Was shefali really wrong?

Honestly , I don't like shefali at all since starting but it was task so how she was supposed to irritate them to get up? Did not it happen in last seasons too. I guess all are being very harsh on shefali. They had to catch a dukhti rag of contestants to attack and aarti just give her that one day before so using that was fair enough . Was aarti really married I don't know but there was nothing lyk that on Google the why was so hungama.its Bigg boss chaal to give such tasks.

This also forced me to think is bb really scripted , Shefali lovebird comment then aarti hungama on that and co incidently arti was not choosen by other medical staff for skin n mouth disease?? only shefali n arti were confronted in kaan disease.

Absolutely not wrong. Everything in the task is consensual. Anytime the patient feels uncomfortable, they are free to stop the other person and get up.

By continuing to sit on the chair, the patient is consenting to whatever is being done by the doctor. By not stopping Shefali, Aarti was consenting that she is ok with whatever Shefali was saying being aired.

Crying, whining etc about doctors (or "doers" in similar tasks) are just part of game to gain sympathy.

The limits of task are decided by the patient. They are at absolute freedom to get up. The doctor's task is to make them uncomfortable to the extent that they get up. If they are not getting up, they are conveying hat they are ok with it.

I said it on another thread too. Shefali was NOT wrong, nor being a vamp, neither crossed any line.

Shefali was just doing her task very well. The whole hearing task was lame, how can someone make them leave the chairs by just talking? -makes no sense.

As Sid Shukla said, there's no other way Shefali could've gotten them up from the chair by just talking. She had to go personal.. infact since Shefali was able to get a reaction outta fake nautankibaaz Arti, hence IMO she won! She wasn't being a vamp, but just doing her task very well.

I think calling rashmi fat and all was little wrong and bringing shaadi tuti and all...if shefali would have just continued with siddharth wala love angle to bhi thik hota as aarti herself wasn't letting it go. Ghar wale issue use krne chaheye thay usse .

Originally posted by: kirti31096

I think calling rashmi fat and all was little wrong and bringing shaadi tuti and all...if shefali would have just continued with siddharth wala love angle to bhi thik hota as aarti herself wasn't letting it go. Ghar wale issue use krne chaheye thay usse .

That Sid love angle issue was discussed to death already.. how can Shefali get a reaction from it? Other than going personal, there's NO WAY that she could've gotten even 1% reaction outta her. IMO Shefali did her task very well.

Originally posted by: Oye_Chup_Kar

That Sid love angle issue was discussed to death already.. how can Shefali get a reaction from it? Other than going personal, there's NO WAY that she could've gotten even 1% reaction outta her. IMO Shefali did her task very well.

Bagga ji did superb.

Anyway it was planned by bring current and ex together in a such verbal task with shefali to ignite this issue and create drama in future😉

What could have shefalli done they have been there only for 2 days , so they don't have any content controversy to use from the house, so they can only use some personal things with aarti they tried love thing which is hyped by Aarti herself and with rashmi calling her fat etc.

What else she could have use, call them they can't make round rotis

i believe she was doing her task...its a task so its over and she did it well

Shefali was doing her task. She was not wrong. Infact it was more challenging for shefali and shenaz to make the other two get up from their chair just by saying some words in thier ears. It was a hard task for them and they did it correctly especially shefali.

Nah, she didn't do her task well as none of the girls stood up. Shefali only did one thing right, hurt other people's feeling and saved herself from possible nomination. 👍🏼