Mandy played the Smartest to make Rish win the Task - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.2k

Users

17

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

Ctrl-Alt-Del thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Yes, it was Gizel who recognized Prince as murderer prior to anyone else and then she told this to Rish. And I'm not giving credit of all the plotting to Mandy, perhaps it was all Rish's mind and Mandy just played her part. Remember last night Rish & Mandy were all alone in the bedroom so probably they planned all this then. Rish had to make this plan with Mandy because she was the only one who could actually do something for him as she was the only aam aadmi alive from their group, Gizel was already murdered.

Edited by Ctrl-Alt-Del - 9 years ago
vitriolic thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
much as I'm beginning to like mandy, I think we are giving more credit to her than she deserves, cos until the end she too believed it was rishabh who was the killer. I just watched the clip again to see how the sequence of events played out.
rishabh played brilliantly, gizelle is another smart cookie, and given the tight parameters of the task, I would say even prince did a good job.
The rest can go back to the bathroom to hide themselves in shame.
Edited by vitriolic - 9 years ago
Rithu0203 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: vitriolic

much as I'm beginning to like mandy, I think we are giving more credit to her than she deserves, cos until the end she too believed it was rishabh who was the killer. I just watched the clip again to see how the sequence of events played out.
rishabh played brilliantly, gizelle is another smart cookie, and given the tight parameters of the task, I would say even prince did a good job.
The rest can go back to the bathroom to hide themselves in shame.


ya, but the entire HMs were so confused that the murder will happen something due to physical touch, so only they were hiding themselves in rest room.

But, Gizele, Mandana and Rish were the only ones to think that the murder can happen without being physical touch but due to getting the reactions from common people also. Prince already murderer he know it.

So, atleast Gizele,Mandana and Rish stands different from other HMs.

purva thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: ankusanu

Mandy devi ki jai...
She us undoubtedly d smartest..
Dats why she was killed


No no.. she wanted to get killed so that her best friend Rishabh could solve her murder and win the task😉.. sacrifice and all you know 😉😆😆
zayarock thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Gizelle gave Rishabh the hint that Prince is the killer...and Rishabh was also sure...but later he got confused between Nora nd Prince...thats wen Mandy cleared his confusion and said that its Prince for sure( uncensored video)
So yes Rish,Mandy n Giz worked as a team...

BUT Mandy herself got confused in the end coz of everyones arguments...
But she supported/helped Rishabh till the end
snehaHCAPK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
nice try tm.
mandana who was not even ready to share her bed initially.
mandana who never cooks for ppl who she doesn't like.
mandana who refused to share a pkt of chips bcoz she won d luxury budget has become so selfless for rishab.
i m telling u it only bcoz of d fear of giselle that she is being nice to rish n gizu.
i know u won't agree bt despite knowing that prince was murderer she got murdered. n in d end she ad a doubt on rishab.
no smart player could that.
in fact along wid priya she was one of the dumbest person in d task. d murderer has confessed it to her n still she was doubting others.
bt nice theory. i wish mandana ke paas victim card play karne ke alava bi kuch aur karne ka dimaag hota.
MsFoodyTwoShoes thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
🤣I wish mandana was that smart ..she got killed even when murderer himself told her ..oh may be that was the part of her super secret rishabh plan
desisrule thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Ctrl-Alt-Del

Mandy played this task for sake of Rish. She did each and everything she could do to make Rish win the task. She never suspected Rish as murderer and knew with 100% surety that the murderer is none other than Prince. She knew that she's an ordinary person in this task so ultimately she would be murdered as she's not the type who would hide in the toilet to not get murdered (nominated). So she thought that instead of trying to save her own self from nominations it would be wise to make Rish win the task so that he may get some power or captaincy.

Now here are few points that will make it crystal clear that how she played:

* First of all we all need to understand that detective's job was not to stop the murder but to identify the murderer once the murders have been committed. And for this purpose it was mandatory that few murders must be committed.

* In the morning we saw Rish, Mandy and Gizel laughing and ridiculing Priya and housemates at the fact that they all are thinking that Rish, a detective, is a murderer.

* Later we saw Prince telling Mandy openly that he is a murderer, he has murdered Gizel, tried to murder Mandy but unsuccessful and that BB has gave him number of ways to do the murder.

* In the next scene we see BB calling Prince, and he is talking to BB in front of Mandy and then saying to her that he urgently needs to go to wash room, will come back in a minute.

* When he came out, he came towards Mandy and started doing that food throwing act. Mandana played along and showed reaction, called Rish and later go to wash room as well as maybe BB requires her to show reaction in front of housemates for declaring her murder. She also tried to convince them to come outside.

* Later we saw Mandy, Rish and Prince in bedroom when BB announced her murder. If you see that scene minutely then Mandy's lips were synching with BB while taking her name, as she was waiting for BB to announce it.

* Then she went to washroom again and asked Priya to put her in coffin. Rish was also a detective and her friend too so if something was not fishy then she should have asked Rish to do that but she asked this from Priya.

* Plus she also told Priya that Prince is a murderer. In Policy task it was crystal clear that Mandy and Priya dislike each other a lot so it was a red light for Priya that why would Mandy suddenly started having that much concern about her. Mandy's friend is Rish and as out of two detectives, only one would win then if Mandy really knows who the murderer is then she would tell this to Rish and not Priya. So in this way Mandy tried to make Priya belief that Prince is not a murderer.

* While court room, Mandy told the juror in detail that the moment her tears fall, she was declared murdered which shows that she understood fully that how her murder was committed but after some second she took the name of Rish as a murderer while voting process to strengthened the belief of Priya b so that she may not change her statement, Mandy just wanted Priya to stick to her statement that Rish is a murderer.

* And once the verdict is declared that Rish won the task, that hi5, a sign that mission has been successfully completed.



Hats off to your imagination !!!👏👏

krittika23 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Haha
I don't think your theory is entirely true.. But would love to believe it :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".