Final verdict - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

4.3k

Users

13

Likes

146

Frequent Posters

MistyDawn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: PlainJane



I agree with you completely. Right now, everything is murky. We still don't know what happened exactly. But, both Ayan and Maya are far from innocent.

As for the episodes, I can only say that the courtroom scenes failed to impress me. No cross questioning.Prosecutor hardly said anything. The judge was like a cardboard. Petty name-calling and personal digs at each other. It was nasty and not in a good way. So, what now?

Arjun and Maya being mushy-mushy again...so not looking forward to that. 🤢

Samay and Maya (SaMaya) on the other hand. Now, that's something to be hopeful for.😳 I love their scenes together. Two very intriguing and eccentric characters. Their relationship dynamics is utterly unique. Simone Singh is entering the show...I hope its true and not a rumor. I like Simone Singh ever since I watched her in Being Cyrus. She was also in the Kabhi Khushi Kabhi Gham right? I wonder if she is positive or a negative character.


Courtroom scene was melodrama for 2 days. Today we were shown legit evidences- tampered or not that we can debate but I think they were not.While Saanjh's intention of presenting the case as frameup by Maya was right but she had no evidences to prove her theory in the case under investigation. Its surprising that she didn't go through the CCTV footage herself if we go by the shocked expression she gave when she actually saw it.. When prosecution lawyer said that Ayaan broke the cameras, Ayaan didn't deny Saanjh did.. How could Ayaan locate the cameras? Biggest mistake - how could Saanjh assume that Maya will not go for medical examination when she knew this was an attempt to rape case not a rape case unless she through Ayaan didn't even touch her.. How can Saanjh assume that Samay will not be summoned given the fact that he's the only eyewitness? The fact that she asked him to stay away which was openly brought out by the lawyer is also contempt of court because she tried to influence a key witness.

Maya is capable of anything - that's what we are made to believe so deep down we all will feel maybe she staged this.. that smile in the precap- creatives want to confuse us.. But some of the statements made by Maya and lawyer, like the one where she pointed out that every woman whether a corporate honcho or a house maker has a right on their body and their pride that no one can violate without their permission, not even their husbands.. Even a mad, bad, obsessed, freak of a woman has the right to decide who touches her.. THAT is the message I want to keep from this otherwise OTT court drama..

And yes Ayaan deserves punishment for his stupidity.. he is not innocent.. Maya felt threatened of rape that is debatable..but she has every right to get Ayaan punished for what he did..

Samay had once said that he is not anyone's friend or enemy..Samay only sees truth.. now he said Ayaan wasn't raping or trying to rape Maya but he didn't deny he was assaulting her.. so I will take his word on this case.. so looking forward to his scenes with Maya..
Edited by MistyDawn - 8 years ago
1005068 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12
There was a bite mark on Maya wrist, that can't be accidental. According to medical report all injuries was because of Ayan, that's why I think report was fake. But is it that easy to get a false report?? Ayan destroying camera should have raised an argument. Court drama was disappointing.
PlainJane thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: MistyDawn


Courtroom scene was melodrama for 2 days. Today we were shown legit evidences- tampered or not that we can debate but I think they were not.While Saanjh's intention of presenting the case as frameup by Maya was right but she had no evidences to prove her theory in the case under investigation. Its surprising that she didn't go through the CCTV footage herself if we go by the shocked expression she gave when she actually saw it.. When prosecution lawyer said that Ayaan broke the cameras, Ayaan didn't deny Saanjh did.. How could Ayaan locate the cameras? Biggest mistake - how could Saanjh assume that Maya will not go for medical examination when she knew this was an attempt to rape case not a rape case unless she through Ayaan didn't even touch her.. How can Saanjh assume that Samay will not be summoned given the fact that he's the only eyewitness? The fact that she asked him to stay away which was openly brought out by the lawyer is also contempt of court because she tried to influence a key witness.

Maya is capable of anything - that's what we are made to believe so deep down we all will feel maybe she staged this.. that smile in the precap- creatives want to confuse us.. But some of the statements made by Maya and lawyer, like the one where she pointed out that every woman whether a corporate honcho or a house maker has a right on their body and their pride that no one can violate without their permission, not even their husbands.. Even a mad, bad, obsessed, freak of a woman has the right to decide who touches her.. THAT is the message I want to keep from this otherwise OTT court drama..

And yes Ayaan deserves punishment for his stupidity.. he is not innocent.. Maya felt threatened of rape that is debatable..but she has every right to get Ayaan punished for what he did..

Samay had once said that he is not anyone's friend or enemy..Samay only sees truth.. now he said Ayaan wasn't raping or trying to rape Maya but he didn't deny he was assaulting her.. so I will take his word on this case.. so looking forward to his scenes with Maya..


@blue: Yeah...that was a good message.
@red: Wow! Yes, he did say that. I am with you on this score and take his word for it. Besides, I have always believed that Ayan did assault her. Intention doesn't matter, action does.
1005068 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
Also, if Janvi was at home, there had to be some security or atleast one person for her. She can't live alone.
Edited by soumya04 - 8 years ago
MistyDawn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: soumya04

There was a bite mark on Maya wrist, that can't be accidental. According to medical report all injuries was because of Ayan, that's why I think report was fake. But is it that easy to get a false report?? Ayan destroying camera should have raised an argument. Court drama was disappointing.


Things will get clearer next week. As of now, Ayaan's DNA matched with the tissue samples they got from the wounds and we have to go with that. If Ayaan is confident of his innocence in this matter, Saanjh can challenge the medical reports and ask for re-examination from an independent forensic lab. Saanjh was ill prepared for this case from evidence point of view. Her entire case was based on theory and perceptions.. Weirdly, in the courtroom drama we all were laughing on the prosecution lawyer but he came across as both well prepared and professional .. he spoke to the point without getting personal and OTT.. even when he took a jibe at Saanjh for being inexperienced it actually sounded like a sound advice a senior would give to his junior.. didn't appear like mocking her..compare that to Saanjh, who was like Arrreyyy sirrr! very cocky and totally unnecessary..
1005068 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: MistyDawn


Things will get clearer next week. As of now, Ayaan's DNA matched with the tissue samples they got from the wounds and we have to go with that. If Ayaan is confident of his innocence in this matter, Saanjh can challenge the medical reports and ask for re-examination from an independent forensic lab. Saanjh was ill prepared for this case from evidence point of view. Her entire case was based on theory and perceptions.. Weirdly, in the courtroom drama we all were laughing on the prosecution lawyer but he came across as both well prepared and professional .. he spoke to the point without getting personal and OTT.. even when he took a jibe at Saanjh for being inexperienced it actually sounded like a sound advice a senior would give to his junior.. didn't appear like mocking her..compare that to Saanjh, who was like Arrreyyy sirrr! very cocky and totally unnecessary..

how will they re-examine?? They can't examine Maya again for proof. If report was fake, it will be difficult to prove.
MistyDawn thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: soumya04

how will they re-examine?? They can't examine Maya again for proof. If report was fake, it will be difficult to prove.


They have Maya's tissue samples and Ayaan's too..they do the tests in vitro not in vivo..
sunithi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
Well written post 👏

priyanka... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: devil_heart

arjun is duffer

he will pay for his foolishness
he deserve what maya will do to him now
I think ayan will commit suicide
he won't be able to face this humilation now


No No.. Ayaan should not die.. Why he should die for someone else's crime. He needs to come strong now and prove his innocence. And about Arjun, after all this, he doesn't deserve his family. Yes, he will pay for his foolishness.
Fernandes43 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: priyankazzz


No No.. Ayaan should not die.. Why he should die for someone else's crime. He needs to come strong now and prove his innocence. And about Arjun, after all this, he doesn't deserve his family. Yes, he will pay for his foolishness.

We don't know if this track will continue or not!
If it continues, an appeal to higher court, a bail application pending appeal , an emergnce of new-found evidence, a change of heart or U-turn from Arjun, a possible deal between Maya & Arjun to withdraw complaint under certain conditions are just some possiblities come to one's mind!
Ayaan need not give-up hope! Not yet!
Edited by Fernandes43 - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".