My Name Is Khan looses to 3 Idiots

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Deepak Tamang

@SolidSnake

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#21

So which SRK and Aamir movies are releasing in 2010?

Quote

anna

@anna143

Sparkler

Posted: 15 years ago

#22

MNIK and 3 idiots cannot even be compared to each other. Nevertheless MNIK is a HIT and so is 3 Idiots. I hate people who are tryna make it seem like a competition both movies made good money and were much appreaciated and thats the end of it.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sam

@mz.gigglez

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#23

Both of the movies did great in fact they did extremely good at the B.O . But if one is to compare 3 Idiots success to MNIK .. then the only reason according to "me" MNIK is behind is because of the touchy subject. Movies on terrorism and 9/11 have been beaten to death and no one wants to watch movies on similar topic again and again . Considering that MNIK is done well for itself . I loved both the movies equally and would never put one down to make the other look good.

Quote

sheela

@Aamnakideewani

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: anna143
MNIK and 3 idiots cannot even be compared to each other. Nevertheless MNIK is a HIT and so is 3 Idiots. I hate people who are tryna make it seem like a competition both movies made good money and were much appreaciated and thats the end of it.

haiiiiiiiiii yeh tou sara prb hai na these two ppl are like edges of line unko compare kia he jayega😕

Quote

395575

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: xetaxeta
What I find most amusing is when you find fans on here say, "3I was very commercial with songs and dance but MNIK was a serious movie and people don't like serious movies. So MNIK did not do so well " and then there are Kaminey fangirls (I know it so dont play coy) who are hell bent on proving 3I is a trash just to elevate kaminey. Personally, I dont see any remote connection between the genres that these two movies belong, but kaminey fangirls are an epidemic of their own. Anyway, Well here is the newsflash, both 3I and MNIK are as commercial as lemon pie, so there's no need to put down one to raise the other. Its not like SRK was being Nandita Das in this flick or KJO satyajit ray. They all want money (rightfully so) and will go to any extent to publicize and hype their flicks. The whole crediting fiasco with Aamir/3I and frisking incident with SRK/MNIK are prime examples.

It does not matter which film did well, the point is both made huge profits and SRK/Aamir are probably shaking hands in happiness behind media's back as we speak. Frenemies that they are, they make ullu out of media and fans and get away with it, love them for that although both come across as childish at times.

i agree with u xetaxeta becoz if i can remember..there was a topic in which it was a direct article...'Shahrukh beat aamir khan' i think we must all remember it...and i am sure tht these were the same members who said 'yes srk did beat aamir and having fun around...and when now the actual figures are out now they say the movies can't be compared.🤪🤪...now what should i call this, being a crybaby or immaturity at its best..😆

as far my thing goes i will stuck to my words..that i dont compare but really laugh at those people who do compare and when their assumption falls flat..they say it cant be compared HILLARIOUS by god😆

Edited by tweety_lovely - 15 years ago

Quote

melancholic

@melancholic

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#26

this is nt comparison based on genre of movies, i believe.. this is comparison based on which is better grosser in market..:) so why cant it b compared in terms of making profits?