The day Ayan's truth will be out-GUILTY/NOT GUILTY OF RAPE ATTEMPT - Page 4

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

@anshvi

Beautifully put. Totally agree with your views...It isn't about hypocrisy or about hating Maya or about loving Saanjh...I m as neutral a viewer as you are, n I have always only tried to interpret the storyline as shown, n then tried to predict what the CVs intend to show, by picking on the clues which they intentionally or unintentionally drop along the way...😊

Originally posted by: anshvi

Physical assault - Yes Ayan is guilty of that

Rape attempt - Nope he is not guilty

The thing is BEYHADH is a story about Maya's beyhadh love for which she can go to any extent- the tagline itself says - HADH SE ZYADA KUCH BHI ACCHA NAHI HOTA - PYAR BHI

Maya has put rape allegations on Ayan to separate Arjun from Ayaan and his family. SHE WILL GO TO ANY EXTENT FOR HER LOVE...Isn't this the entire concept of this show?

If we think logically then Maya has framed Ayan in the rape case..I think we will hear Ayaan's side of the story too in the upcoming episodes...what Ayaan did - physical assault , tearing Maya's sleeves is Absolutely wrong.

But Maya putting false allegations on him is also wrong.

Those who think Maya is telling the truth and Ayaan did attempt rape then what is the story...Maya trying to seek justice for herself with help of Arjun ?

Then what ?

M not sure if this is the story...it is a dark thriller about a woman whose love knows no bounds and she will go to any extent to keep her love.

AYaan definitely should be punished for physical assault but not for rape attempt coz he did not do it is what I think.

And I am saying this as a neutral viewer coz neither I am a Maya nor a Saanjh fan

I watch this show for it's unique concept and real characters who are not WHITE BUT FLAWED !

Also Arjun is supporting Maya and fair enough she is a woman and his wife and Arjun is right no woman will lie about a sensitive issue like rape

But we also have to understand that Maya is not any ordinary woman...she can tie her husband , drug him and can hit herself, can try to commit suicide as well.

Arjun must hear Ayaan's side of the story too and then come to a conclusion.

He must try to examine everything coz this is a very sensitive matter...one should he totally unbiased when it comes to cases like these...coz Maya and Ayan both lives are at stake...but one of them is lying and the other is innocent.

I am excited to watch the future episodes. I am not sure what will be the final judgement of the case..let's see.

And yes if Maya indeed is proven right and Ayaan did attempt rape then he deserves a severe punishment and I will not back out in condemning him.

But if we go as per the theme of Beyadh then Maya would have put false allegations on Ayaan and if this is the case then she also deserves punishment but more than that psychological counseling.

We all will have to wait for the story to unfold

Let's wait and watch

THIS!

You have pretty much summed up why it's difficult to believe that Maya is the victim here. This is a story about what she can do and to which extent she can go. Not how she fights her rapist. It's unfortunate & insensitive that the "auraat hi auraat ka dushman" cliche is being wielded here in the forum to guilt-trip people but the fact remains what you just said.
If the CVs want to turn 180 degrees and show Maya to be yet another victim, then yeah Ayaan deserves punishment. But so far no such indication. It's sad enough that a fake rape case has to be incorporated in the serial, for rape is a very sentivie isse and should not be played around with. However, Let's not go all radical feminist on viewers for seeing the different side of the coin.

Originally posted by: ishakumar

This is the beyhadh hypocrisy of this forum! 👏
Had it been Saanjh everyone would've bombarded ayaan with curses!

@ ILZM - I am not at all trivializing suicide. Maya might have suicidal tendencies but she also uses that to get whatever she wants.
Nope Maya accusing Ayaan of rape & hurling accusations at Arjun is her drama , not the assault part. I think people are much senstivie towards Maya, even though she's pretty much a character with black traits more than white traits. Everybody sympathizes with her childhood trauma and wants her to get healed. If pointing out her crimes are being insensitive, then I donno what to say. All criminals should be shown mercy for having disturbed childhood and mental unstability.
@Isha - you guys are no less obsessed with Sanjh. 😆 Even if there were no Sanjh in the show, my opnion would have remained the same. I knowing saying all these will go in vain but for the last time, if you wanna debate, come up with better arguments.

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

N y is it 57 % exactly?😆

I had only this no. in mind!😆

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

Sorry, wrong thread.

Ok...so who has to say what today??????😆

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

Ok...so who has to say what today??????😆

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

Ok...so who has to say what today??????😆

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

Ok...so who has to say what today??????😆

So ayaan is innocent it's full of maya plan and saanjh is right.