Which joke on Tanna was more offensive - Page 4

Originally posted by: vitriolic

i dont buy this logic cos despite their arch enmity for the game, they do share conversation and jokes, so it is not like they despise one another and are not on talking terms. case in point, the dance they did for some task.
basically, she is sporting only when she is in mood for it, as she herself has hinted time and again.

Well you don't have to buy it. Not a problem at all. I wasn't trying to sell it to you. I was simply stating my opinion behind it.

Originally posted by: ChemistryMajor

Well you don't have to buy it. Not a problem at all. I wasn't trying to sell it to you. I was simply stating my opinion behind it.

"buy it" is a manner of speaking.. and not literal as in buying n selling! phew!
I thought we were having a civil discussion. you could have added to the discussion and suggested why - despite sharing jokes at other times, you believe kari was not expected to take that joke from gautam at that particular point.

why cant we have discussions without getting all personal and defensive on these forums?

Originally posted by: vitriolic

"buy it" is a manner of speaking.. and not literal as in buying n selling! phew!
I thought we were having a civil discussion. you could have added to the discussion and suggested why - despite sharing jokes at other times, you believe kari was not expected to take that joke from gautam at that particular point.

why cant we have discussions without getting all personal and defensive on these forums?

LOL Dude. OMG. Let me clarify. I did mean it in a manner of speaking as well when I said "sell". We are indeed having a civil discussion.

I was simply saying of course you don't have to agree with my opinion. I simply stated my way of looking at the situation and wasn't trying to convince you or anyone else to agree with me.

Please, I wasn't getting personal by any means. Just saying we see things differently and that is totally fine!

I did add my point of view to the discussion in my original post which you quoted. I didn't have anything else new to add to what I already said.

So rest assured, I wasn't stating anything defensive or personal. Just saying you're entitled to your POV and I am to mine.

Originally posted by: ChemistryMajor

I did add my point of view to the discussion in my original post which you quoted. I didn't have anything else new to add to what I already said.

no worries mate. i understand.

Dress 1... as it can be insulting to a girl... and means disrobing her an act of r@p...
Whereas the ghajar ka halwa was fine and as a joke...not as insulting as the dress...

and the intemtion also counts...
Dress-rude way
Halwa-joke way

Tanna is reaching a point in my BB watching experience where anything she reacts on now- Is irrelevant and unworthy of discussion.

Its simple as the fact the 'Her Highness' not not in a 'mood' for the joke and when the person who makes the joke is gautam, even if she was in mood she'd say the same thing i guess.
These days everything happens according to 'Her Highness's' mood.

Originally posted by: Yashikha_Diyana

Dress 1... as it can be insulting to a girl... and means disrobing her an act of r@p...
Whereas the ghajar ka halwa was fine and as a joke...not as insulting as the dress...

and the intemtion also counts...
Dress-rude way
Halwa-joke way

Disrobing? lol yeh wala accha hai - was she wearing a robe? Pulling things out of context is an art some people excel at when they are just on a hut to prove somone wrong for whtever reason.

This is the same as people saying shit about Tanna and Upen's relationship just because he said somethings and was possesive of her as a friend- Upen's commment "Ki aap game ke liye karo mai pyaar ke liye karra raha ho" "You are effecting me strongly" etc were taken out of context to show they were in LOVE. My point- Niether was the dirty view on Upen & Tanna true nor the Dirty disrobing view for Gautam's comments is.

Originally posted by: _Ann_

Its simple as the fact the 'Her Highness' not not in a 'mood' for the joke and when the person who makes the joke is gautam, even if she was in mood she'd say the same thing i guess.
These days everything happens according to 'Her Highness's' mood.

Tabhi toh iss aurath aur uske best friend Upen Patel ko industry mai kaam nahi milta- They are so moody and whinny. No social etiquette whatsoever.

Originally posted by: tanya.91

Dress cutting joke...that she made an issue out of Or gaajar (in pritam's pronunciation 'gHajar) halwa comments hi h she took sportingly ?

This is the best you could do?
Bringing out an incident that happened ages ago...!!

Come on Tanya... You are better than this.

Karishma wasn't even involved in Pritam's joke if i remember ...

and even if she was involved... Karishma's equation with Pritam is different and her equation with Gautam is different..

Gautam has no right to even joke with her,,,,
Are they good friends? was she even talking to him when he jumped in her conversation with Sana...?
Have you ever seen Karishma dangling around Gautam just for footage...

It would be better if people could just admit the fact that Karishma gave a terrific reply to him...!!!

Period