Rachana Parulkar approached for Maharana Pratap -TOI SeeModnote pg 19 - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

192

Views

19.2k

Users

64

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

_Poulomi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

Alright thats it! M appalled now! enough is enough! Rachna hasnt even entered the show and her whole fandom has descended here asking us to like her, give her a chance and what not...whether they have watched roshni's ajab or not, whether they have watched MP or not...

and this boy - Faisal Khan - who has been playing the role of Young Maharana Pratap has been working hard day and night for more than a year and his role is not just another role in a soapy drama - its everything from action which includes, martial arts, sword fighting horse riding and so much more to romance to comedy to emotions to patriotism and "he dint impress some rachna fans"..?!! - who watched what one or two epis and passed judgement that just the way they dint like FK, we dint like Rachna...right🤢 our analysis on rachna was purely whether she would suit ajab or not...but here people are critisizing an existing actor in MP!?? and that too Faisal???
we have watched faisal as pratap grow every day and today I can proudly say that he is a master class actor, a very talented boy and nearly flawless in his performance...and carried the show on his shoulders for so long and can easily give all the grown up actors a run for their money...

This is the limit yaar! 🤢 hadd hoti hai. I have always watched historicals, and by far MP is best in terms of everything. I agree I may have not been a regualr watcher, I had studies, and all, at that time, but Faisal was outstanding. You know, every actor takes time to get into the skin of the characters they are playing. Faisu, had to speak in shudh hindi, had to train his body so hard... worked day and night... and I could see him improving with in a month...! This is a kid we are talking about! But, of course, these are nor feats that can impress people, apparently tapkaoing annsu every dialogue is actually very hard to do.

chood na yaar Faisu has won hearts as a child, and everyone watching the show knows what he is worth.
phanita_21 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -JaanVi-




You don't like MP and you like RP ?
Don't degrade MP by writting such comments . He was a great freedom fighter /warrior . The least people can do it to watch his story get inspire by him . And this show have perfectly showed MP struggle and journey till now . How can someone be so blind in fandom of some actor ?


hi jaanvi:)
sorry if it wasn't ur name😕
i really appreciate wat u have said about our freedom fighter MAHARANA PRATAP..
personally i too dont watch historical dramas...
i dont want rachana to be in MP. n i also dont think she is degrading the magnanimous personality maharana pratap..
may be she doesn,t like the actor who is playing MP, everyone has their own likes n dislikes ...like how some people who dnt want RP as lead and want some fresh new face instead of her..



Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: atominis


This forum lost many members it had when it began. Now it will be oveturned even more. Serial has not seen any change yet but forum already gives me creeps with these fanbots who think any opinion is nothing but bashing!

We talk on basis of history and this show's early episodes not for fanship or hatred of certain actors!

I was looking forward to history discussions and sharing of info on historical and cultural events in future...related to MP and Rajputana but seeing these conditons, CVs choices and their own inclination towards drama than history I think I better get outta here before this place becomes unrecognisable.😕



@ Anu - I was wary of watching MP because just a few episodes of another historical 😉 put me off. In general I prefer shows on Sony so might give this one a watch.. .. and if you are on the forum, I am sure there are meaningful discussions on history and culture aplenty to read. That would be an interesting and enriching experience certainly.

How long has MP been on air and do I have a lot to catch up on, should I decide to watch?

General comment - who are these fanbots? Handful of Rachana fans?😆 Dont mind them please. They are by and large a fairly peaceful lot coming from a fairly peaceful forum reeling from her being thrown out of a show unfairly, saddened by the offscreen politics of that show and Rachu being discriminated by more or less the entire team based on the color of skin (one of the things) !!! Hence the sensitivity and the remarks. Its shocking that even in this day and age color of the skin can such a furor.

I am not familiar with this PH or MP CVs. Honestly, I dont remember much of what I learned about MP in school and I dont watch MP so could not give any opinions on whether SM or RP would suit the roles they are rumored to be considered for. We shall know soon who CVs finalized.


As viewers, we all dont have to like the same things. Difference of opinion is perfectly acceptable. Its the way the opinion is expressed that makes the difference. That is what I reacted to...


Nandy
Edited by Infofan - 11 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -JaanVi-



Thanks polo the truth just came out 😆.



Maybe some of the 'fandom' did watch. 😉
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
@jyotic and @poulomi
This forum is already looking unrecognisable! 😲 I agree they will make it saas bahu and love triangle. Show will be a mangled mess till battle of Haldighati comes up.🥺

@DayandNight

Hold it! Faisal is fantastic being a child actor and has more fierceness and command over language, litheness in doing stunts than many grown men. In fact he, Vishal and Dhruv (who played Shakti) look more regal and masculine than that melted chocolate Sharad who is now going to play "adult" Maharana Pratap!

Nobody wants Sanaya or Barun type actors but actors that SUIT the historical narrative and feel of that period. Rachna or Sharad don't even look Rajasthani!

Nobody bashed Rachna for her complexion. Rather Ajabde is supposed to be dusky only and it was said CVs just picked up any dusky girl they found. RP has no quality of Ajabde except dusky complexion.

But that statement was twisted to make it some war! You people first check the way you all are responding and twisting statements.

Trashing child actors isn't going to hide lack of suitability of adult actors. And who can trust this PH after they ruined Veer Shivaji with pathetic post leap casting? We didn't want same bad experience to repeat!

@Others

It is not replacement but matter of suitability. None of the reported adult actors fit in the historical profile. Nor are they a step ahead of existing adult and child cast.

This is our opinion on basis of what we read and watched till now. We too had hopes for accurate post leap handling of the show. Rather hoped it to be better as there is more material available on Maharana Pratap's adult life than childhood. But not anymore.

It is not about replacements. Don't know why people miss the simple point of "suitablity"!

Ajabde was around same age as MP. Not much younger. And MP wasn't a medium built choco boy with feeble voice! He was tall, rugged, well built. But CVs took much bulkier guy to play Akbar giving totally opposite casting.

Expectations are built on basis of historical accounts and not mere fandom.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
@Infofan
PH is Contiloe that earlier made shows like Jhansi ki rani, Veer Shivaji. MP has been on Sony since May last year. It is not like other historical. Better quality when it started which is why it won many awards and was praised by even current Maharana of Udaipur.

I have read about MP in books and folktales and read even more when this show started. Anyone who has watched this show from beginning or read MP's history is bound to have issues with casting.

I can see how peaceful the fans or fanbots are. Even their twisting of statements reflects a lot. Nobody bashed RP for her colour.

History is impossible to discuss given CVs ' decisions and style of responses by pankhas.

If a show couldn't even cast actors as per history then what history will it actually show...and what discussions can be done here if people think of everything from prism of fan war?


_Poulomi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
@atominis: I said it before, I will say it, again... "Bhais ke agey Bin bajana"
No matter who claims to have "read all comments" before commenting... just repeats the same thing over!😆

Ah, now i am bored.
Edited by _Poulomi_ - 11 years ago
Mayavi-26 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
well rachana will suit as ajab bcos ajab is dusky completion girl like JB and so rachana is also dusky completion and good actor 😛 they cant sign a white completion for this character so she can be good choice. but nothing is confirm yet
Edited by flamenco - 11 years ago
Joyness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
So perfectly summed up atominis...this leap..thing with such bad casting has already spelt doom...and faisu is one of the best actor period...rosh has brought ajab alive...and these new people who never watched MRP...are saying faisu can't act...oh god...please to go else where...i toh pray RP is not selected only
Edited by jyotic74 - 11 years ago
_Poulomi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
SM aur Nikitin se yaad, aya...
Akbar was supposed to be a small man compared to Pratap's huge structure. Nikitin Vs. Sharad? Nikitin had a huge body compared to Sharad. Its just role reversal.😲

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".