Holding Collar is more violent then Three pushes?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#41

@Anu thanks for keeping ur pov in unbiased manner .. even though i dont agree to the fullest ..i respect it 😊

Quote

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: sscomp32
Strictly my opinion:
Tanisha and Kushal both were warned first time and BB clearly told any more offence and they will be evicted. Today it was kushal's 2nd offense. First was jumping the House and now physical violence. It maybe tough to beleive but Tanisha had only 1 offence till now and hasn't done any thing after the warning. So i feel it was justified. 😊

P.S. I am not going into the depths of how are the pushes and "Collar holding" and whatever. I am just quantitatively analyzing the situation.

No worries ..opinion differs 👍🏼.. members should co operate with each other's pov without insulting each other on forum ! If one dont agree just agree to disagree..demeaning others view just because their opinion is different is not a healthy way of discussion ! 😊 I respect ur point !

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: -Nightingale-
Kushal never invited Tanisha for physical violence..but Andy was definitely doing it ...he provoked Kushal to say words n do what he can do..

Andy said a lot of things and his ill mannered behavior was not even shown ! 😛 That says alot ..i dont support violence and rules should be same for all ..kushal is out ..good ..but she should have been out too !

Quote

0o0o0o0o0o

@0o0o0o0o0o

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#44

Its the intention ---

Tanisha was at fault ofcrs but it can be justified to some extent as a reaction to stop Kushal from further getting personal with her in that task --@ And Kushal hasn't apologized for it because he thinks he getting personal can be justified.

So with his own logic, Andy getting personal in a task can be justified too and kushal should accept it 🤔

Kushal already climbed the BB house wall and crossed boundary, which a clear violation of rule. And add to that, this incident where he ran towards Andy with intention to harm him. And he kept on abusing him even after than and said he will slap him ---so intention is violence here. ---@

At the end of the day, the matter is between Gauhar and Andy. They both were close friends at one point so they can always sort their own issues by discussing. Why Kushal ? ---When BB already stopped Andy earlier, then why ? --

Edited by --GODFATHER-- - 11 years ago

Quote

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#45

@godfather Okay i believe tanisha's first push was not intentional and in anger whatever what about the second bump..that was not unintentional right ? If it was ..what she was trying to do by bumping herself into him ! Her intentions were right there ? i seriously dont think so !

Coming to kushal ..keeping aside the things andy said to him or gauhar .. of course he was wrong and he should be evicted and BB have always done that in previous seasons.. but rules should be same for all !

Quote

0o0o0o0o0o

@0o0o0o0o0o

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: ..SalmanGirl..
@godfather Okay i believe tanisha's first push was not intentional and in anger whatever what about the second bump..that was not unintentional right ? If it was ..what she was trying to do by bumping herself into him ! Her intentions were right there ? i seriously dont think so !

Coming to kushal ..keeping aside the things andy said to him or gauhar .. of course he was wrong and he should be evicted and BB have always done that in previous seasons.. but rules should be same for all !

Agreed ---

Tanisha pushed him -- her fault. People have been evicted over that, but she was let go with a warning.

Kushal climbed the wall and crossed the house boundaries in spite BB asking him to stop, clear violation of rule. I think Raja chaurhari was evicted for that. Kushal was let go just with a warning.

So its 1 -1

And what does kushal do now ? -- He charges towards Andy and repeatedly says he will beat him -/ why? - Gauhar is more than capable of handling her matters. --- If he was so sensitive to women's dignity and respect , he himself wouldn't be doing all that to Tanisha -- 🤔

Quote

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#47

@godfather Tanisha pushed him -- her fault. People have been evicted over that, but she was let go with a warning.

Kushal climbed the wall and crossed the house boundaries in spite BB asking him to stop, clear violation of rule. I think Raja chaurhari was evicted for that. Kushal was let go just with a warning.

You have a point 👍🏼 But when raja climbed the wall .. violence din took place .. when pooja pushed sid ..nobody climbed the wall.. Both the incidents happened at different time in different situations ..Hisab se tanisha and kushal should have been evicted that day but they could not have evicted kushal because tanisha was involved in the matter..and evicting kushal that day would have been blatant bias !

Quote

shalinii173

@shalinii173

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: ..SalmanGirl..
Let me tell you they evicted him for hinsa ..not for violating other rules ! And i obviously will bring her in this scenario !😳

Both violated the rules. Both expressed there anger in different way. That's it. BB warned both and Tanisha even apologized for her behavior and didnt violate any rules after that whereas Kushal 😕

U keep bringing her in this scenario for no reason to justify ur favorite. All the best 😛

Quote

Shelly

@Venus.X

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#49

@SG - Isn't it fab how convenient everything is for BB?? 😒

Problem 1: People cribbing that the show is boring 🤔

Solution 1: Come up with tasks that instigate fights

Problem 2: Solution 1, the task (which required placing a HM in a box and throwing stuff at her through holes), resulted in TANISHA assaulting another HM and crap! we didn't make proper rules of what to and what not to throw in the boxes 😒

Solution 2: SK to attack the other HM in the Saturday episode for doing the task and the words (not gaalis) said by that HM after Tanisha's attacks and label it as "standing up for women's right" 😡

Problem 3: SK is labeled as being unfair by the social community for the Solution 2 😲

Solution 3: Implement another task that is sure to cause arguments and fights and take the attention off of SK and the Saturday episode

Problem 4: A HM disrespects another female HM (NOT TANISHA..this is very important! 😉) during the task which was Solution 3 and this results in the female HMs boyfriend's attack 😳

Solution 4: (Yay! He was the same one who was the reason for Problem 3!) - forget "standing up for women's rights"...evict him!! 🥳

All too convenient for a reality show if you ask me 👎🏼

Let's consider what BB would have done if Andy flaunted Tanisha's underthings...😲 .. Can I hear someone saying "dekho to larki kahaan se aaii he.." 😡

Quote

Yuvika

@Yuvika_15

Moderator

+ 9

Posted: 11 years ago

#50

Ok i'm just going to quote a message from another member in another topic which I think summarises really well why tanisha's push and kushal's attack at andy can't be compared!

Quoted by sangramsingh: I don't know how old you are but there is a thing known as "INTENTION". It is even used in courts and unless police can prove intent, the nature of the crime changes.

Well, Kushal was dumping junk, cigarette ashes onto Tanish, which itself can be classified as violence arguably. Tanisha couldn't take it, lost it for a moment, came out and pushed him. Her intent was to stop him and make him realise what he was doing and NOT HURT him.

Kushal on the other hand, went unprovoked, abusing, towards Andy proclaiming that he would hurt him. He straightaway went for his neck and stopped by others. After that, MULTIPLE TIMES, he said that he would beat him. He even said he would have broken his neck. This is "threatening". Even after Bigg Boss asked him to leave, he said he'll slap Andy before going.

The two scenarios are COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. What Kushal did was violence in all respects. He was repeatedly threatening to hurt Andy. It is totally fair to ask him to leave for the safety of Andy. Tanisha, on the other hand, was NEVER a threat to Kushal's safety.

Eventhough, what I guess is that they'll send him to the Caravan. So he'll have that awkward moment with Candy. And then they'll send Andy to the Caravan too, for an even more awkward situation. Remember, nowhere is being said that Kushal has been "evicted". Every report says either "Kushal asked to leaave" or "Kushal dismissed from the house".

Edited by Yuvika_15 - 11 years ago

Quote

1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 ... 11

Holding Collar is more violent then Three pushes? - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics