Was shefali really wrong? - Page 2

I did feel bad for Aarti, not gonna lie but this was the task, its not like Shefali broke any rules as such. Anyway the ones who go first to be tortured in the task are almost always painted as the heroes and then when they have to torture, all they are getting is 'revenge'.

No.. not at all..

Shefali is a reporter and this is her forte.. It was expected she would come up with personal comments.. She did her task the way it was expected.. Aarti infact looked cry baby rather than accepting it with a grace.. What's wrong even if she had broken/failed marriage..

i infact likethe way sid confronted her later..

Shefali was bang on. I agree with the majority here that she was doing her task. As a news reporter she has all the information about these celebs personal life. (Because they have this job to interfere into celeb's personal lives)

But Aarti's crying and all honesty was looking like bit of maniac. It was clearly visible that she was doing such thing to gather sympathy.

Shefali wasn’t wrong.

When you enter BB, you know your past will be dug up. And how else would Shefali get her to quit the game?

Did you prefer Shehnaaz’s crying to Shefali’s taanas?

The task was pretty impossible to begin with - no matter what was said, people aren’t going to get off the chair in reaction - they can react plenty on the chair itself.

As such, they could’ve tried different angles - shocking them off the chair by unexpected noise in the ear, etc. Probably wouldn’t have worked either, but the former certainly wasn’t going to work. So I disagree that Shefali did a good job in the task with her chosen strategy.

And it’s a pet peeve for me when people bring in outside lives and issues to hit below the belt - just something I don’t appreciate. Yeah it’s only been 2 days - tough, it’s not the first time BB has set such stupid expectations.

That said - I don’t think it was anything super nasty - we’ve seen nastier in just the last two seasons. So while I think Shefali’s chosen tactics were pretty cheap, I agree with Shukla too - Aarti handed a win to Shefali by crying on the chair, particularly given it was after the fact.

I don't think she was wrong. She was expected to say things which are absurd lies to force them to leave the chair.

I'm sure nobody expected shefali to sweet talk Arti out of her chair lol😆

Originally posted by: Oye_Chup_Kar

I said it on another thread too. Shefali was NOT wrong, nor being a vamp, neither crossed any line.

Shefali was just doing her task very well. The whole hearing task was lame, how can someone make them leave the chairs by just talking? -makes no sense.

As Sid Shukla said, there's no other way Shefali could've gotten them up from the chair by just talking. She had to go personal.. infact since Shefali was able to get a reaction outta fake nautankibaaz Arti, hence IMO she won! She wasn't being a vamp, but just doing her task very well.

yes I agree. Shefali might have gotten personal but she had to do the task. She wasn’t wrong. It’s not like shefali physically harmed her

It was sad for Aarti having to hear that