Rajiv Vijayakar
December 12, 2008
Are marriages – or in this case, matches – truly made in heaven by God? Can a seemingly mismatched pair be actually made for each other even though it seems completely incongruous at first look? And finally, can true one-sided love overcome all odds and win over the reluctant objet d'amor?
Yash Raj Films' Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi attempts to answer these questions – in the affirmative, that is – by narrating a tale that has just two protagonists and a third main character. The film comes at a crucial stage in the YRF fortunes – with its abysmal track-record for over two years now with just one super-hit, Chak De! India, and the average Bachna Ae Haseeno among multiple flops. Moreover the SRK-YRF record (Darr, Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge, Dil To Pagal Hai, Mohabbatein, Veer-Zaraa and Chak De! Indiaincluding even Saathiya in a cameo) has been unblemished, and its three years since King Khan has had an individual flop.
So will it work at the all-important box-office? Methinks it will, though not on a super-hit scale, and it will be the non-multiplex audience that might accept it more. Yes, there are danger areas that might offend even the conservatives, especially in Punjab, the region that is the story's base, and North India, where they will not take kindly to a married woman's physical proximity to a stranger after marriage even if the relationship is platonic from her side. The script is slow in parts of the first half and there is a lot of flawed confusion in the second half that was completely avoidable: like the hero talking about leaving the heroine when the lady wants to run away with the hero himself!
But to understand this conundrum, you have to know the storyline. Surinder Sahni (Shah Rukh Khan), in his early '40s, we presume, is your average upper-middle-class employee of the local electricity board in Amritsar. He is attending the wedding of his teacher's daughter Taani (Anushka Sharma) and having never been in love, falls for her at first sight.
But when things take a tragic turn, the dying teacher actually wants his favourite one-time student Surinder to marry Taani so that she will not be left alone in the world. But after marriage, Taani, the bubbly girl full of fun and her love for dance, is now a changed person, withdrawn and incapable of rediscovering love for anyone. The understanding Surinder suppresses his love for her, and she remains a dutiful wife, but the couple lives in separate rooms.
Surinder's only wish is to see Taani happy. When Taani expresses a desire to join a dancing group, he agrees, and with the help of his best buddy, hairdresser Bobby (Vinay Pathak) metamorphoses into the cool dude Raj so that he can watch her dance and rehearse from close quarters. But destiny plays a part when he is sucked into the dancing group as Taani's partner. He even masters dancing skills so that they can win the competition. But the double life has to end somewhere, and as Raj makes Taani start loving him he begins to wonder what will happen to Surinder, for Taani in a weak moment confesses to Raj that she wants to run away with him!
The screenplay (Aditya Chopra) could have done with some crispness and the film should have been ideally shorter by a good 20 minutes. Aditya's dialogues are a strong point and along with his directorial nuances etch out an authentic image of modern yet traditional Punjab in a much more wholesome and genuine way than in the recent Oye Lucky! Lucky Oye!. Munnish Sappel's sets and production design deserve high marks and Ravi Chandran's mood cinematography helps. But the languid editing is a liability, and the film's biggest minus point are the mediocre songs and the clichd, irritating background score, though Jaideep Sahni writes a couple of decent lyrics.
But for all its flaws, Rab Ne… derives great strength from the two protagonists. Without Shah Rukh Khan, the film would have zero appeal and prospects, and SRK once again delivers with amazing conviction and intensity. As Surinder, he mixes his patent mannerisms with some brilliantly-etched details of a small-town simpleton. And SRK is helped in no small measure by one of the brightest star discoveries in recent times – debutant Anushka Sharma. All that we can say about this girl and her performance is that when you watch her it's like watching an actress who is ten films old. Move over, all you contenders for the best female newbie of the year. Rab Ne… may or may not make it, but Anushka Sharma will.
RAJSHRI.COM RATING: ****
Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi Movie Review
December 12, 2008 5:28:12 PM IST
By Martin D'Souza, Bollywood Trade News Network
It's very rare for another actor to steal the thunder right from under Shahrukh Khan's nose. Even though the script is the winner here, newcomer Anushka Sharma walks off with an applause-worthy performance. It's difficult to believe that this is her debut. RAB NE BANA DI JODI will be spoken more for the spunk in her performance than for SRK's dual role. Knowingly or unknowingly, SRK is supporting Anushka!
Right from the first frame, until the last, Anushka captures the screen and keeps her character alive with effortless ease. She portrays a gamut of emotions with the grace of a seasoned pro. Here is a natural beauty with an impish grin and an infectious screen presence. A crazy dancer, too. A star is born.
With her performance, she has thrown her hat in the ring for a plethora of awards. Best Actress, Best Debut, Fresh Face of the Year... This film too, will be a top contender for the Best Film Of The Year Award along with JODHA AKBAR, JAANE TU... and ROCK ON. Of course, GHAJNI is still to hit the cinemas.
For a newcomer, Anushka has handled well the pressures of standing up to one of the biggest stars in Bollywood. She matches SRK scene for scene. So powerful is her presence and performance, that SRK at most times, pales in the shadows. This, in no way means that SRK has under-performed. Keeping his character in mind, he has stayed 'within', playing perfectly to the script and the direction of Aditya Chopra. To his credit, it must be said that it's a brave decision to have played the character he played because the role of Anushka has turned out to be the central point on which the film rotates. And this would not have missed the sharp eyes of SRK at the post-production stage.
The movie plays within itself and the concept that some relationships we choose, while others are ordained by God. This is exactly the story of Surinder Sahni (SRK) and Tanni (Anushka). By a twist of fate, they are married off. While Surinder loves her deeply, Tanni cannot bring herself to love her husband and she also makes this fact clear to him. She marries Surinder because her father asks her to on his deathbed after suffering from a massive heart attack because her husband-to-be and the entire marriage party are killed in an accident.
He is a simpleton working in a government office while she is, or rather was, just the opposite. She expresses her desire to take part in a dance competition. Surinder encourages her and also hits upon an idea of going in for an image change (for fear of being recognised by her) to take a closer look at her during her dance rehearsals. What was meant to be a one-time makeover goes on until the end. So who wins in the end, Surinder, or Raj, the makeover persona?
This movie is loaded with the right dose of emotions, action, lighter moments and 'masala' scenes. In one song, SRK does an ode to Raj Kapoor, Dev Anand, Shammi Kapoor, Rajesh Khanna and Rishi Kapoor. He is accompanied by Kajol, Bipasha Basu, Lara Dutta, Preity Zinta and Rani Mukherjee. A clean take on the yesteryear stars, with fear of lawsuits. Remember Manoj Kumar and OSO?
On the flip side, I fail to understand why every film from the Yash Raj banner needs to have references from their past hits... or flops.
Anushka, once again, take a bow. Aditya Chopra, you too. This one is an ordinary love story told in an extraordinary manner. In the current scenario where everyone's emotions have taken a beating, this film is sure to lift up your spirits.
Ratings : 4/5
http://www.glamsham.com/movies/reviews/12-rab-ne-bana-di-jodi-movie-review-120807.asp
95