Too much negativity in this forum - Page 5

Originally posted by: astha36

I just want to say one thing to the author of this post. I don't know how many shows' forums have you been a part of, but in the few forums that I have been, it was clearly a norm to never make posts about other members of the forum. Any member is free to discuss the show, the characters, the actors because that's what this forum is for. But not for bashing or calling out other members in the forum. It is really unfortunate and distasteful.

Originally posted by: astha36

I just want to say one thing to the author of this post. I don't know how many shows' forums have you been a part of, but in the few forums that I have been, it was clearly a norm to never make posts about other members of the forum. Any member is free to discuss the show, the characters, the actors because that's what this forum is for. But not for bashing or calling out other members in the forum. It is really unfortunate and distasteful.

Originally posted by: Maharaani

It is even more unfortunate and distasteful that people are so biased in this forum...you hate an actor, you can criticize her acting skills

i think that is what me, vyoman and babita did when you were naming us , quoting us and runing behind us and now you are at it again...we will say what we want to say..lets see how you stop us...

Originally posted by: at118

I also want to say you something, even this is a rule to not bash any actor personally (pls go and read forum rules). but these members I named in this post, have not just called Shubhangi a C grade actor but lots of other derogatory remarks about her character, about her clothes etc etc. They called her cheap, vahiyat, half nude... Very surprising that you seem to have no issues with that but you are strictly against naming and shaming those who have actually used this language????

It is even more unfortunate and distasteful that people are so biased in this forum...you hate an actor, you can criticize her acting skills, her appearance in show in respectful language but why to stoop to this level of indecency???

Originally posted by: at118

Plain and complete Lie. Bunch of false lies... I had never ever questioned anything against any constructive criticism...

Oh really...you are the one complete liar...i have the proof...reproducing the page link and how you went behind us three when we said she is not acting well.

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4619064&TPN=5

I used to always say my say...not quote anyone , not name anyone and the attacks started and so you got bakc same eventually

see the page everyone and you will know...i have proof...against her lies

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

EXCERPTS FROM THE PAGE

it is her after us for saying acting is not good -

she begins by quoting me. with me..arey if I think someone acts bad...why are you after me??

I am okay with replacements...as long as the replacement acts convincingly...what I am talking about here is not a opposition to replacement but about the choosing of an incompetent actor as Angoori who cannot play the role well, so if someone else can and I do not feel like she is faking, then I am okay with it.

Fortunately, many of us would disagree with you on this. Many of us found Shubhangi very competent. so its your individual choice... she is playing the role quite well. and she is very decent actor.

Vyoman says -

It is also your individual choice...but fact is what Shilpa says is 100 pecent true...she has no originality and she copies shilpa like a clone...a copy cat cant be a good actor...may be you are unable to see that she has no originality and she copies shilpa's gestures even...even if some dialogues are angoori's gesture's are of original actress. she tries sex appeal to compensate for her lack of acting skills by exposing much.

@ blue

Absolutely agree...

Shubhangi is a fabulous actress. I have seen her in AKH recently and appreciated her work. But, unfortunately she is not suitable for Angoori. This is what I felt and I'm entitled to my opinion who have been seeing this show from day one and falling in love with this show very much. Coming back to her sex appeal and acting skills I don't understand why creatives are not taking much care about this ...I assume whatever creatives are telling she is doing...so it's not appealing...

and here she gets personal like one has and must say subhangi acts well

@Maharani, Babita, Vyoman-

Only time will tell whether new Angoori is doing her job perfectly or not. Going by the general opinion of people in this forum, it seems she is winning hearts except you 3, most of us appreciate her and her efforts.

and she says minority and all...ask babita and vyoman.

I say -

I appreciate substance, not superficiality, may be you are sold just by glamour...but we want good and convincing acting...we have no problem with clothes, but too revealing clothing means she tries to sell herself only by glamour because she has no acting capability and you tend to have no answer to her copying original actress's gestures even...anyway stop quoting us and answering us directly...we are not bothered abt u...we are entitled to our opinion...if you like her say so and just be off...and let us say that we do not like her acting...no need to run behind us becaue it wont change or opinion unless her acting improves. More people appreciate C grade movies and few Satyajit Ray's movies...but hat does not make the former better...so glamour is okay as long as it is not done to hide incapability in acting...glamour wont help copy cats.

Babita says -

From next time, stop quoting our names. Grow up U too

Vyoman says -

Exactly...Stop quoting names...if you don't like any comment then just ignore it...BTW I'm wondering you really read & understood my comment @ page No.4...just you need to grow up...not me...next time read and understand well before naming anyone for that matter...hope this time you will understand what i'm trying to say...

vyomanIF-Rockerz

-------------------------------------

This says how she attacks people and stalks them by calling them personally taking their names and quoting them...till that time we never spoke to her or mentioned her...time n again in my posts i have said i am not interested in her anyway and here in the forum to air my views

Edited by Maharaani - 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Maharaani

It's surprising that you don't seem to have an issue when shilpa shinde is being called a cow or liar among other indecent names. Why is this post then only about atre? It should have been a generic post, if you insist that the intention is to not name call any actor.

Exactly. Nobody jumps to attack when Shilpa gets bashed.

Originally posted by: Maharaani

Exactly same thing I was saying..I would have argued but have never used abusive language for anyone first...I named you all (@Maharani, Babita, Vyoman-

Only time will tell whether new Angoori is doing her job perfectly or not. Going by the general opinion of people in this forum, it seems she is winning hearts except you 3, most of us appreciate her and her efforts. ) but was that personal attack??? was that abusive??? where as I was subject to abusive language... was that fair???

It was my fault to just quote your names in this post first, but in return I got bunch of abusive language?? was that a good treatment to me???

Nevertheless... I want peace now and lets be friends... no point of going back and back and pointing out the things that can pick up fights...

so peace pls... and apologies from my side if inadvertently I have hurt anyone but I am not fool/mental or psycho as well 😊 pls understand..