kangana stated boldly in a candid conversation on Raj Shamani’s podcast. “All Khans are very nice to me, they are...

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Briaahna

5 months ago

Ibrahim Khans next torture

Brace urself A a a b https://x.com/sidkannan/status/1910238216650965450?s=46 t=vevCm3I0SGjUvmq-Bjkadg

https://x.com/sidkannan/status/1910238216650965450?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: wat_up

6 months ago

American vibing to Salman Khans song

https://zeenews.india.com/viral/american-man-vibes-of-salman-khans-teri-chunariyaaa-song-while-driving-video-goes-viral-2871240.html/amp

https://zeenews.india.com/viral/american-man-vibes-of-salman-khans-teri-chunariyaaa-song-while-driving-video-goes-viral-2871240.html/amp
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Amira21

23 days ago

Any outsider actresses that made big without Godfather?

Most of the outsiders that made big usually had Godfathers or they came from beauty pageant. Like Juhi, Ash and PC came from beauty pageant and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".