Hina played tremendously well in terms of tasks..she has so many good qualities..but like you said her negativity towards others, self-obsession and narcissistic behavior was really off putting to me. She lacked poise in my opinion. If she had overcome those negative points early on in the game, she could have easily won and that too would have been a deserved win. There are some videos floating on twitter about her...her behavior is mentally disturbing to watch. It must have given shock to the trp audience who have seen and adored her in the role she played in her show (and she definitely was not the sole reason for the success of that show).
This is why if I had to choose between Shilpa and Hina, I would have picked Shilpa. She was put under a really difficult situation in the show many times but she handled them too well. Yes, she wasn't good in tasks, but I feel her contribution towards the tasks wasn't absolutely zero in the entire season (may be she didn't participate in the museum task but overall season it wasn't like she never participated). Hina didn't take advantage of Shilpa's negative points wisely and instead went overboard which did not sit well. On the other hand, Shilpa played very smartly. That's why all the mistakes she made especially towards end of the show didn't cost her the trophy.
Honestly, Vikas was actually the best played amongst all. Yes, he was disrespectful at times. He played smartly, respectfully and maintained his dignity overall. I do think celebrity status of Hina and Shilpa helped them be in top 2. Otherwise, Vikas was quite deserving. But I knew he won't win. I am happy for Shilpa though. I hope this helps her get her career back on track. She is very talented.
Regarding what happened between Vikas and Shilpa, I feel both parties were at fault. Vikas has admitted a couple of time in the show itself that he did not let her work. But I can also see Shilpa being impatient about money and all. I hope the two can resolve their issues and work together.
Edited by monsoonlove - 7 years ago