Worst performer of the lagaan task-my opinion

Page

Next Last

MistyDawn

@MistyDawn

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

To start off, I think lagaan task was heavily in favor of the zamindars, so it would have been hard for the sevaks to win in any case.. Kishwar was desperate to win this task at any cost because she wanted to be free of the ''bandhan'' with Aman so in no way could she let the sevaks earn more money than them.

Even then, the sevaks did pretty decent. BB realized that sevaks will not resort to anything drastic unless they are prompted to do so. Clever on part of BB to choose Keith and Mandana to divulge the option of ''bending rules'' I guess BB knew than Mandana will step up and take charge if they decide to steal..

When Keith and Mandana announced this to the team, I maybe wrong, but I think Prince was the one who suggested to steal, and Keith too was giving Gautam Gulati's example from last season.. So if the idea if stealing to win the game came in their minds, how is Mandana the only one to have understood the game according to Salman?? Not sure.. But yes she did volunteer to steal and was the most convinced about it.. Suyash backed out coz of obvious reasons, Prince and Keith were in two minds.. because of the whole morality angle Suyash was trying to show them.. Its not like no one knew they could win by stealing or that stealing was allowed.

Keith and Mandana went ahead and stole the coins and they could have won.. My point is why did Keith have to go on a guilt trip and then decide to return the coins? If he is so smart and mature, then why should he get influenced by Suyash's lectures? He could have simply said that you din't steal so you can relax! You are not losing your morality or getting divorce from your gf. So chill.. it's on me!

To that extent I can understand Mandana's frustration when she threw away her mike and belt..and I am saying this despite the fact that I don't like Mandana's attitude at all... But if Keith had held his ground, they could have won..

So if it comes to who I think is the reason the sevak team lost, it would be Keith and since Mandana was paired with him , she got the brunt..

Hope from now on, housemates don't play moral science when they are doing tasks.. Win by hook or crook, as long as you are not physically or verbally assaulting anyone.. that's it..

Edited by MistyDawn - 9 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

MistyDawn

@MistyDawn

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Pretty1
Totally agree with u.. it was prince who said about stealing first...
ofcourse Mandana got praised for understanding task because she is Salman's fav.

if these ppl Mandana Keith and Rochelle r soo smart and intelligent why did get influenced by Suyaash

Exactly! If we talk of performance, I will Rimi is worst coz she doesnt take interest in any task. But if you ask me to name one person coz of who they lost , it would be Keith.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

FeminEra

@FeminEra

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

actually suyyash brainwashed his team mates

it was not only keith it was team's decision to return money to zamindaar's

so u can't blame keith for losing it

keith's mistake was he didn't discussed the chori idea with whole team

mandy broke house rules

thats y they were voted worst jodi by their team

but now they realized how suyyash tricked them to make kishwer win

Quote

MistyDawn

@MistyDawn

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: witchybitchy
actually suyyash brainwashed his team mates
it was not only keith it was team's decision to return money to zamindaar's
so u can't blame keith for losing it

keith's mistake was he didn't discussed the chori idea with whole team
mandy broke house rules
thats y they were voted worst jodi by their team

but now they realized how suyyash tricked them to make kishwer win

I don't think Suyash has brains to trick anyone.. He was only trying to save his ass so that if Kishwar loses then he can say Oh baby! I told them not to steal..

Keith however is perceived smarter and way maturer... You would expect him to see through Suyash's motive behind all that morality drama.. and to be fair to him he did say that they can execute their plan of stealing, but he is not going to be part of it.. again goes to show how much scared he is of his GF LOL

N what team did they have anyway? The girls had physically given up... Prince was kinda on both sides.. he wanted to win and at the same time, had to stick with his buddy... Rochelle and Mandana were supporting Keith.. so Keith could go ahead and finish the task if he had been firm on his stand.. specially when he was the one who heard BB say that they can win at any cost..which Mandana understood..

Edited by MistyDawn - 9 years ago

Quote

FeminEra

@FeminEra

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: MistyDawn

I don't think Suyash has brains to trick anyone.. He was only trying to save his ass so that if Kishwar loses then he can say Oh baby! I told them not to steal..

Keith however is perceived smarter and way maturer... You would expect him to see through Suyash's motive behind all that morality drama.. and to be fair to him he did say that they can execute their plan of stealing, but he is not going to be part of it.. again goes to show how much scared he is of his GF LOL

N what team did they have anyway? The girls had physically given up... Prince was kinda on both sides.. he wanted to win and at the same time, had to stick with his buddy... Rochelle and Mandana were supporting Keith.. so Keith could go ahead and finish the task if he had been firm on his stand.. specially when he was the one who heard BB say that they can win at any cost..which Mandana understood..

because his team mates r even dumber than suyyash thats y they agreed to return coins 😆

but keith is not assertive thats y he agreed to give coins along with his teammates only mandy was against it😕

Edited by witchybitchy - 9 years ago

Quote

cherrypansy

@cherrypansy

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

Almost all members of the workers group were not in favor of stealing...even when stealing was done...most of them were saying its bad...and ultimate was when Suyush told Keith...ask your conscious...from that point they lost the task as Keith forced Mandy to return the coins...

Quote

CoffeeCake

@CoffeeCake

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

You can't clap with one hand.

Keith and Mandy both were equally responsible. She talks non stop with her tooti photo hindi when not required but at that time she could have explained to keith. Throwing Mike was melodrama, they lost a task not some big battle.

All living in big boss house are fools. It was not hard to point out that suyash was preaching coz his gf was in opposite team. No one asked that where were your morals when you were shouting on Rimi to remove her hairs? Never thought how would a girl look without hairs? At that time task was important but now when you have an opportunity to win task there you are talking nonsense about morals.

Definitely they were not strong team and all understood the task but didn't want to do. Salman and her special treatment for Mandy won't understand this.

Edited by White-Rose - 9 years ago

Quote

MistyDawn

@MistyDawn

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: cherrypansy
Almost all members of the workers group were not in favor of stealing...even when stealing was done...most of them were saying its bad...and ultimate was when Suyush told Keith...ask your conscious...from that point they lost the task as Keith forced Mandy to return the coins...

Well that's what I am saying.. because Keith got influenced by people around him, specially Suyash and so he decided to give the coins back..Rochelle also at one point told Keith not to steal because it will create a bad impression of him..that must have weighed on his mind too...

Quote

MistyDawn

@MistyDawn

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: White-Rose
You can't clap with one hand.
Keith and Mandy both were equally responsible. She talks non stop with her tooti photo hindi when not required but at that time she could have explained to keith. Throwing Mike was melodrama, they lost a task not some big battle.

All living in big boss house are fools. It was not hard to point out that suyash was preaching coz his gf was in opposite team. No one asked that where were your morals when you were shouting on Rimi to remove her hairs? Never thought how would a girl look without hairs? At that time task was important but now when you have an opportunity to win task there you are talking nonsense about morals.

Definitely they were not strong team and all understood the taste but didn't want to do. Salman and her special treatment for Mandy won't understand this.

I agree.. and that's what I said that Mandana got unnecessary credit from Salman for being the only one who understood the task.. the idea of stealing was discussed by Keith and Prince..she also joined it and got pumped up with the idea.. Coz she knows very well how to get footage.. What Mandana did right was that she stuck to her stand whereas Keith got swayed by Suyash.. I never support Mandana for the tantrums she throws..throwing away mike and belt and all that.. but when she saw Keith was backing out last minute she again got a chance to do all that drama..

Quote

Suvarna

@Super Kool

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

^^ true...Keith got swayed...his team mates convinced him that they will look bad if they steal...in the house it's natural that there will be times when one will falter or will show a lapse in judgement...same happened with Keith...prince didn't agree because of his bonding with sukish...suyash batted for different team by confiding in kish...that's why he was pulled up the most...he was a bundle of contradictions and gave ammunition against himself...it wasn't that he was in two minds about stealing (confused about how his stealing will be perceived by the audience)..he just didn't want to do it because that would have made kish lose the task...error of judgement and deliberately mucking up a task are two different things...

I think, vikas and Keith should be more assertive...Mandy, ro and kish are all noise and no substance...they throw tantrum at the drop of the hat and push the other HMs in defensive mode...

Edited by Super Kool - 9 years ago

Quote

1 2

Worst performer of the lagaan task-my opinion

Related Topics

Explore Topics